Ah,
Stealth old chap, we hadnt been debating this for some 2 years, so to bring it back up is confusing to say the least.
Etiquette suggests that it is bad form to re-open old threads that have remained dormant for so long, unless there is genuine new information that can be offered. I dont think that has been the case with your post, no matter how well intentioned.
As I dont think there is anything else to add, I am now closing the thread.
Bruce (Moderator)