dark light

scotavia

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,281 through 2,295 (of 2,399 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Buried Lancasters.(2004 thread) #1305166
    scotavia
    Participant

    quarry holes

    And I know for certain that a quarry near Elgin on the West edge of Quarrywood was used to dump unwanted parts from the nearby scrapyard. contents include turrets from a variety of bombers which certainly included Lanc..because I found makers plates on the surface. It used to be a wide open tangle of wires, hydraulic lines and twisted metal bits. About ten years ago the council dumped soil on top and levelled it off due to a worry that kids would get trapped in the mess. So it can be true.

    in reply to: A moral dilemma #1309041
    scotavia
    Participant

    Leave it as it is now in my view. There have been instances where during a modern wreck recovery human remains have been found at the site when a burial took place in wartime. In two cases the group involved re buried the fragments when the hole was being back filled.

    If an actual burial has already occured I see nothing to gain but as you suggest it may cause distress.

    scotavia
    Participant

    For a similiar experience read the book about the protracted recovery of Peter Vachers Hurricane from India. It highlights the multiple layers of Red Tape which can be as tricky as hacking thru a rain forest. Certain sections of the Indian press do not appear to be very accurate either but that can happen anywhere…even on this forum!

    in reply to: Vulcan XH558 Gets Clearance For Take Off #1316124
    scotavia
    Participant

    Sir Jack Hayward

    This kind gentleman has already helped with avaition historical projects. The Assault glider trust at Shawbury for one. Well done Sir Jack.

    in reply to: Bader – The TV Programme #1321344
    scotavia
    Participant

    What is in a name?

    If the digging up of aircraft or removing them from remote high ground crash sites is henceforth called recovery and not archaeology would that not keep the academics from getting upset?
    For the qualified archaeologists on this thread I would say that the sites of several official non aviation digs I have visited were left in terrible condition after the dig.Litter including large sheets of plastic, stones strewn around, holes not filled. So calling all the aviation recovery teams useless at what they do is unfair. All groups have bad days paid or unpaid.

    in reply to: Bader – The TV Programme #1322363
    scotavia
    Participant

    relic hunting?

    When enthusiasts began digging up aircraft wrecks in the uK no academics were really interested.Even then they stayed away. I was fascinated to watch the B17 recovery on Time team, the non aviation archaeologists had to amend their painstaking approach. The change was evident when the A26 Invaders in the River Ribble estuary were featured in Time team recently.

    I believe that a quality recovery can take place but it will not be of the same style as layered archaeology .The parts are relics and can add to rebuilds also form a fitting memorial.

    And where human remains are present it should not be a war grave left in situ. A full recovery should take place followed by a funeral .

    in reply to: Bader – The TV Programme #1323389
    scotavia
    Participant

    recover or leave?

    For MBV…most buried or undersea remains are under threat once the first discovery has been made. Legal protection can only be enforced by a 24 hour security gaurd. Or the building of an on site protective barrier.Looters, scrapmen and souvenir hunters will pillage a site until the historical value has been degraded and it then becomes only scrap.

    It is wishful thinking to believe that the acedemic view is held by most people.
    So I am all for recovery, storage in a secure place with eventual display.

    in reply to: Bader – The TV Programme #1323402
    scotavia
    Participant

    A good programme

    On several levels the programme was very good.It was refreshing to see the progress which has been made in several areas since my attendence at the first large meeting of the Aviation Archaeologists Association at the RAF museum a long time ago.
    While traditional land archaeologists moan about the digs not being done in accordance with their own standards I would agree with current aviation recovery diggers that there is no other practical way. I encountered the same attitude when carrying out underwater wreck site survey and recovery in UK waters. Certain established archaeologists would not take into account the huge difference in tidal flows etc between UK water and the Med and that it was not practical to set up huge string grids under the sea.

    The level of research was impressive and so was a sight of Andy Saunders archive which reflects his own time and money spent over many years. Also to have experts on hand during the search projects was well planned. To see Mr Arnold in action deftly naming parts with a manual to hand as well was another surprise…in my day we used to squint at small cutaway drawings from an old Flight magazine !

    Well done to all involved for an informative programme and I agree that the presentation of the helmet and goggles was a kind gesture.

    in reply to: Battle of Britain won by Royal Navy? #1330530
    scotavia
    Participant

    Historical truth WW2

    So this time a re issued theory has gained a lot more publicity than is usual.Many readers of this forum will have enjoyed a magazine called After the Battle. My knowledge of wartime events has been revised on many occasions when writers of articles in this magazine have demolished many long held beliefs about what actually happened .Other magazines are also available of course although ATB deals with a wide range of events not just aviation.

    in reply to: Hawkins and Powers auction soon 22Aug #1334645
    scotavia
    Participant

    Firebombers galore

    I forgot the smiley, glad that you heard about the auction as well ,puzzle for me is why I was sent an invite to bid via email. No room here for any of the piles of kit for sale !

    in reply to: Who does O'Leary think he is, Prime Minister? #544789
    scotavia
    Participant

    security

    I was caught up in the alert. My camera gear had to be transferred to my hold baggage when I returned from overseas and still had a UK internal flight .
    The staff at Manchester were all very patient and trying very hard to keep cheerful which in turn was helping keep passengers calm,well done to them.

    As far as putting stuff in the hold like cameras and laptops,now that all are aware of the situation there should not be a problem. You need a sturdy suitcase and can protect items using bubble wrap. Of course all your kit needs insuring. A memory stick can be used to back up critical laptop contents.And as a professional photographer I will have a back up plan if my suitcase goes missing.

    And I would agree that the cabin baggage being carried on under old allowances had reached a size and weight that is really not safe in overhead containers. I did see a person injured when a bag fell onto his head.

    in reply to: Hawkins and Powers auction soon 22Aug #1334745
    scotavia
    Participant

    But I was first !

    in reply to: Hurricanes in the Loch #1291872
    scotavia
    Participant

    loch enoch politics

    The LOch Enoch Whitley affair was a huge mess.I would advise anyone to keep well away from this site because they could easily get into all sorts of aggro from the same individuals who stirred up a hornets nest to get restrictions made on the site.

    in reply to: Hurricanes in the Loch #1294206
    scotavia
    Participant

    Nothing in Findhorn Bay, virtually dries at low water,well apart from all the fish which the Ospreys come over to feed on, seen up to 15 at once.

    in reply to: Risk Assessment #1296055
    scotavia
    Participant

    I recall a time when RAF stores chappies used to roll full cylinders of breathing air off the back of trucks until one day a cylinder hit the ground at an angle…….the valve was badly damaged and the air came rushing out. It took off across the sports pitch like a rocket. Luckily it was not a Wednesday, no one hurt.
    We treated full diving air cylinders with as much care as you might give to a live bomb.

Viewing 15 posts - 2,281 through 2,295 (of 2,399 total)