dark light

  • Geforce

Future for the British/Spanish gov`t

Short may resign over Iraq
Clare Short has told BBC News she will resign from the government if Britain goes to war against Iraq without United Nations backing.
The international development secretary told BBC Radio 4’s Westminster Hour she could not “stay and defend the indefensible”.

“If there is not UN authority for military action or the reconstruction of the country, I will not uphold a breach of international law or this undermining of the UN,” she told the programme.

“I will resign from the government,” said Ms Short, who described Tony Blair’s actions as “reckless”.

Downing Street expressed surprise at Ms Short’s comments, with a spokesman insisting she had not expressed such views before to the prime minister.

Wrong forum?

Home Office Minister Beverley Hughes said she was surprised by Ms Short’s comments, which she argued should have been discussed with cabinet colleagues instead of on the airwaves.

Ms Hughes told BBC Radio 4’s Today programme: “At a time of critical importance, when everybody, including the government, wants to get a second resolution, it is surprising to have a cabinet minister expressing her views on the radio, not to the prime minister and her colleagues round the cabinet table.”

Britain, the US and Spain have put forward a draft resolution to the UN which sets a deadline of 17 March for Baghdad to disarm.

Our failure to use our influence properly is so dangerous for the world
Clare Short

Downing Street insists that it is confident the Security Council will back the draft resolution in a vote, which is now likely to take place later in the week.

The UK and US are already planning concessions including agreement to table a list of specific demands on disarmament that Saddam Hussein must meet if he is to avoid a war.

It is also possible that the 17 March deadline for compliance by Baghdad could be extended.

Mr Blair spent Sunday at his Chequers official country residence, engaged in an intensive round of telephone diplomacy over the deadline idea.

‘Bad atmosphere’

But Ms Short, who resigned over Labour’s support for the last Gulf War, said she was surprised at Tony Blair’s “extraordinarily reckless” stance.

“The whole atmosphere of the current situation is deeply reckless – reckless for the world, reckless for the undermining of the UN in this disorderly world, reckless with our government, reckless with his own future, position and place in history.”

Ms Short said she had raised her objections in frequent detailed discussions with both the prime minister and foreign secretary Jack Straw

AIDES ‘THREATENING TO RESIGN’
Cambridge MP Anne Campbell, PPS to Trade and Industry Secretary Patricia Hewitt
Michael Jabez Foster, PPS to Lord Goldsmith, the attorney general
Great Yarmouth MP Tony Wright, PPS to Ruth Kelly, the Treasury minister.

“People like me are being told, ‘Yes, all this is under consideration’,” she said
“And then the spin the next day is, ‘We are ready for war’.”

It was time to put her “cards on the table” and reveal her intentions, Ms Short added.

“I feel the need now, because it is 10 minutes to midnight, to say out loud what I think Britain should do with its influence – because our failure to use our influence properly is so dangerous for the world,” Ms Short said.

“We are undermining the UN,” she added.

“Allowing the world to be so bitterly divided – the division in Europe, the sense of anger and injustice in the Middle East – is very, very dangerous,” Ms Short told Westminster Hour.

“It is a recruiting sergeant for terrorism.”

Blair’s surprise

BBC political correspondent John Pienaar said Ms Short’s threat had come as a surprise to Downing Street.

“She isn’t just laying down this ultimatum, she is accusing Number 10 of reverting to old habits of spin, saying one thing in private and another thing in public.”

Earlier on Sunday Loughborough MP Andy Reed announced he was quitting as parliamentary aide to environment secretary Margaret Beckett.

Three other parliamentary private secretaries – MPs who work as assistants to ministers – have publicly indicated they also would step down if action was taken without a new UN resolution.

——————————————————–

With ministers threatening to resign from Blair`s gov`t, Labour-MP`s who are not backing their own gov`t, is it possible for this administration to survive untill the next elections? 85 % of the Britons are against unilateral actions against Iraq without approval of the Security Council. Wheter you like Tony or not (I always thought of him as an inspiring example of how a good PM should be, especially his vision on what the EU should become eventually), you have to agree that this was probably the most reckless thing he could ever do.

