dark light

Bayar

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 91 through 105 (of 363 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Bayar
    Participant

    @Deino it was clearly written above in my post that Dassault is Turkish Aerospace Industries partner for the mission computer software development effort. It is also well known that the primary partner is BAE Systems. In fact, close sources to Turkish defence officials are saying that BAE Systems itself recommended Dassault for the Software component.

    See http://www.trt.net.tr/francais/science-sante/2018/06/22/cooperation-entre-tusas-tai-et-dassault-systemes-997453

    Bayar
    Participant

    ^Better watch out with France. They are not a sovereign country. The US could direct them to leave the program at any time

    Dont worry Turkey is no longer putting all its eggs in one basket.

    Turkey is working with Russia, Europe and other States on military technology so it hedges its political risk in defence programs.

    Bayar
    Participant

    I don’t follow Turkey’s defense requirements, but why the expansion?
    Looks like a capable (and expensive) program.

    I think the European members of NATO are unhappy with the Trump Administration’s unpredictability and opting to decrease their dependence on the US. I think PESCO will be Europes primary defence framework in future as opposed to NATO.

    Italy, France and Turkey are working more and more closely in the military technology scene of late. They are also developing a more advanced SAMP/T- Aster ABM system.

    Europe will field several different types of combat aircraft in future.

    As for the TF-X being an expensive program- The Turkish Government has allocated $20 billion for the program. TAI officials have also for the first time revealed that they will be relying heavily on the BAE Systems Replica program. So we could basically see the Replica being developed into a mature modern platform under the name of TF-X

    Bayar
    Participant

    Dassault Systèmes of France also officially joins the Turkish Aerospace Industries TF-X Fighter program. http://www.kokpit.aero/mmu-dassault-yazilim-destegi

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DgXUzhYXUAA5Q-Z.jpg

    The companies now working on the TF-X are as follows:

    Turkish Companies
    ASELSAN
    HAVELSAN
    AYESAS
    Turkish Aerospace Industries
    TUSAS Engine Industries
    KALE Aerospace

    Foreign Companies
    BAE Systems PLC (UK)- Platform design & Integration Support Partner
    Rolls-Royce (UK) – propulsion design and development Support Partner
    Dassault Systèmes (France)- Mission Computer, Software/Algorithms, AI/Data Fusion Design Support Partner
    Saab AB (Sweden)- Pre-conceptual design support Partner

    in reply to: Helicopter News & Discussion #2142043
    Bayar
    Participant

    TUSAS Engine Industries of Turkey introduces its TS-1400 Turboshaft Engine family made of 50% 3D Printed Super-alloy Parts.

    The TS-1400 will power the:

    TAI T-129 Atak Light Helicopter
    TAI T-625 Utility Helicopter
    TAI T-130 ATAK-2

    TAI Hurkus COIN Aircraft (With Propeller modification- Turbo-Prop version)
    TAI Akinci HALE UCAV (With Propeller modification- Turbo-Prop version)

    http://idora.milliyet.com.tr/YeniAnaResim/2018/06/12/yerli-helikopter-motorunda-basari-11687205.Jpeg

    The platforms are intended to receive European Aviation Safety Authority (EASA) Certification in 2024.

    See also https://www.tei.com.tr/dosyalar/kitap/1441/dosya-1441-1669.pdf

    Bayar
    Participant

    Turkish Government issues formal tender for AIRCRAFT ARRESTING SYSTEMS (AAS) technology.

    It intends to begin development efforts for the 300+ metre Aircraft Carrier arresting system for STOL aircraft. This will most likely be for land based testing and development phase.

    See formal tender document in English: https://www.ssm.gov.tr/Images/Uploads/MyContents/V_20180516180632000492.pdf

    Bayar
    Participant

    https://seawaves.com/wp-content/uploads/2018/02/Navantia-Turkish-LHD-840x391.jpg

    Bayar
    Participant

    Dear Bayar, the problem is not that we don’t like the discussion, but merely that fact what you are presenting, the way you present these information and most of all that – I would say with a lot of nationalistic fewer included – a normal decent discussion is simply not possible:

    You are a presenting completely illusion plans, projects a country like the USA, Russia and China or multinational projects by the EU can barely manage with their budget and their vast expertise and experience and you even more present timelines and a budget, no one with the slightest sense of logic and understanding in aerospace matters would rate possible.

