dark light

Creaking Door

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 11,746 through 11,760 (of 12,419 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: General Discussion #360091
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Wasn’t there some books that came out with photographs of Russian Naval Officers and one of them was identified as Crabb?

    Blimey…a post about ‘Buster’ Crabb! Thank you sir! 🙂

    I’ve got to say I’m always suspicious of ‘revelations’ that coincide with the publishing of a book or the showing of a TV documentary (and the making of money by somebody from the ‘success’ of either).

    Of course it is very tempting to speculate about defection (or abduction) and a ‘new life’ as a Russian naval officer or (another story I’ve read) as a trainer of naval divers in East Germany but there are rather obvious problems with these versions.

    Firstly, who is the body if it isn’t Crabb, and more importantly who is a planted body intended to deceive?

    Surely if the Soviets wanted to hide the defection of Crabb a missing body is safer than risking a planted body being discovered as fake by the British.

    Much has been made of the fact that Crabb’s ex-wife, girlfriend and former diving partner failed to identify the body as Crabb (after it had been in the sea for fourteen months) and that some were pressured by the British government into confirming it as Crabb despite this.

    The conspiracy theorist would have us believe that the British government wanted to hide the ‘embarrassing’ defection of war-hero Crabb by saying the body was Crabb when it wasn’t. How would the British government have explained the embarrassment of a lunch meeting between Crabb and Khrushchev, televised for propaganda purposes, a few days, months or years after they confirmed Crabb was definitely the body found in the wetsuit?

    Secondly, why no public information (or propaganda) about Crabb in the fifty years since he supposedly defected?

    Thirdly, why do the only public accounts about Crabb to come from the former Soviet side both detail the circumstances surrounding his death?

    Crabb would be about ninety-eight now, no piece of knowledge that he had in 1956 could be of any possible use to anybody in 2007 so there would be no point in concealing his defection now. Also there would surely have come a point in the last fifty years when all of the (limited) information Crabb could have divulged to the Soviets would be overshadowed by the propaganda value of such a high-profile defector.

    To me, it just doesn’t stack up.

    in reply to: Pilot POW Falklands #1249672
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Only one Harrier pilot was captured during the war and his name was…er… 😮

    Flight Lieutenant Jeff Glover of number 1 Squadron RAF shot down near Port Howard on 21st May 1982.

    in reply to: Multi-engine synchronisation #1249677
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Have you a (German) source for that? Sounds to me like an example of British propaganda or myth. Certainly German W.W.I aircraft were noted to ‘sound different’ including having a ‘beat’ to them, as were W.W.II bombers; as to the Germans doing that ‘deliberately’ I can’t see it really, but it’s a good story to tell Grandma in the east end about the dastardly hun.

    I’ve read somewhere that this was done to counter early ‘sound-locating’ anti-aircraft locators / directors?

    in reply to: Multi-engine synchronisation #1249682
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    And here I was thinking all these years that logically multis have engines/props rotating one way (clockwise) on one wing and the other way (counterclockwise) on the other wing.

    None of the WW2 multi-engined ‘classics’ (Lancaster, Halifax, B-17, B-24, Mosquito) were designed this way.

    In fact I can only think of two aircraft from that era that do…the He177 and the DH Hornet.

    I wonder what was the first aircraft to operate in this way? :confused:

    in reply to: Jaguar doing her thing #1249702
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Don’t think this is the last flying Jaguar as I believe ETPS still have XX145 at Boscombe Down in ‘raspberry ripple scheme?

    Haven’t the Indian Air Force got one or two also? 😀

    in reply to: What Happened to Snoopy? #1250041
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Sold to Belgium or the Netherlands for re-build to fly I think. 🙂

    in reply to: Multi-engine synchronisation #1250523
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Interesting question…but surely it is just chance.

    If two engines are running at roughly the same RPM the relative RPM between them must be low…

    …and since at three points in every revolution the blades will adopt the same orientation they will ‘synchronise’ fairly often. And if the relative RPM is low they will tend to stay roughly synchronised for much of the time.

    Just my guess. 🙂

    in reply to: Bristol Aero Engines book #1254491
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    For those interested in Bristol sleeve-valve engines…

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Liqqo8Cdb68

    …I could watch that all day! 🙂

    in reply to: Todays aircraft quiz… #1254819
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Windscreen?

    in reply to: Todays aircraft quiz… #1254839
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Nosewheel tyre?

    in reply to: Lancaster over Hamburg #1264241
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    The camera contained a roll of film for about twelve exposures and was timed to expose them in ‘quick’ succession at approximately the same time as the photoflash would explode. The idea being that one exposure (at least) would coincide with the photoflash and give a good target photograph.

    Don’t know what that means in terms of length-of-exposure…just my thoughts. 🙂

    in reply to: General Discussion #361332
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Divers underwater would be a poor target for a sniper.

    I think the implication was that Crabb was on the surface when (it is claimed) he was shot…this ‘covert’ dive when Crabb went missing took place in daylight (which I hadn’t realised until recently).

    I have never described the ideas of defection as anything more than conspirasy theories… not to say they are wrong… just that I don’t believe them.

    So why do you persist in doubting that ‘the body’ is Crabb…or do you just doubt it is Crabb because the British government say it is Crabb?

    The body recovered in the wetsuit was buried, by the way…in Milton Cemetery, Portsmouth…so could probably provide DNA evidence.

    This diver is claiming to have cut his throat while he was planting a mine.

    …and this former member of Soviet Naval Intelligence claimed that Crabb was shot by a Soviet sniper.

    So a least one of them is lying…yes?

    in reply to: Russian Diver Admits Killing ‘Buster’ Crabb #1922626
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Divers underwater would be a poor target for a sniper.

    I think the implication was that Crabb was on the surface when (it is claimed) he was shot…this ‘covert’ dive when Crabb went missing took place in daylight (which I hadn’t realised until recently).

    I have never described the ideas of defection as anything more than conspirasy theories… not to say they are wrong… just that I don’t believe them.

    So why do you persist in doubting that ‘the body’ is Crabb…or do you just doubt it is Crabb because the British government say it is Crabb?

    The body recovered in the wetsuit was buried, by the way…in Milton Cemetery, Portsmouth…so could probably provide DNA evidence.

    This diver is claiming to have cut his throat while he was planting a mine.

    …and this former member of Soviet Naval Intelligence claimed that Crabb was shot by a Soviet sniper.

    So a least one of them is lying…yes?

    in reply to: Cute names for Teddy Bears #1922643
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Jehovah

    You’re only making it worse for yourself!

    Making it worse? How can it be worse? Jehovah! Jehovah! Jehovah!

    in reply to: General Discussion #361352
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Jehovah

    You’re only making it worse for yourself!

    Making it worse? How can it be worse? Jehovah! Jehovah! Jehovah!

Viewing 15 posts - 11,746 through 11,760 (of 12,419 total)