July 11, 2004 at 12:50 am
It’s taken me a while to get round to typing this one up, but I figured that this particular story might be of interest, and possibly of use in a kind of “I made the mistakes, so that you don’t have to” kind of way…
Anyway, last week, I promised SWMBO that I’d take her to France for lunch. It would also be her first time coming up with me, but I was happy and confident about it bearing in mind JN-4 had been my guinea pig last weekend, and the club were happy for me to plan and execute the trip. So, on Wednesday night, Catherine and I planned the flight from Cambridge to Calais. Well, I planned it while she ate my food and drank my wine…
Weather during the night was pretty horrendous, but Thursday dawned bright, if rather breezy. After downloading the Met, I estimated we’d have a 50-50 chance of going, but if the France trip was off, we’d have a decent chance of at least getting a short local flight done as a consolation. So off we went to Cambridge.
Arrive at Cambridge, to be told by Trev that the weather in the channel is shockingly bad. So bad even the gulls are taking Eurostar.
So it’s plan B time.
I’ve got July’s ‘Pilot’ magazine as a backup. With free landing fee vouchers for Old Buckenham and Leicester. We decide on Leicester. Or rather, Catherine decides on Leicester, on the basis that they serve food on a Thursday. So I rapidly plan Cambridge Leicester, using Sierra Foxtrot as she’s the PPL aeroplane. Bad news though – SF got hurt a few days before when someone landed her awkwardly, and so she’s over at Little Staughton being mended. We’ve got to take dear old Whiskey Bravo instead. Different aeroplane, different speeds, different wind and drift calcs… all of which takes a while, and I’m a bit conscious that Catherine’s possibly getting a bit bored.
But, I get it all sorted, brief Catherine (who struggles not to laugh at the unprecedented sight and sound of me being serious), we don the canary jackets (to mock mild indignance from C), and off we go. Preflight the aeroplane, carry out the internal checks, key in, “CLEAR PROP!”… and all we get is a loud grinding noise from up front – the starter motor’s engaging, but the engine isn’t turning, and neither’s the prop.
Switch off, breathe, count to ten, run through the start up procedure again… same thing happens. Oh dear. I switch off, tell C to stay put, and off I go to get Trev. He takes a look, and discovers the starter motor shaft has sheered. Whiskey Bravo ain’t going anywhere. We ain’t flying.
But then Trev suggests plan C. Sierra Fox is due to be ready today; he’ll make a call, and if she’s ready, he’ll fly us over there in the 182, we’ll pick up Sierra Fox, and be off on our merry way. Catherine and I gather up our kit while Trev makes the call, and it’s a go! Fabulous news, the day is saved! Sierra Fox is airworthy and can be collected, so C and I pile into the 182, and Trev flies us over to Staughton. As we depart, I’m aware of the sky to the south getting darker, but that’s okay, as it’s forecast to pass by the time we’ve been where we’re going. What I don’t realise at this point, is that we got out of Cambridge ten minutes before a major cumulonimbus unloads right overhead and shuts the airport.
We land at Staughton, park the 182 at the end of the runway, and get out. Trev and I are going to walk over to Colton’s, pick up SF, and taxi her back. We tell C to sit tight at the 182, we’ll be back in a minute. Thirty minutes later, we taxi SF up to the 182. Catherine doesn’t mind too much, she actually found half an hour sitting by herself next to an aeroplane in a field quite tranquil. Which earns her a few brownie points in itself. 😉
However, we now know about the weather at Cambridge, and Trev knows he has to sit tight with the 182 until Cambridge phone him and say the airport’s open again. Meanwhile, the clag’s on it’s way to Staughton, so C and I had better get cracking. I’ve preflighted SF, so we get in, taxi out, and go. Fuel’s only about an hour’s worth, but there are no refuelling facilities we can use at Staughton, so Trev tells me to fuel up at Leicester, and he’ll reimburse me. Leicester’s 25 minutes away, so I’m happy that we’ve got enough to go. Climbing turn out of Staughton to avoid the mast (!), and off we head for Leicester. We’ve beaten the weather!
For now.
Everything goes swimmingly well, we track slightly north so as to get onto the track I’d pre-planned from Cambridge, but then approaching Corby, the sky turns grey. Very grey. The clouds get lower, and suddenly our clear air at 2500 feet is a wall of cloud and rain, and before I can even think about avoiding it, we’re slap in the middle of it. Hell, this isn’t in the plan! Carb heat on, power back to 1800, bank left, nose forward, and down we come to 1500 feet. We’re lower than I want to be, but just scraping our rudder against the underside of the cloud. As I look to the west, it’s looking even lower.
