Who would you rather fly with ?

This is a lighthearted question I posed to a friend of mine.

You are going to be in the back seat of an aircraft going into combat, you have the choice of flying with either of two pilots.
You can only give the answer of A or B, no other comments are acceptable

A) A pilot with no combat experience, but knows the rule book inside out.

B) A pilot who threw the rule book out of the window, Is qualified on a multitude of aircraft,
and has years of combat experience.

A or B ?