In Spain, there`s even a bigger opposition than in the UK. Actually I don`t understand why Spain is so pro-War. I`ve always thought of Spain as a pro-European progressive country. Ofcourse, I`m fully aware that the Spanish gov`t doesn`t represent the people at all, for which they`ll be punished next elections.

Member for:

19 years 1 month

Posts:

2,805

Send private message

By: Geforce - 10th March 2003 at 23:31

Own opinion? We`ll see next elections, my dear friend. There`s a reason why so many people marched in the streets of Madrid a couple of weeks ago, and believe me, not all of them were tree-hugging pacifists.

Member for:

19 years 1 month

Posts:

546

Send private message

By: BME330 - 10th March 2003 at 23:11

There are so many shames…

The shame is that our french “allies” are selling us terrorists like cattle (but extremly more expensive), we bought terrorists with the Super Pumas deal, we bought terrorists with the Cougar deal, we bought terrorists with the Mistral deal, wow we love that “help”…. even with the conflict with Morocco we saw in wich side is our northern “allie”

Firstly some newspapers said that more than the 90% of the population was against the war, after that the number was 85%…after that the 80%….the same journalists that are telling us that the PdA can launch 8 SSM Harpoon….real experts, for sure…

We don´t need that frenchs or germans speak for us, it´s so simple….at least for one time we had our own opinion

Member for:

19 years 1 month

Posts:

1,900

Send private message

By: keltic - 10th March 2003 at 19:59

Aznar, as a deep disgrace and shame for Spain, will be sent to the dustbin of history (his party) as soon as elections be held. 85% says NO under any ciscunstance. We don´t have any gratitude to the US, they didn´t save us from Hitler and didn´t pay us any attention when living more than forty years in ditatorship. But the Spanish people, is absolutely upset with Aznar (he doesn´t care, since he´s leaving next term) is his cheap eurosceptism, in such a euro enthusizast country. There´s some hints:
-He´s supposely blackmailed by the US…..Ceuta and Melilla, the US contention of Morocco.
-CIA, cooperation against ETA.
-Support for the location of the ultra modern cold nuclear reactor
-Entrace of Spain in the G8
These are some explanations, but I am affraid he´s so ignorant that prefers the usual sumiss and begging position of Spain to the US. Shameful. He talks in a very mesianic way, setting himself in the Olympus, and talking if he received holly relevelations of God and as White House puppet (he repeats the same stuff). The rest of the politicians, from Aznar party, keep quiet and adore his leader as in the Bulgarian comunist democracy. I really congratulate the labour party for being able to have such a lively debate in the party, not our dull officials, who are paid by the citizens to serve us, choose loyalty to their salaries instead to their compromise of a country which says…NO.

Member for:

19 years 1 month

Posts:

1,317

Send private message

By: Rabie - 10th March 2003 at 13:45

she is in the gov as a sopmto the left wing – dosne’t matter one bit if she leaves

rabie 😉

Member for:

19 years 1 month

Posts:

19,065

Send private message

By: Moggy C - 10th March 2003 at 10:24

Re: Future for the British/Spanish gov`t

Originally posted by Geforce
Short may resign over Iraq

Ah well, some good will come from the war at least.

Personally I’m a bit tired of the whingeing and whining of the pinko-liberal fringe who seem lined up to support the continued rule of a mass killer and then think they are taking some kind of moral high ground.

Loose figures are chucked into the argument as if they were truth “85 % of the Britons are against unilateral actions against Iraq without approval of the Security Council” Where’d that come from? I’ve seen a welter of different figures, why believe that one?

Come on guys, let’s get in and get it over with. All this self-indulgent introspection does nothing but offer succour to the killer, torturer, oppressor of many thousands of his own and other countries’s citizens. There’s a job needs doing.

I often wonder how the conscientious objectors in the UK during WW2 felt when they saw the Pathe News films from Belsen and Auchswitz.

Moggy
A member of the 15% +
And proud of it

Sign in to post a reply