I call Leicester, ask what their weather is. Cloudbase 700 feet, light rain, and the runway in use is 04, their shortest runway. Suddenly I’m not entirely sure that we’ll get in. And I’ve got another dilemma; my fuel is low. VERY low. We had an hour’s fuel when we left Staughton. I reckon we’re now down to 45 mins. I need to get us down and refueled, quickly. Look at the map; Sywell. But that’s grass, it’s raining there, and hell! I don’t have my Pooleys approach plate for Sywell in the kneeboard. There’s no fuel at Staughton, we can’t go back to Cambridge because that’s closed…
All of a sudden, we’re running out of options. And fuel. Suddenly a bit of inspiration – Peterborough Conington might still be open; it’s twenty miles to the east of us. I don’t have the approach plate for that either, but I do have their frequency, and I remember what the runway is like; I flew from there in 1990 I call Leicester again; tell them that given their weather, I’m diverting and calling Conington.
The cloudbase is getting lower. We’re now dragging our rudder through the muck at 1200 feet, slightly east of Corby. This is not good. Got to be careful about Cottesmore MATZ to the north too. A mile away to our south, an RAF Hercules trundles past at 1000 feet. This sky is getting very small. I’m nervous, but having to remain outwardly calm. Don’t want to freak Catherine (but she’s still happily taking pictures of fields anyway and so can’t see the beads of sweat on my brow.
Then suddenly we’re out from under the cloud; great, a bit more visibility. We’re overhead Oundle, ten miles to Conington. Call them up… fab, they answer. Runway in use is 10, right hand circuit, no other traffic. The sky is getting lighter. I can see Conington, we climb to 2000 to join, then descend deadside, fly the circuit, approach, and land. Then fifty yards later we land again. “Ha!” says I, probably more out of relief than genuine humour, “There you go girl, with me, you get two landings for the price of one!”
We taxi in, park up in an impossibly tight space, inch perfect, shut it down and get out. I’m drenched in sweat, but Catherine’s fine, shows no signs of having been apprehensive. She’s either utterly oblivious, or I kept the fear hidden. Besides, she’s starving, needs her lunch poor girl. So we wander in, pay the landing fee, get C sorted with Pastie and Chips.
Weather out west is grey and horrible. That’s where we’ve just come from. Conington ask me how low it was. I tell them. They’re amazed we were out there. So am I. We eat, sit, and in C’s case, stretch out in the sunshine (where the hell did THAT come from, we wonder?) while I help get the aeroplane fuelled. I call Cambridge, they’re open again, but with light rain clearing, and a very wet runway. Not ideal, but after surviving a wall of clag over Corby, I reckon we can do light rain. If all else fails, we’ll go into Bourn, call it a day, and get Trev to drive over and collect us.
So we go out to SF, preflight her, get in, get started and hell! There’s a flash of forked lightning out to our east. I’d just spoken to Cambridge ten minutes before, and they told me the weather was clearing directly north. I look again, and it does look as if the clag is slightly to the north of Cambridge and ten miles to the east of us. I’ve dodged one bullet already today, do I chance it? I look to the south, that’s clear. Maybe, just maybe, we can get up, depart due south, and skirt round the clag, hoping to find a clear gap leading to Cambridge… We give it a go. Climb out of Conington on full power, climbing turn to the south as another bolt of forked comes down a few miles to the east. Quick call to Conington to say we’re changing to Wyton, and thanks for the help guys. A nice bunch.
Wyton are silent. I don’t want to bust their zone, but I can’t climb above the required 2000 feet due to cloud. I make blind calls, and skirt round past Wyton at 1600. Suddenly, the sky gets lighter…. and we’re out from under the cloud! The sky to the south is a mixture of clear blue, and broken white clouds at 4000 feet. And from here I can even see Cambridge, we’ve done it! I call Cambridge approach, and we get a straight in clearance for runway 23. Right base join, non-standard approach, but we’re down. Another ‘two-for-the-price-of-one’ landing, and I daren’t touch the brakes because of all the surface water on the runway, but we’re back safely. We taxi in, park up, tie the aeroplane down, and in we go.
Cambridge has never looked quite so lovely. I’m utterly drained. On the way home we stop at a pub for a beer and a sit down, and I nearly fall asleep. And then at work on Friday morning, I found myself drifting off into quiet contemplation, reproaching myself over mistakes made and trying to make sense of the lessons learned.
