I’ve never said my photos are perfect. They certainly aren’t ! You’ve obviously just started posting your photos on airliners an JP judging by your comments on other people’s shots (they are screeners comments !)

There are no rules with photography – a photo looks good or it doesn’t – it’s an emotional thing – like music. Obviously a decent shot has to have basic stuff correct such as sharpish focus and light but the other stuff that you mention is just criteria set by JP and airliners to get a photo accepted on their site.

You mentioned aspect ratio not being 3:2 and change it ??? This is the point I am making – people can have what aspect ratio they like – is it wrong because it won’t get accepted by those sites ?

You say comments such as “wow great shots”, “great catch” or whatever are useless ? No they aren’t – we are not entering these photos into a competition – we are just sharing our recent trips and local airport visits.