dark light

Turbinia

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 526 through 540 (of 879 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: what is the "best" high endurance SSK #2082217
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Anyway, what is this about steel that doesn’t rust? :confused: Every ship owner in the world, commercial or military, or operator of offshore rigs and equipment in coastal areas would love to know :rolleyes:

    in reply to: CVF News #2082259
    Turbinia
    Participant

    There is a legitimate question over whether this is the best thing we can spend our defence money on.

    in reply to: what is the "best" high endurance SSK #2082262
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Well, if you buy boats never commissioned properly that have sat rusting and decaying for a decade and don’t do a proper evaluation of whether you have the capabilities to re-activate the things don’t blame anybody else for the f**k up. Same with hatches, if the crew don’t maintain good sea discipline then don’t point fingers at others.

    Turbinia
    Participant

    Yeah, but good OPV’s and an anti-corruption program won’t give anybody a hard on or allow their politicians to swagger about boasting of their great new toys. The problems Indonesia has would seem to indicate blowing money on expensive SSK’s is a mixed up priority.

    in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2082292
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Personally I’d like to see more OPV’s in the RN, the River class seem decent enough boats and good enough for Police duties.

    in reply to: VIRGINIA CLASS SSN !! #2085203
    Turbinia
    Participant

    I dunno, I can’t say a lot in public but I work in the nuclear decommissioning industry and I’ve seen some reports on the satus of a lot of old Russian boats that don’t make for good reading.

    in reply to: China wants to buy Rafales for it's fleet of carriers? #2085235
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Will there be a 6th. or 7th. generation fighter as we know it? Many think the current programs will be the last before the UCAV comes of age. Who knows what form of carrier will be required for UCAV ops?

    in reply to: VIRGINIA CLASS SSN !! #2085267
    Turbinia
    Participant

    There is an awful lot of info in the public domain on the dreadful safety record of the Soviet/Russian submarine service. Not just the serving boats, the way they dispose of their older boats is a scandal I think the world should be shouting about.

    in reply to: China wants to buy Rafales for it's fleet of carriers? #2085332
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Don’t worry Francois, it’s just the way the whole Internet has gone. When I first went on line the Internet was small, but what there was tended to be pretty good, I’m a literature lover and in the early days there were some wonderful sites on fine literature, often maintained by students as a labour of love. Now the web is HUGE but the vast majority of it is crap, pornography, marketing/sales BS or just plain junk, and nowadays finding the golden nuggets can be hard work.

    in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2085464
    Turbinia
    Participant

    On the Castle class, 25 year old OPV’s are hardly the stuff of dreams, and those two boats have been worked hard. I wonder if Pakistan will up arm them? RN policy is to have a nominal weapons fit on their OPV (at least in peacetime) with little more than a light automatic cannon.

    in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2085505
    Turbinia
    Participant

    My brother helped build one of those subs!. We told the Canadians they’d been layed-up, unmaintained, for a decade. They signed off on the refurb work…their issue!!!! :rolleyes:

    Yeah, but it’s a lot easier to make a **** up buying subs that have been left to rust and decay for years and then blame somebody else. As the saying goes, buyer beware, the UK didn’t exactly hide anything on the status of the four Upholders and Canada had plenty of opportunity for inspection.

    in reply to: China wants to buy Rafales for it's fleet of carriers? #2085508
    Turbinia
    Participant

    You mean like in Iraq when when little girls are stalked and then followed to their homes and raped and murdered along with their families to eliminate witnesses.

    True, that is terrible, but then when these soldiers are caught they’re put on trial and if found guilty will be punished. And where is any of that listed as official state policy? This may surprise you but in hot war zones soldiers losing it is hardly uncommon.

    About the Rafale, it’s a fine fighter and excellent carrier fighter, the French Navy have a superb machine to be proud of.

    in reply to: Bush might Steal space #2539531
    Turbinia
    Participant

    This whole thread is nonsense as everybody knows that all of space is owned by the Queen of England already, god bless her!

    in reply to: CVF News #2086716
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Joint programs tend to work well where their is a dominant partner and the junior partners accept they’re basically buying a bit of influence and workshare but accept there is a boss (eg. UK involvement in JSF) but where it is with equals and things are done by committee it’s not so great. An exception is the Tornado which has been an outstanding aircraft (ADV excepted) but when you look at other programs usually the expected cost savings are cancelled by constant arguments, delays, mission creep to try and satisfy differing requirements etc. One of the things I admire about France if they’ve had the balls to go their own way so often and produce some outstanding systems (Mirage family, Rafale etc.).

    in reply to: The best SSK till date? #2086844
    Turbinia
    Participant

    The most serious problems have effected the lead ship of the class, the ex-Upholder/Chicoutimi. The Upholders might be a “reasonable” design, but have not proven to be reliable.

    Most of these problems were initial production faults and errors common to almost any new design of major vessel. They were never fully commissioned and the RN had no interest in doing the hard work of the shake down to get the design up to advertised standards. This isn’t just me being a British big it up guy, I’ve seen enough warships to know that major problems following delivery are neither unusual nor usually a long term problem with utilisation. To introduce a totally new design to service is a highly demanding job.

Viewing 15 posts - 526 through 540 (of 879 total)