So, what lessons have I learned?
One – do not deviate from a plan at short notice with re-planning thoroughly.
Two – fuel, fuel, fuel, fuel!
Three – always plan a diversion AND carry the airfield approach plates.
Four – phone the destination airfield before departure to get their actual weather.
Five – if it looks horrible up there, it probably is. Stay down here.
So Cambridge to Calais, turned into Cambridge to Leicester, then Little Staughton to Leicester, and finally Little Staughton to Conington. In horrible weather. And an aeroplane with not much fuel. And instead of Croissants in Calais, I treated Catherine to Pastie and Chips at Peterborough. I sure know how to show a girl a good time. But amazingly she tells me she had a great day, and wants to come with me when I attempt Calais again later this month. She’s a strange girl, but with that attitude, I could get quite attached to her. 😉
One final footnote, I really can’t praise or thank the folks at Flying Club Conington highly enough. A marvellously friendly bunch, who rustle up a cracking pastie and chips. Go and visit them, and if you buy enough of their fuel and ask them nicely, they might even let you off the landing fee. 😉
By: Melvyn Hiscock - 22nd July 2004 at 22:44
Yeah, what he said.
Now get down to Popham sometime.
Watch out for B-52s though . . .
Melv
By: YakRider - 22nd July 2004 at 22:38
Glad you got there at last and missed the nuclear power station too! Can hear the thunder as I’m typing this in.
Here’s to more days out in France, Belgium, Hollland, Germany…
YR
By: Arabella-Cox - 22nd July 2004 at 21:14
A happy ending…
Well, all good (?) stories have to have a happy ending, and I’m delighted to report that there’s one here too.
Today, G-MASF, Catherine and I all managed to make it to Calais in one piece. And back again. And Catherine’s STILL talking to me. Guess I must have done something right.
Here’s the happy trio. Ahhhhhhhh….. 😀
By: Steph - 13th July 2004 at 11:15
Steve, thanks for the great post! It was a good read and resonnates of all sorts of similar experiences I guess we all had at some point, fortunately with a happy outcome.
Just on the “oblivious” passenger side, I can’t help but agreeing that this is a strange but precious fact sometimes that they don’t realise we are struggling a bit 😉
Like the first time I got cought in some rain and had to turn back to actually land in that rain. I had a first time passenger who was delighted because it was really pretty, especially the rainbow all around the propeller as we landed. My vision of it was a difficult landing in the rain with the sun dazzling me on final. Didn’t get to see the rainbow!
Cheers,
Steph, off to Egypt in a few days YEAH!
By: John C - 12th July 2004 at 09:03
She Who Must Be Obeyed
Ancient Rider Haggard story, and 60’s film, with Ursula Andress
To be fair I should have said “introduced” as I’ve nicked it from another forum :p
Nice writing btw Steve – should have said that first time around 🙂
John C
wondering where the weekend went
By: Bigglesworth - 11th July 2004 at 23:37
Sounds like an interesting trip Steve, in marginal conditions. I’ve flown out of Staughton once, that aerial makes an interesting landmark for sure. I (and I’m sure many others) enjoy(?) hearing about these experiences and hopefully learn from them. Connington has changed much in the time since I worked there for a summer job (15 years ago!), I must pay a visit again.
The fact remains clear file IFR or don’t fly.
If your not IR rated do not fly if the weather is below the minimums or you think it will soon be that very case.
Then again “One will learn from his own mistakes, then he will become human.”
But the flight sounded intresting. Skud run, an American aviation term I understand used in the King maunuals.
Oh dear ‘R’, go back and read it again….
Then again “One will learn from his own mistakes, then he will become human.
Hasn’t worked in your case, has it.
By: macky42 - 11th July 2004 at 21:57
She Who Must Be Obeyed
Ancient Rider Haggard story, and 60’s film, with Ursula Andress.
Steve, a great ILAFFT story.
By: Arabella-Cox - 11th July 2004 at 21:56
am I resonsible for this particular acronym?
You are indeed. It works well when referring to Catherine. 😉
Moggy / Propstrike / YR – thanks very much for the comments guys. After a few days of reflection, I can see now where I went wrong, and hopefully how not to do it again.
