Home › Forums › Modern Military Aviation › Missiles and Munitions › BVR : RF missiles vs ECM › Reply To: BVR : RF missiles vs ECM
I have been looking into the eternal fight in between RF missiles and Fighters ‘s ECMs .
There is a lot of infos on the open Net , including some rather interesting studies but the problem is to find enough data on the latest ECCM techniques used by missiles like Amraam , Mica , R-77 .
These missiles are all using some kind of mono-static multipulse radar .
Latest ECMs must use some kind of Digital Radio Frequency Memory (DRFM) techniques to try to fool the incoming missile(s) .
From the Net :
http://img607.imageshack.us/img607/5578/phaseshift.jpg
Of course , the defender must first detect the missile ‘s radar but this is not a problem nowadays if the RWR is up to speed .
When the missile goes “active” , the fight missile-ECM begins .
Missiles like late Amraams and Mica are using some very clever tricks (ECCM) to try to “resist” the deceptive jamming , but how ?Here , I wanted to explain by myself how it is done until I found an excellent post from a guy called Gambit . Since his explainations are tip top , I decided to copy/paste what he said . If he ‘s reading , I thank him 🙂
Here is what he said :(Thank you again Mr. Gambit)
Now , the DRFM capabilities have increased tenfold the past 10 years to the point that missiles have very little chance against powerful ECMs .
Missile ‘s radar usualy use the X band (8-12 Ghz) , very few are using K (12-18 Ghz) , Ka (18-24 Ghz) or even Ku (24-40 Ghz) bands .
(it is the reason why ECM suite like Spectra are going up to 40 Ghz) .It has been said that some ECM suite like Typhoon ‘s Praetorian are capable to listen simultaneously the whole range of X band while sampling at up to 300-500 Mhz . Spectra sampling seems to be 500-700 Mhz .
Thalès Carbone system does even better and it seems that the sampling is up to 2 Ghz but this is classified .
Sampling rate is usualy 10 to 12 bits with a resolution comprised in between 2 and 0.5 nanoseconds (!) with Up to 4 independent and coordinated range, Doppler, amplitude target returns per DRFM channel .
What I don ‘t know is how many DRFM channels are used in systems like Praetorian and Spectra . Since Spectra is using multiple Bragg cells channelizers which are even faster because it is optical devices and it uses less filtering (more efficient) , it is even harder to guess how fast the system can duplicate the pulse-train and how many pulse-trains can be treated simultaneously .More I think about it , more I think that missile ‘s radars are easy fooled by such ECM suites .
So , RF (EM) missiles should have a very low pk .
This is the reason why medium to long range IR missile (Mica) are probably the best way to deal with top range fighters , especialy stealthy ones .As I said many times , it is not because a EM missile has been fired that the target will get destroyed . Even a salvo of said missiles can be fooled .
What do you think ?
Cheers .
Interesting post Bluewings, thanks.
Do you have a link to Gambit’s original post?