July 15, 2003 at 4:41 am
This thread is open to any opinion you have on these new aircraft.
I want to know what you think will happen or even what aircraft is better.
Please, No A vs. B wars.
( I think both aircraft are great, the 7E7 should be built exactly as shown in the models, it will bring some “spice” into the industry. But dont forget the A380, a brilliant aircraft in many respects:)
Thanks-
ACA345
By: EAL_KING - 15th July 2003 at 22:01
yep this is the case very expencive
By: GZYL - 15th July 2003 at 21:54
Interesting you mentioning the “Black projects” seems logical I guess! I attended a talk at university by a guy from Rolls-Royce, he reckoned that for a new engine to be developed it would cost 10 times as much as the entire project cost for the Channel Tunnel (At least). Which according to my research is around 150 billion US Dollars!!!!
By: tenthije - 15th July 2003 at 21:16
I think GZYL described it quite nicely. Those new engines won’t show up anytime soon. GE and P&W would not be able to afford it even if they wanted to.
The only thing that might bring these engines here anytime soon is if the USAF has a requirment for them. In that case the engines will be developed (largely) at the cost of Uncle Sam.
Now imagine the USAF has the engine, problem then is that there will also be a plane that’s going to be attached to the new engine. A plane that will likely be a black project for at least a few years.
Because of the “black plane” the USAF will not allow the engine to enter the civilian market. If suddenly a high-tech engine pops up in the US seemingly out of nowhere, everyone with half a brain will know the origins of it and will realise there is more than meets the eye.
And I did not even mention the problems Europe might give if a (largely) US funded engine pops up. Dishonest competition to RR and SNECMA!
—————-
Perhaps a bit of topic, but of interest none-the-less.
—————-
I think that both planes look ugly, each in their own way. At the moment I am not going to guess who will be more succesful.
The 7E7 will sell more because there is a larger markter for planes of that size. The A380 will likely sell with a larger profit margin because there is no competition (the 747 is still smaller than the basic A380 and a lot smaller than some of the proposed versions of the A380). The 747 sold in smaller numbers than the 767 and the A330 combined, still nobody calls it an unsuccesful plane!
One thing I thought of, what if Airbus cross-subsidizes its product with the extra profit that MIGHT be made. Maybe they could sell the A330 for less money, or do a massive upgrade of the A330 (a la A34-500/600). This would affect the 7E7 sales, maybe not a lot but still.
Boeing has done the same for donkey’s years. The 747 at one time or another cross subsidized almost every airliner Boeing made!
Sorry this topic got so long.
By: GZYL - 15th July 2003 at 18:51
Building fast aircraft these days is difficult, because you’re going to need a new revolutionary engine. This will cost hell of a lot to produce, and I can’t see any manufacturers wanting to put huge sums of money into developing something which isn’t really needed at the moment.
By: EAL_KING - 15th July 2003 at 17:08
i personally think the A380 would not look nice but insider if it anything like what the pic’s show it would be amazing while i like the look of the 7e7 but doesnt it lok a bit like the embrear 170? but longer
By: KabirT - 15th July 2003 at 11:26
they can make the BWB design into a SST if they want….that design supports the SST requirements, plus carry arnd 400 passengers i think.
By: dartie - 15th July 2003 at 11:24
Well lets keep some faith! LOL!
By: KabirT - 15th July 2003 at 11:21
its possible…wont be easy but possible!
By: dartie - 15th July 2003 at 11:16
You realise that they could make a bigger aircraft faster with the advancement in technology these days.
By: KabirT - 15th July 2003 at 11:09
So it is in the current scenario, but sooner or later the industry would have to make air travel faster, for which bigger aircraft wont be necessery. If they dont the civil aviation technology will be dormant for a too long period of time.
By: dartie - 15th July 2003 at 10:47
I disagree most major airlines want larger aircraft as it would generate more revenue per flight!
By: KabirT - 15th July 2003 at 07:04
I am and will always be against the A380 design……. as i prefer speed over size. Although it will be a whole new aspect in the aviation world. The 7E7 looks good though actualy no comments can be really made before seeing its specs.
By: steve rowell - 15th July 2003 at 06:56
I think both are going to revolutionize air travel