Moggy, in particular I’ve taken on board your point about scud running; seeing that Herc pop out of the muck a mile ahead of me was a bit of a worry, at least by getting a bit of distance between me and the cloudbase I’ll be able to give myself a fighting chance of avoiding other aeroplanes next time. Not that I intend to go through Thursday’s fun and games again in a hurry…
By: John C - 11th July 2004 at 21:49
I promised SWMBO
Was this in use before I arrived or am I resonsible for this particular acronym?
John C
This weekend I have mostly been teaching myself plastering.
By: Propstrike - 11th July 2004 at 21:35
Great account Steve, I think most of us have had moments like that, and hopefully learnt from them. The funny thing about areas of bad weather is the way that they seem to suck you in.
You can often see quite distinctive cells of rain and general nastiness, and though you adjust your track to go past, you suddenly find you are in it, having completely missed the imminently approaching phase. I suppose it is because they are moving too, and the very outer edges are so wispy that they do not stand out from the main body of the cell.
It has been an odd few weeks for us aviators, with a bit of rain almost every day. That said though, the vis has been really good for ages, and I don’t recall any hazy inversions for quite a while. A bit of settled weather would be nice.
By: YakRider - 11th July 2004 at 08:12
Good post. Lots to learn from here. Glad it all turned out well and that your passenger enjoyed her trip!
We’ve all been in this situation at one time or another. I can remember being a passenger in a 172 on a trip to Bournemouth. Lovely trip in bright sunshine and excellent visability until we got to Hengistbury Head. Solent Approach had passed us over to Bournemouth and we we given a left base join for 26.
It was then that we hit a front coming through. Visibility rapidly deteriorated, but the pilot had an IMC, so could fly the procedure. Then they told us to orbit because the Coast Guard Sikorsky was doing a procedural approach too. The gusting winds made life very bumpy.
We were then cleared to continue the approach. We saw the runway through the gloom and rain. Then I looked at the compass and realised we had become disorientated as we were heading about 270 and the runway was at the wrong angle. We were heading for the old cross runway which is now a taxiway. It’s a good job we didn’t try to land on it, there was a 747 parked there! (I’ve done that before too, at Norwich. You see a runway and assume its the right one, when usually the right one is at right angles to your approach path and thus more difficult to see – a real ‘gotcha’.)
So a rapid about turn and a radio call to the tower telling them what had happened. We were Number 1, so they cleared us to land. The landing itself was ‘interesting’ in a stonking crosswind. Here was a classic flight of everything going swimmingly until the last five minutes when we got bitten.
We were lucky that both of us were pilots, so I could reduce the workload a bit by working the radio and keeping an eye on things. If he had been on his own with a non-flying passenger things would have been a bit frantic to say the least, so I think you managed very well.
On the way back we hit the front again at Shoreham. We were out over the sea tracking the Seaford VOR, so had no problems about flying low. So when we entered cloud and it got very turbulent, the pilot decided to descend below it. He put the nose down, but we kept going up. There was an embedded CB. We eventually broke cloud south abeam Brighton Pier at about 800 feet, and once again the weather began to improve.
We got back in the same sunshine and excellent visibility we had when we left in the morning – several hours older and very much wiser. A little bit later my friend decided that his IMC got him into more trouble than it was worth and decided to let it lapse. I certainly learned an IMC rating needs to be constantly practised to be safe. I haven’t done one yet, prefering to learn about recovering from unusual attitudes by doing aerobatics.
I’ve been asked to go to Le2K next Saturday with another mate. From the long range synoptic chart it looks like there’s another front coming through. So maybe we should plan an alternate to Conington too!
YR
By: Moggy C - 11th July 2004 at 07:29
Excellent post Steve and a classic GA story.
You did really well in difficult circumstances and have every right to feel satisfied with your performance. Top marks to Catherine too, I’m sure she and Sandra would have lost of notes to compare.
Just a point to think about.
Scud running is high risk. We all have to do it at some time, but it doesn’t make it comfortable.
You can reduce a little of the risk level by not sticking your tail fin into the cloudbase. The temptation is always to get as much height as possible since height = thinking and acting time, but the wispy bits that hang out the bottom of clouds can easily obscure another scud runner
“…. down we come to 1500 feet. We’re lower than I want to be, but just scraping our rudder against the underside of the cloud.”
Over here in E Anglia 900 might have been a much safer and more comfortable option (Don’t try this in Wales) as long as your nav is well sorted.
Don’t get too hung up on needing plates for VFR arrivals either. If it’s an option of making a non-standard join and getting there or wandering into cumulo-granite there isn’t a field in the country that will mind.
But these are details. Glad you are safe.
(Le Touquet beats Calais any time)
Moggy