November 19, 2011 at 6:09 pm
Evening all! It’s been a while since I’ve been on here but I’m looking to you for advice on my parking fine, I’ve just had it within the last hour. Now I’ll be up front and say that the fine was justified, I paid for parking untill 16:45 and the time of the contravention was 16:53.
Now naturally none of us ‘want’ to pay a fine so I’ve been thinking of ways to get out of this and need to know if any of you think these are valid and will/won’t work if I appealed them.
1. Every detail is basically correct, he’s noted the date/time/location/registration/colour and the expiry date of my tax disc correctly, however! He hasn’t noted down the tax disc number where it says “NA”, now I’m guessing this of course means “Non Applicable” or something along those lines?
Is that correct that it can be like that, or is the tax disc number require as a detail, because after all it is not “NA”. I’ve tried Google etc but nothing seemed to result off the searches I did on a similar situation. Does anyone think there maybe a chance with this route? I’m thinking not…
2. Now a friend of mine who is still at work and was parked maybe about 20 metres from where I was parked and paid untill 16:53 and as I left around 17:15 did not have a fine! Immensely frustrating as you can imagine, but I imagine she has got away with it. Now my next thought was to potentially appeal using her 16:53 ticket as evidence and say that the fine was unjustified and here is my proof.
Now some of you are thinking that may not work of course, however the reason I thought I’d be potentially fine with this, was because it is of course basically dark by 5pm now and the popular consensus around where I live is that the wardens finish around 5pm as none of them appear to be around after that time.
My idea was to go back to that spot tomorrow and see what the light is like at the time I was given the ticket, because most wardens take pictures of the parking fine attached to the car etc, but I’m not sure about the pay and display ticket itself, with the dark etc I’m not sure if he bothered with the potential of a flash off the windscreen etc, who knows.
If he didn’t do that I could say this is the evidence, he made a mistake and my fine is cancelled. If he did then I look rather foolish and pay my fine, the words of the council are “If you challenge this PCN within 14 days and its rejected, the council will “generally” extend the period within which the reduced penalty charge may be paid”.
Does anyone have any constructive thoughts? Preferably none just saying “you deserved it” etc. Thanks guys :).
Tom
By: Lincoln 7 - 26th November 2011 at 11:28
Well done Baz, “Up the revolution”, against these little Hitlers :diablo:
Jim.
Lincoln .7
By: spitfireman - 26th November 2011 at 03:09
I posted this sometime back, about a wheel clamper who got a bit flustered!:D
http://forum.keypublishing.com/showpost.php?p=1760725&postcount=649
Baz
By: EGTC - 25th November 2011 at 20:41
Only time will tell, Jim 🙂
By: Lincoln 7 - 25th November 2011 at 20:25
Jim, I had to laugh at that 😀
Yeh! Brilliant, I wonder if they have any more gems like that tucked away for a particular Post?.for future reference.:diablo:
Jim.
Lincoln .7
By: Lincoln 7 - 25th November 2011 at 20:18
PeeDee. It was there, I can assure you buddy, and it was seen by A.N. Other too.
I don’t speak German either, but may well be if it hadn’t been for our lads and lassies in WW11.
Jim.
Lincoln .7
By: PeeDee - 25th November 2011 at 19:57
You couldn’t make it up, but on the bottom of this page is an advert for “Civil Parking Enforcement Officer”
Is this Keys way of telling us it has a twisted sence of humour?.:eek:
Jim.
Lincoln .7
My adverts are in German. I don’t see parkuhr or Parkplatz Offizier.
By: EGTC - 25th November 2011 at 19:53
Jim, I had to laugh at that 😀
By: Lincoln 7 - 25th November 2011 at 19:26
You couldn’t make it up, but on the bottom of this page is an advert for “Civil Parking Enforcement Officer”
Is this Keys way of telling us it has a twisted sence of humour?.:eek:
Jim.
Lincoln .7
By: Arthur Pewtey - 23rd November 2011 at 22:04
If they were going to take her £30, I was keen for the council to spend some of it on some research
What you wanted to do was ensure that money used on some fruitless exercise. You said yourself that the appeal failed – therefore pointless.
People park illegally all the time thinking they’ll get away with it. Kind of why traffic wardens exist I guess.
By: T5 - 23rd November 2011 at 21:56
As to T5, I’m glad I’m not a Wokingham council tax payer. I would be very irritated that council employees were wasting their time pursuing pointless freedom of information requests.
Pointless? How exactly? We appealed to the council and brought to their attention some of the observations made on the street in question. They decided to reject our appeal and insisted that we pay the fine. But on the same day, other cars had also been ticketed, and walking down the street countless times over the following weeks, I saw other cars with tickets on them too. Were these people that were deliberately parking illegally in the hope that nobody would spot them – in one of the busiest towns in the south? I don’t think so. These were people who genuinely believed that they could park there.
If ever I am not happy or wish to challenge the council on, well, pretty much anything, I will continue to use this rather brilliant service – regardless of the time ‘wasted’ on research by council employees. There will come a time when you might want to make a ‘pointless’ request yourself.
By: Future Pilot - 22nd November 2011 at 16:55
Sorry, but you deserved it. 🙂 Just pay it; it’s only £25 after all and you were in the wrong.