    You are presenting lists of projects ranging from stealth fighters, trainers, transports, helicopters, AUVS, UCAVs and carriers that even the biggest aerospace countries have issues to manage and finance and you are presenting them as it would be some sort of plug-and-play.

    One has to remember – and that’s not to diminish any Turkish achievements – but a fact: so far Turkey has not developed and fielded any significant major project on their own, none: No combat aircraft, no transport, no helicopter , … in fact NOTHING. All TAI so far has done was participating in local co-production and / or license manufacturing.

    So I beg you to stay realistic and accept that there are not few who remain most skeptical on what will ever happen.

    These projects – in fact – NONE could be taken seriously.

    Even more you are oversimplifying the political background: the current path president Erdogan follows is most likely wrong, this playing one side against the other with the UE, USA and Russia will never ever ease the situation and make such projects even more unlikely to come to fruition. And that’s my third point of concern …

    With respect Deino,

    (1) Lack of experience does not mean Turkey cannot have such programs nor does it mean that such programs will be a total and utter failure.
    (2) Co-production and licence production of platforms are achievements in and of itself which lead to indigenous programs.

    I’ll show you how Turkey is doing this by giving Turkish Aerospace Industries and TUSAS Engine Industries as an example. Both the aforementioned companies were incorporated for licence production of the F-16 and General Electric F110. After the F-16 programs were completed both companies became OEM parts manufactures for other major defense companies. In the 1990’s, the companies then moved onto licenced production and co-production of parts for major international programs such as the Airbus A400m. In the early 2000’s, these two companies began to purchase intellectual property rights for existing disused platforms such as the AgustaWestland A-129 Magoosta and the upgrade them using subsystems designed, developed and produced by Turkish companies. With these programs these companies obtained experience with integration of sub-systems into complex platform. Subsequent to the success with this model, both Turkish Aerospace Industries and TUSAS Engine Industries commenced their own indigenous programs for combat aircraft and helicopter.

    The below shows how Turkey went from having zero experience with helicopter production to becoming and indigenous designer and producer of both rotary wing aircraft and turbo shaft engines.

    Turkey went from parts producer, to licence production of the T-120 (Agusta Westland A-129), T-70 (Sikorsky S-70i) and LHTEC T800 engine to indigenous platforms such as the T-130, T-625, 10 Ton Utility Helicopter and TEI TS-1400 Turbo-shaft engine!

    Licenced Production Programs

    T-129- Coproduction deal with AgustaWestland (now Leonardo)

    https://putalahuea.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/AIR_A129_ATAK_Components_lg.jpg

    TURKISH UTILITY HELICOPTER PROGRAM- T-70 (Coproduction/Licence production deal with Sikorsky for S-70i)
    http://i26.servimg.com/u/f26/16/26/67/16/2ajnot10.jpg

    Turkish Aerospace Industries Indigenous Helicopter Programs

    TAI T-130 ATAK 2- See https://www.tai.com.tr/en/product/atak-2

    https://www.tai.com.tr/uploads/atak-2-urun-gorseli.png

    TAI 10 Ton Utility Helicopter- See https://www.tai.com.tr/en/product/10-ton-utility-helicopter

    https://www.tai.com.tr/uploads/10-ton-sinifi-genel-maksat-helikopteri-projesi--1.png

    TAI 625- See https://www.tai.com.tr/en/products/helicopter

    https://www.ainonline.com/sites/default/files/styles/ain30_fullwidth_large_2x/public/uploads/2017/06/464_21284901-wagner.jpg

    Indigenous Turbo-shaft Engine Program and Development

    TS-1400 Turboshaft Engine for Indigenous Helicopters

    https://silahvecephane.com/wp-content/uploads/2016/11/14993507_1278141392217283_4608109242435261044_n1.j  pg

    Bayar
    Participant

    If it’s really modfied to such a degree, good luck with the F-35B you referred in your limk, if Turkey will ever get them. I assume you know what is the maximum payload of the F-35B in Vertical take off.

    So your bombastic original post about a STOBAR (btw the links you provided referred just to the construction of a dry dock, which could be used i.e. for commercial and cruise vessels, nothing more) was incorrect?
    Now you talk about a 300+ m STOVL carrier. Such a pity, the QE class is just 280 m, I thougt that the most advanced shipbuilders and engineers in the world could have squeezed something more then UK with 20 m more in lenght. 😀

    Reread the entire post before commenting.

