dark light

knifeedgeturn

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 467 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Cockpit-Fest USA #950805
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    If this event takes off like the one in the UK, then after three years, it will be down to about half the numbers that it had when it started, and it will take a further seven years to get back to it’s original size….

    in reply to: Mastermind tonight (Fri 23 Nov) #960490
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    The answer is C119.

    in reply to: Museum storage #964686
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    to acquire
    to conserve
    to research
    to exhibit

    It is being researched, by top men, Top Men…….

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #965814
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant
    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #965826
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    On the web page I mentioned above there are a few gps co ordinates posted unfortunately my Italian (or lack of) means I don’t know if it is the wreck site or the remains location.

    Due to my low level of competence with all things computer I cannot post a link, but I found it on PPrune under p40 in the desert.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #966775
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    Qattara appears to have a web page, with quite a lot of information (unfortunately in Italian) and a couple of pictures of the recovery of a certain A/C………

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967241
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    Surely these exchanges achieve nothing. It is clear there are 4 or 5 scenarii for what happened but until hard evidence is proved we will not know which, if any, is correct.

    As I see it, hard evidence will be the discovery of flt sgt Coppings remains, in one place or another; if we presume that he died in the crash, and persons unknown removed his body, then he is already buried, and our quest comes to an end.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967379
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    “As for other typos, maybe you’d either send me a list or report the matter to the spelling Police? If you like, and if its important, I could reciprocate”.

    Now this is pointless!

    I’ll stick my neck out here, I believe the forced landing was survivable, and Copping did indeed survive it; I think he cut the harness maybe to make a carry strap, maybe just to collect “useful” items together for a trek, whether he made one I don’t know.

    Did British fighter A/C operating in the desert carry rations/ water?

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967420
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    That’s re your last scenario! ;I thought that in the original thread that at least part of the serial was readable and that was seventy years on!

    And yes if they did find him (in that scenario) but not his A/C that would tend to suggest that he didn’t die in the crash.

    Re typo, what about all the others!

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967533
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    Tangmere, (note correct spelling) I’m not suggesting that anyone is not trying to help, just that the fixation of the “discovered remains” and the situation r.e the Italians and the Mod (in Egypt) is an impass.

    I do wonder whether there was any point in contacting MP’s, as their information (assuming they could even be bothered to ask for it) would come straight from the Ministry for Defence office, doubtless who have a prepared statement, along the lines of “everthing that can be done is being done”.

    Am I alone in wondering why we are allowed to discuss this matter, but the thread with all the background information, remains inaccessable; I for one would like the chance to re evaluate the information relative to flt sgt Copping, and his fate.

    If his remains were recovered in the scenario you suggest, he would have to have been quite a way from his A/C, for them not to have seen (or indeed looked for) said A/C, because if it were found, the identity was there to be seen.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967580
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    “Isn’t this whole thread, fascinating though it is, starting to sound like a broken record in some respects?”

    That maybe because “we” all want different things from this;
    some are not bothered about subsequent details because they are “certain” the remains found are those of Coppings,

    others have him buried by beduins, (in an unknown location)

    one or two take the opportunity to attack the British govt and the MOD, with accusations of lies, (when the most obvious answer is incompetence)

    The question is; which of these will help find the remains of flt sgt Copping?

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #967823
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    Having re examined the pictures, the item protuding from the sand in the seat base is definately the lower strap fixing, the webbing has also been cut (along with the removeable section of the shoulder straps) the waist strap laying in the sand has been removed without cutting.

    As Tony D has said, waist straps are secured with a folded metal bracket, some have adjustment buckles and are removable at that point.

    If you are removing a body/remains, (and as Tangmere says cannot see the pull clip) you would in all reasoning cut the straps, but at least one of them isn’t cut, and the lower back strap is cut as close to the fixing as possible, which means you would have to push the body/remains all the way forward, to get right down there, in reality you would cut the strap much higher up, as there is no need to cut at the bottom (especially as it would be partially obscured by the parachute pack)

    I am also unsure how you would open the canopy that was locked shut for flight, without breaking the perspex; the photo linked by Tony T shows the canopy shut and (originally) intact.

    Was the very pistol found (I can’t remember now) if it were I wouldn’t be that surprised ; didn’t this bit of desert change hands frequently at that time? in all probability you would be signalling your whereabouts to the enemy.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #968136
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    ” It may be a masterful piece of deduction or a complete fluke”

    I suppose the question you have to ask yourself is, which way does a man walk when he is already hopelessly lost?

    If I remember correctly from the original thread, Copping refused to change course, despite various attempts by his “wing man” to get him to do so.

    Suggestions were that his compass was faulty, that being so, would it have remained faulty after the crash or indeed totally U/S, and what about the standby compass?

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #972331
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    I still cannot believe how you are all coming up with these “conspiracy” theories whilst seemingly ignoring the one tangible fact, there is body remains in the near vicinity, but you all seem to have him buried beside it, dead on impact, abducted by Germans, Allies or Aliens.. None of which is helping his relatives if searching the web for information..

    Are the remains nearby? I thought it was said 5km away; was it not the MOD that discounted these remains? I am just trying to get a better understanding of what might have happened; we have no control over what is or isn’t being done on site.

    I personally couldn’t make head nor tale of quattara’s last post, not his fault, my Italian is non existant, his English is much better.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #972352
    knifeedgeturn
    Participant

    Agreed, mostly guesswork; when planning DDay, did the MOD not ask for holiday snaps to be sent in, used to help build up a profile of that general area?

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 467 total)