dark light

broncho

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 785 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078271
    broncho
    Participant

    Nevesbu had sold the design of falcon corvette to an indian shipyard. I am guessing it was to goa shipyard for the OPV.

    The P-28 is not based on falcon as anyone can see. Is it me or does 8.5 m depth sould ridiculous for a piddly corvette.

    I can’t find the newslink but:
    http://www.defensieforum.nl/Forum/-t10101.15.html

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode III #2463846
    broncho
    Participant

    If PAK-FA (russian) had waited for joint venture then the first proto-type would have flown in 2020. It was always known that PAK-FA will kave to be MKIzed. The avionics of Su-35 are soley meant for RuAF. If there is something IAF likes it will be bought else develop own your own or with Israel and thales. Exactly what has India invested? As long as India is not investing any money on PAK-FA, I don’t see how Russia is obligated to co-develop the aircraft. Isn’t it better to wait and see how the russian PAK_FA turns out. If PAK-FA turns out to be expensive and not really too advanced compared to F-35 IAF can opt for F-35. No commitments.

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078289
    broncho
    Participant

    That design is not indigenous its the falcon corvette design bought from Nevesbu. I don’t see why IN needs OPV. The P-28 in the model is as good as any OPV.

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078299
    broncho
    Participant

    Without any decent SSM’s I wouldn’t accept it into any navy. The least they could do is to attach a few Kh-35’s on to front. GRSE director quoted the price as Rs 700 cr or $ 175 million per ship. I don’t see why 8 SSM’s can’t be afforded.

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078317
    broncho
    Participant

    I see, I will ask Maz at BR. The models you posted have some VLS at the rear just before the Hangar. Any idea what they contain?

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078331
    broncho
    Participant

    Russia is offering some design for P-17a but not sure which one. I have no idea where you got that model from. It does not look like P-28 to me. http://www.bharat-rakshak.com/NAVY/Images/Project28c.jpg

    The gun looks wrong from the pic released by GRSE and the speed is also not correct.
    From BR:
    rmament is to include a license-built Oto Melara 76mm Super Rapid gun in a stealth mount and the usual assortment of weapons similar to what is found on the Talwar Class and Project 17 frigates including a Klub-N missile system, two Larsen & Tubro built derivatives of the RBU-6000 anti-submarine rocket launcher and Larsen & Tubro built torpedo launchers. Revati, the naval variant of the DRDO-made Central Acquisition Radar (CAR), which is capable of tracking 150 targets at ranges of 200 km, is a confirmed sensor aboard the vessel. Hangar and aviation facilities will also be standard features

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode III #2464040
    broncho
    Participant

    With all the customization it can’t be less than 80-85 mil per piece. MKI itself is about 62 mil with support and spares.

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078363
    broncho
    Participant

    Oh I know, but since the newer talwars are comming with brahmos, I assume navy would want the P-17’s also to have them. There will be enough klubs on the older talwars, kilos and P-28’s.

    in reply to: Project 17A Frigate for India #2078414
    broncho
    Participant

    no Kashtan’s for P-17s most likely be 2 Ak-630 and 2 barak 16 cell launchers. However there are reports that weapon suite was changed which delayed it further, so they might have Vl-shtil rather than a arm launcher then again it could be because of brahmos.

    I hope it is VLS shtil or barak-2(unlikely). Klub doesn’t make any sense, I hope they go for brahmos.

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread #2078451
    broncho
    Participant

    http://www.aeronautics.ru/ka31.jpg

    Seems so

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread #2078453
    broncho
    Participant

    couldn’t find the US navy thread 😀

    in reply to: IAF news-discussion October-December 2007 #2465348
    broncho
    Participant

    PAF or PN was never the threat.

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread #2078505
    broncho
    Participant
    in reply to: Another Tamil Air-raid #2465643
    broncho
    Participant

    THe raids seem to have been useless.Did the SLAF chase the aircrafts?

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode III #2466188
    broncho
    Participant

    If the PAK-Fa is going to fly in 2009 it better noit wait for India or brazil. It can be suitably MKIzed later.

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 785 total)