    Reference was made to 3 separate vessels:

    TCG Anadolu (LHD/Light Carrier)- under advance stages of construction
    TCG Trakya (LHD/Light Carrier)- Contract to be signed
    300+ metre CV proper – (STOVL)- newly announced

    Bayar
    Participant

    Reliance on Russian aviation design prowess has not played well for the Indian’s FGFA. The Russian design bureaus could not pay their engineers in the 1990s so they all quit. For many their income was higher if they drove a taxi cab. When they left, the Russian design bureaus lost the expertise needed to field a workable weapon system. After the T-50 prototype rollout, the Russians seem to struggle with maturing it into an operational airplane.

    Will the Russians suddenly develop the skills to help Turkey develop an airplane for a new aircraft carrier? I doubt it. Best to check with Dassault and see if they will sell Ms.

    India does not have the experience Turkish Aerospace companies have with NATO standard aircraft production.

    At the end of the day Turkish industry has been able to licence produce 300 F-16’s including their engines. They have also been a program partner for various international projects such as the A400M.

    Turkish companies also produce various high tech subsystems such as avionics, 3rd Gen targeting pods, mission computers, AESA radar etc. All Turkey needs is assistance with design and development of a fuselage and propulsion system. It can then integrate NATO standard subsystems it develops.

    Bayar
    Participant

    I think you are confusing the present with the 1970s to 1990s. That’s when the UK built small STOVL carriers, as did Italy & Spain, while India & Thailand bought one each.

    The UK currently has two large STOVL carriers afloat. Italy has one small & one very small. Japan & Turkey have or are building ships the same size as Italy’s bigger, newer carrier, but not designed as primarily STOVL carriers.

    Not much of a trend compared to 30 years ago.

    Turkey’s TCG Anadolu is a highly modified derivative of the Juan Carlos class LHD designed as a light VTOL carrier- it cannot not operate STOVL aircraft.

    Turkey’s newly announced 300m + vessel will however use a STOVL aircraft. Most likely a TFX naval variant

    Bayar
    Participant

    President Putin of Russia informs his Turkish counterpart that Turkey can choose any combat aircraft in Russian production in the event that Washington imposes an Arms embargo on Turkey…or alternatively Turkey and Russia can co-develop a clean sheet aircraft together.

    http://www.milliyet.com.tr/putin-acikladi-dunyanin-en-iyi-dunya-2676463/
    https://www.aa.com.tr/en/todays-headlines/putin-turkey-has-right-to-choose-its-military-aircraft/1157062

    Bayar
    Participant

    JRS vs Bayar Alert!
    Altough i,m not the slightest surprised of the content.
    I am quite dissepointed at some senior members give this thread the undeserving attention..

    When did you begin to determine what thread is deserving of attention and what is not? Do you really need to derail all my threads with ad hominem attacks at other users? If you dont like the discussion just do not take part in them!

    Bayar
    Participant

    Meanwhile, according to Turkish media sources US Officials have informed their Turkish counterparts that the first Turkish block of 30 F-35A’s will be delivered to the Turkish Air Force on 21 June 2018 with an Official handover ceremony at Fort Worth, Texas despite US Congressional moves to impose an embargo on Turkey.

    https://www.sozcu.com.tr/2018/gundem/f-35lerin-turkiyeye-teslim-edilme-tarihi-belli-oldu-2396447/

    So the problem was obviously not with the Trump Administration but Greek and Armenian Lobby backed Congressman.

    Bayar
    Participant

    Turkey seems to develop a lot of sophisticated defence equipment — a pity that they seem to move in a wrong direction politically and culturally. Also they seem to become more and more confrontational.

    Turkey and the West could go from the old win-win to a new lose-lose situation… I think if Turkey and the West really split, both sides will regret it deeply afterwards. On the other hand if Turkey keep moving in the current direction sooner or later a split will become inevitable. No doubt Turkey will in such a situation blame the West, completely ignoring the facts — Turkey has been a reliable NATO partner for many years, and I am not seeing NATO changing. It is Turkey that is changing, not NATO, and not the West.

    Turkey will never fully divorce the West and vice versa. It will end up being a de facto relationship.

    Turkey it seems will be equidistant to both East and West.

Viewing 15 posts - 91 through 105 (of 363 total)