Someone had to….:rolleyes: 😀 aha.
Thanks again for all the replies everyone, it’s interesting to hear your stories as well so keep them coming if you have them.
Tom
By: John Green - 22nd November 2011 at 11:07
T5.
I like your style ! Your opening para. is quite correct – hence my previous question to Future Pilot. Always ignore the ‘naysayers’ and have a go. Try and make life difficult for those who want to make your life difficult. This matter under discussion is really about making as much money as possible by the service provider to the detriment of the service user.
Using almost any interpretation of ‘natural justice’ will show that there is very little slack in the system of dishing out penalty parking notices. A minute over your time – a foot over the yellow or white line – that’s enough to merit the award of a fine.
I urge anyone who has a doubt about the legality of their Local Authority PCN to pay up together with a letter detailing their complaint, to keep copies and sue for the return of their money thru the Small Claims Court. If your claim has merit, the issuing authority will not defend it on the grounds of expense.
The reason why apparently only about one in a hundred people ticketed, ever bother to challenge the fine is because most cannot be bothered.
John Green
By: Arthur Pewtey - 22nd November 2011 at 07:30
Preferably none just saying “you deserved it” etc. Thanks guys :).
Tom
Sorry, but you deserved it. 🙂 Just pay it; it’s only £25 after all and you were in the wrong.
As to T5, I’m glad I’m not a Wokingham council tax payer. I would be very irritated that council employees were wasting their time pursuing pointless freedom of information requests.
By: T5 - 22nd November 2011 at 00:46
If it was a private parking company, I would suggest that you tear the ticket to pieces and forget all about. After buying your details from the DVLA and bombarding you with a countless number of threatening letters, these sorts of companies soon give up.
Being the council, however, you might as well pay the bill (whilst it is more affordable at £25) and learn from the mistake. A relative of mine tried to challenge a parking ticket with Reading Borough Council last year but her appeal was rejected and she was forced to pay. Looking at the photographs taken upon returning to her car, I agreed with her that the signage was inadequate. Let’s face it, few people are going to intentionally park illegally, and she honestly believed that the space she was occupying entitled her to 1 hour of free parking. Two signs positioned next to one another meant that there was some confusion and she was actually in a bay for permit holders only.
Keen to claw back some of the £30 fine, I decided to make a freedom of information request to the council. If they were going to take her £30, I was keen for the council to spend some of it on some research. The street in question had perhaps a dozen parking spaces, so I wanted to know how many tickets had been issued in the 12 months leading up to her ticket being issued – 1,703 was the answer (almost 4.5 per day – a high number, I thought, especially considering there were no meters at the time so nobody could overstay on a pre-paid ticket). I also asked what percentage of ticketed drivers in this particular street appealed their fines – only 1.23% apparently (I’m still not convinced by that figure – do only a little over 1 in a 100 people challenge a parking ticket?). And of them, 20% apparently claimed that the signage was not clear and there was confusion about where they could and could not park. And finally, I wanted to know how this particular street compared to others in Reading as a ticketing hotspot and was told that it was the second most ticketed street in the whole of the rather large town – second to the Oxford Road, which is a road stretching for several miles (with ample parking space and more opportunities to catch out careless drivers).
By: PeeDee - 21st November 2011 at 23:34
Pay it.
I hate the system as much as anyone, but it is very seldom beaten. One of Wifey’s pals is a Traffic Warden…and to prevent people getting away with it, they take down a lot of details and photo’s of the car. This includes Valve positions on the wheels (For the “No return in two hours rule”), warmth from the front grilles, photo’s – preferably with the restriction sign in shot.
Wait till you get a £45 fine from a private car park scam, or a Wheel clamp scam of £180, then moan.
By: benyboy - 21st November 2011 at 22:12
We did park an 18 truck on the grass on a red route :-). I think it was around 50 quid if paid in the first week.
By: Lincoln 7 - 21st November 2011 at 09:58
[QUOTE=benyboy;1824886]Think your self lucky our ticket in farnborough (the one near Biggin Hill) a couple of weeks ago was £125.
So, Contrare to popular belief, there is no basic starting off price like the £25.00 the O.P. has got to pay?.
I thought it was a standard scale to which everyone came under, mind you Ben, you didn’t say how many DAYS you were there unloading;)
Jim.
Lincoln .7
By: ppp - 20th November 2011 at 23:14
Your best option is to ask on somewhere like pepipoo
IIRC your options are far fewer with Council tickets than private tickets. As others have said, this is quite a cheap fine!
Hi Future Pilot. I know you stated it was the end of the day, and in theory the little Hitlers should have left off work, however, don’t forget the Police patrol Officers can also issue tickets whilst on patrol.
Jim.Lincoln .7
I don’t think they give people parking tickets anymore. If they were bothered enough by the parking then they would probably have the car towed.
By: benyboy - 20th November 2011 at 22:15
Think your self lucky our ticket in farnborough (the one near Biggin Hill) a couple of weeks ago was £125. The guy must have been some sort of ninja to put it on without us seeing, we were unloading at the time.
By: Lincoln 7 - 20th November 2011 at 21:49
Hi Tom. Just look on the bright side, it’s only money at the end of the day, and not a bad R.T.A. with you injured.:)
Jim.
Lincoln .7