dark light

QuantumFX

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,126 through 1,140 (of 1,756 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: J-20 Thread 7 #2309259
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Supercruise MACH 1,83?!
    Maximum Speed MACH 2,5?!!!!
    Clean Weight – 17 Tons ?!!!!!

    Yea, with the intervention of god almighty or a massive breakthrough in engine technology and materials…
    Those numbers are bogus.

    No official specs have been released, and full potential won’t be met until WS-15 is ready. I don’t think the wait will as long as the J-10 specs but we will have to wait sometime for any official data. So until then they are all rumors.

    in reply to: J-20 Thread 7 #2309300
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-17.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-18.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-19.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-14.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-12.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-15.jpg
    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/PRC/Air/J-20/J20-13.jpg

    in reply to: Quadbike Indian Air Force Thread Part 18 #2310366
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Now thats one cool looking Light Combat Aircraft!

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2310758
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    The mythical J-16 has not made an appearance AFAIK. 2 suspected cases were there. One looked like a Su-30MKK, but this turned out to be just that. SAC overhauled Su-30MKK. The other case was a J-11BH/BSH. So the J-16 is still a no show.

    in reply to: Small Air Forces Thread #14 #2311222
    QuantumFX
    Participant
    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2311228
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    http://i988.photobucket.com/albums/af8/My-Military-Photos/Meme/meme-yawn1.jpg

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2313487
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Ws-15 and Al-41 are both around at same level of development…..

    I don’t understand, Al-41F1 (117) is already flying with the T-50. This engine has a max thrust of 147 kN. Then there is the Al-41F1A (117S) powering the Su-35. This has a max thrust of 142 kN. The next generation engine for the T-50 (170 – 180 kN ???) is under development. I think both Salut & Saturn are vying for this. But the AL-41F1 series is already flying.

    in reply to: Why aren't LM joining Brazil competition w F-35 ? #2313559
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Thx man.
    Is this a typical CAP configuration for the F-15E/K?

    Doubtful. The CFT itself has weapons stores. I have never see an F-15E or its variants flying without CFT but with weapons. I guess it could but what would the penalty be?

    http://www.aerospaceweb.org/aircraft/bomber/f15e/f15e_19.jpg
    http://imagery.vnfawing.com/archive/Weapons/AIM-120/p0062816.jpg

    in reply to: Why aren't LM joining Brazil competition w F-35 ? #2313764
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    ROKAF F-15K right out of the oven without CFT.

    http://www.milavia.net/news/images/f-15k.jpg

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2314914
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    I doubt it, may I know the source?

    Actually I doubt it too :D. My wording was not correct :o. WS-10G is supposed to have 150+ kN thrusts, but no official sources, just the usual rumors.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2315696
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Are there any photos of this other flying J-20 with WS-10G engine and TVC nozzles:confused:

    Or is it just as mysterious as the J-16 birdy claimed to be in development..

    I am not convinced with WS-10G. A close inspection of the nozzle shows it looks a lot more like an AL-31 variant than a WS-10 variant. Member named maya at SDF (who seems to specialize in engines) said J-20 has an AL-31 variant and will do so until WS-15 is ready.

    There is a difference between the PLAAF & PLAN WS-10. Whether it purely for long flights over the ocean (some added corrosion resistance thinggy) or whether there is a thrust increases I don’t know. The WS-10B powering J-10B prototype (1035) has higher thrust it seems compared the the baseline WS-10 in J-11B (132kN V 125kN).

    Edit : There are other WS-10 variants planned, (up to 155kN) but I am just not convinced (yet) that the J-20 will use any of them. WS-15 is the required engine.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2315698
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    117S initially, then WS-15

    No no no! There are no engines by NPO Saturn at CAC let alone the 117S. CAC works with MMPP Salut. CAC & Salut have been doing business for a long time. Salut slightly modified the AL-31 for the J-10 (AL-31FN). NPO Saturn is not the only one in Russia that has High performance engines. Just ask flateric.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2316250
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    That WS-15 engine must be one Massive jet engine..:eek::confused:

    Aviadvigatel D30-F6 turbofans, are rated at 152 kN thrust.
    Given the MiG-31’s role as Mach 2.8+ interceptor and the sustained afterburning this requires, its fuel consumption is higher when compared to other aircraft serving in different roles, such as the Su-27. Consequently, the aircraft’s fuel fraction has been increased to more than 0.40—16,350 kg (36,050 lb) of high-density T-6 jet fuel.

