dark light

Turbinia

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 571 through 585 (of 879 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The best SSK till date? #2090394
    Turbinia
    Participant

    They’re finally getting the Astute program on track, it’s been a nightmare project as for a while it was just totally out of control to the point it was suspended to allow BAE to recover from some of the dreadful mismanagement screw ups and also bring in American assistance to help them out. I’ve no doubt the Astute will be a formidable SSN and a lethal weapon, but the cost is frightening 🙁 Same with the Type 45, it should be an excellent destroyer but it’s clear the RN will be lucky to get 8, never mind the 12 they were originally promised, and I’d be amazed if the Type 23’s are replaced on a 1:1 basis, which begs the question of will the two CVF’s be of real use if the RN lack adequate escorts to field two carrier battle groups? I guess the only (very small) consolation is that the RN aren’t the only navy struggling with their budget 🙁

    in reply to: The best SSK till date? #2090401
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Talking SSK’s, when will the RN see sense and buy good SSK’s? Pretty obvious that they cannot afford anything like enough Astute SSN’s to maintain anything like the number of boats the RN wants/needs so SSK’s would offer a possibility of building up numbers as well as being more suitable for a lot of the sort of inshore and littoral ops that figure heavily in current naval planning. Of course the RN did build four modern SSK’s but those dippy numpties in Westminster and Whitehall decided to sell them off when they were still brand new, great 😡

    in reply to: The best SSK till date? #2090422
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Things like quality of materials, welding, installation etc. do make a huge difference even when boats share a common design, not to mention in service maintenance and operation.

    in reply to: Austria Cancelling Eurofighter ? #2550121
    Turbinia
    Participant

    In that case an aweful lot of countries are failing in their UN obligations. A defence force is there to defend against threats and to project power/influence. Austria has no interest in power projection or joining in other peoples wars, and there is no clear threat to Austria requiring fast jet fighters, so these Typhoons are basically pointless. Have peoploe any idea of the scale of the breakdown in Europe and the EU that would be required to really lead to Austria being a front line state? If that ever happened a debate over a squadron of Eurofighters will be pretty well down the list of concerns of anybody.

    in reply to: Merchant shipping #2090753
    Turbinia
    Participant

    UK ports and terminals are also very efficient, and it is now rare to have any labour unrest or problems, they’re very competitive internationally and have been for 20 years or more, we’ve came a long way from the dark days of the 70’s, semi-permanent strikes, honesty payments etc 🙂 I’m not claiming we’re better than anybody, as these days the competition for business is so intense standards tend to be very high in most port operations (at least in the wealthier world) but the UK has came a very long way from the international joke we were 30 years ago.
    The fuel question is interesting, there has always been a debate over the relative merits of the much lower costs of HFO (and IFO) compared to distillates versus higher maintenance costs, consumables and suppressed reliability/life of engines. The environmental issue looms large too, even though the new annex of Marpol on exhaust emissions is now in force it still allows 4.5% S in residual fuels or 1.5% in designated special areas, even the lower 1.5% level still has a major SOx problem and would be totally unacceptable under land based legislation. The control of NOx is also causing major problems, given that without eliminating S it is very dificult to erradicate SOx emissions from vessels I think we may well see a major push to restrict the use of residual fuels or make major investment in new emissions control technologies.

    in reply to: Update: Belgian NH90 order #2550269
    Turbinia
    Participant

    A fine helicopter for the Belgian forces, the NH90 is an excellent machine.

    in reply to: General Discussion #347602
    Turbinia
    Participant

    We should drill a hole to the centre of the planet, fill it with nuclear bombs and then see if we can blow the whole planet up for a laugh. That’s my view.

    in reply to: North Korea Goes Nuclear #1944299
    Turbinia
    Participant

    We should drill a hole to the centre of the planet, fill it with nuclear bombs and then see if we can blow the whole planet up for a laugh. That’s my view.

    in reply to: General Discussion #347722
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Yes indeed, in your industry H&S is of vital importance, especially where microwave radiation is concerned.

    Thing is, the really high risk industries tend to have excellent safety records, and that is because they have such rigid safety systems in place. Look at the safety records of industries like fishing and construction where things are a lot slacker. In this plant we deal with 120Bar steam, 275KV electricity, radiological hazards, boiling acids, some very nasty chemicals and there has been one significant accident with a storeman having a fork lift run over his foot since the plant opened. That is a pretty good vindication of the safety systems (storeman not withstandin) compared to a lot of companies in the local economy with nothing like the hazards we have to manage.

    in reply to: You Couldn't make it up #1944309
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Yes indeed, in your industry H&S is of vital importance, especially where microwave radiation is concerned.

    Thing is, the really high risk industries tend to have excellent safety records, and that is because they have such rigid safety systems in place. Look at the safety records of industries like fishing and construction where things are a lot slacker. In this plant we deal with 120Bar steam, 275KV electricity, radiological hazards, boiling acids, some very nasty chemicals and there has been one significant accident with a storeman having a fork lift run over his foot since the plant opened. That is a pretty good vindication of the safety systems (storeman not withstandin) compared to a lot of companies in the local economy with nothing like the hazards we have to manage.

    in reply to: Austria Cancelling Eurofighter ? #2550652
    Turbinia
    Participant

    To be fair, the ability to police your own air space is a sign of independance. I do not think most poeple could accpet the condition like Ireland.

    There is the national pride question, but enough countries can live without expensive fighter jets, not just Ireland, New Zealand abondoned it’s air strike capability (Keith Park must be turning in his grave), much of the Caribbean, some African states, Polynesian states etc.

    in reply to: Austria Cancelling Eurofighter ? #2550658
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Do that and you can bet said countries are going to put conditions on defending the Austrian airspace… economical or political… they’re not going to do it for free.

    I think keeping 24 typhoons for air policing makes a lot of sense.

    Nic

    They don’t need to pay, are Germany, Italy, the Czech Republic or Switzerland going to sit and allow anybody to launch a major war across their airspace? Who exactly would Austria need to fight with such capable fighters anyway? Where is the nearest country that could be considered a realistic threat? Syria? Iran? Possibly Russia? Either way a lot of countries between them and Austria.

    in reply to: Report:N.Korea performed first-ever nuke test-What's next? #2550668
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Yeah, but any old bomber will also be shot down. A credible delivery system means they have to be able to mount it on a missile, either ICBM or cruise, and that takes a lot of skill and expertise. Either that or stick it in a suitcase and just leave it in the middle of a city, pretty effective.

    in reply to: Typhoon – Beauty or Beast? #2550671
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Ywp, a strake is not the same as a canard.

    About the EF Typhoon, it is a very pretty aircraft, it’s the thing I like about it most as other than looks I’m not the biggest fan of the aircraft. Love it in black, stunning.

    in reply to: Austria Cancelling Eurofighter ? #2550871
    Turbinia
    Participant

    Can anybody seriously ever see Austria going to war with Germany, Italy, Switzerland or the Czech Republic? As a member of the EU it’s locked into a political union and legal system with is between it and any threats. What is the nearest realistic threat? Either South or East of the Medi or the former USSR, either of which would entail a major war involving all of Europe if Austria ever got into trouble from Russia or the Middle East. Given that, it’d make sense for Austria to invest in internal security capability and rely on others to defend their airspace, with maybe a handful of lightweight fighters based on advanced trainers to handle things like air hijack situations. Do what countries like New Zealand and Ireland do and just rely on the fact that other bigger and better armed countries will do the real heavy job of providing air defence and have a free ride.

Viewing 15 posts - 571 through 585 (of 879 total)