    Seems to me it has the be in the same physical size and weight as the D30-F6 engine..
    Eighter that the Thrust specs is a tad optimistic.. Seeing is believing.

    Their target is an F119 class engine (minimum 150 – 155 kN). Don’t for get YF119/YF120 came in the late 80s. Its 2012 (30+ years later), and WS-15 has flown only on a Il-76 engine testbed. I heard that it’ll take 7-10 years after the completion of high-altitude testing to enter service (2016 – 2019). So I don’t think its optimistic. This is why the current prototypes have AL-31 variant (rumored to be 135 – 140 kN). There is an image of the WS-15 core but you won’t see the full thing soon.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2316338
    QuantumFX
    Participant


    So as it stands, practicaly all bar a few J-10 are still on the AL-31FN engines and with no near future sight of getting domestic engines up and running.

    All J-10 in-service use AL-31FN and another batch of AL-31FN was ordered IIRC (over a 100?). There is one J-10B prototype (1035) that flies with WS-10B engine, but that all. Don’t forget the J-20 will also fly with a Salut engines until WS-15 is ready. CAC is not embargoed like SAC.


    So how was the PLAAF Flankerish numbers again?
    How many Su-27SK/Su-30MKK/MK2 vs J-11 are in service now??

    So China has WS-13 and WS-15 on trials or in some test program right now.
    Are there any specs on these engines, anything?

    The reason i ask is, i want to compair them with Russian fighter engines like the FM1 and by year end FM2 engines.

    Excluding retired or damaged/crashed ones:

    Deino should know better, but here are some tables by HKSDU @ SDF mid last year. But the numbers have increased.

    WS-13 has similar specs to the RD-93. Max thrust ~85kN (There is newer 90-95kN class engine but thats a different core). WS-13 was certified in 2007 and FC-1 taxi trial on 2010 but I have not seen any images of an FC-1 with WS-13.

    WS-15 is still in development. High altitude core testing is said to have completed in 2009. Its officially a 150kN class engine. Recent rumors put it at 165kN (some even higher). But in terms of official specifications you won’t get anything.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 16 #2316362
    QuantumFX
    Participant

    Quite right.
    And i find it weird that some posters often claim that China are or will produce its own engines to replace the Russian AL-31FN(J-10) and AL-31F(J-11) engines, and yet we see more import orders.

    It looks like the AL-31FN engine are at present time not going to be replaeced anytime soon.. If someone has any other source, pls show?

    The WS-10 Engine series, however do replace the AL-31F from Russia, but at what rate? Are they to be installed on those Russian produced Flankers Su-30MKK/MK2?

    This again :

    Imported engines are manly for CAC projects. J-10 (AL-31FN), FC-1 (RD-93), J-20 (AL-31FMx? :confused:). There is one J-10B prototype flying with a WS-10B (1035) and an FC-1 prototype with WS-13 is said to be doing taxi trials, but I have never see any images. CAC don’t seem to be in a big hurry to get local engines or ones they require are not available. Unlike SAC, they have access to Russian engines specifically from MMPP Salut.

    SAC, especially J-11B and variants WILL NOT get Russian engines. Russia is not contractually obliged in anyway to provide engines for J-11B, but they still send kits for the J-11A. So far all WS-10 engines have gone to J-11B/BS/BH/BSH, along with at least 1 J-15 prototype.

    CAC will continue to use Russian engines, but eventually they’ll be replaced with WS-10 variants, WS-13 & WS-15. SAC has to use WS-10 & variants, PERIOD.

Viewing 15 posts - 1,126 through 1,140 (of 1,756 total)