dark light

dienekes

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 14 posts - 31 through 44 (of 44 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Israeli Helicopter carriers #2063226
    dienekes
    Participant

    I read about it in Sea Power Magazine where they used the term LPD (2nd article in the link below). There seems to be quite a bit of confusion around these terms though, so you might be right.

    http://www.navyleague.org/sea_power/aug_04_50.php

    I wasn’t aware that the frigate program was cancelled.

    It’s a shame because the Israeli Navy slowly came to the obvious conclusion that FACs are not the best way to wage naval warfare in Eastern Mediteranean. And I hear that the Saar 5 has some inherent roll problems due to high center of gravity (that is why Gabriels were never fitted, I think).

    I still believe the IN shall wait and see what happens with the USN LCS program and take advantage of the R&D done for this project.

    in reply to: Vosper 69m "Super Vita II" #2063227
    dienekes
    Participant

    Thanks but this is the 62m boat we (the HN) already have. 🙁

    The 69m boat is in “project” state AFAIK but I would hope I could get some model pictures or similar.

    in reply to: Scorpion Class patrol boats.. #2063506
    dienekes
    Participant

    @dionis

    I am afraid the Russian Navy is getting away from it’s cold war pretentions on being a blue water navy (using force projection, i.e. Varyag carriers, Kirov BC, etc). Now the emphasis seems to be on littoral operations (defensive bias) although there is always the fleet of strategic subs (what’s left of it).

    But I think russian shipbuilders push those corvette designs mainly for export. There is, after all, a growing demand for ships between 500 and 2000 tons from navies all over the world.

    I for one would love to see those projects compete with western designs in the international naval market. 😉

    For the AK-630 look here and here

    in reply to: Hellenic Navy (News & Views). #2063525
    dienekes
    Participant

    Btw, to return to your initial thread subject, how about some L class ships from Holland? I believe there are even a lot of common parts with the S class vessels we ‘ve got. I think there may be some available in a couple of years (any new ship won’t be available for at least 4-5 years after the contracts are signed).

    Hmmm… the Jacob Van Heemskerck class…

    I don’t know, these ships are not any younger than our Kortenaers and they are probably only 50% better (all things considered) then the Perrys. Which we refused to accept when offered (and that was a wise decision).

    Furthermore, they were to sell tose frigates to Chile.

    Now, the Karel Doorman class, that is a fine ship, and I know they are looking to get rid of 2-4 ship. In a probable selection of the LCF as our next major frigate/destroyer, we could ask for 2 KDs as part of the package.

    That way, in about 2012, the HN would have 4 MEKO, 2 Karel Doorman, 4 Kortenaer and 4 LCF. A further advantage of that plot is that we don’t need to modernize 6 Standards, only 4 would do, and the extra money spend perhaps in fitting advanced weapons (i.e. RAM, ESSM, etc).

    Nice conversation btw, and hope more members participate!
    🙂

    in reply to: Hellenic Navy (News & Views). #2063541
    dienekes
    Participant

    Remember Dianekes, these purchases (F1652s and U214s) were made about 5 years ago. How about 5 years from now? Where are the Typhoons for the replacement of the F16s in an Air superiority role (I guess the F16s are going to replace the A7s in the Air to Ground role)? The Turks are planning to upgrade almost ALL of their F16s in the F1652+ version. What are we expecting? To try and turn the scale with a purchase of 150-200 planes in 5 years from now? That is impossible. The past has shown that in order to keep the arms balance between us and the Turks, there has to be a constant strategic planning in our hardware purchases. We had Arsenis for 3 years in the MD and the balance went to hell. Now again with these training accounting magicians I think we have another thing coming….and it won’t be good….
    After all, in the aftermath of the parliamentary commision meetings for the TORs and the TPQ radar, the officers are almost afraid to put their signature on a purchase contract (even on a suggestion note)

    You are right to be worried. But then again, Turkey is not in best terms, economically speaking. I don’t think the THK F-16s will be upgraded, at least at that scale.

    I hope this initial numbness of the new government shall cease in the following months… It is now, after all, easier than ever to turn the scales and once again dominate the Aegean. THK is already making rush (and sometimes irrational) moves to counter that.

    Apart from that, ta en oiko mi en dimo, my friend! 😎

    in reply to: Scorpion Class patrol boats.. #2063543
    dienekes
    Participant

    Very pretty designs! Do I see a helo hangar on the corvette??? [edit: I mean the small one, you beat me to posting!]

    Also the Kashtans would have no missile reloads, is that correct? I don’t see how you can fit a reload magazine under them…

    in reply to: Hellenic Navy (News & Views). #2063556
    dienekes
    Participant

    Once again the Hellenic Armed Forces came close to achieve a level of equilibrium with the relevant Turkish forces and once again due to political inactivity, we will lose it big time. (No new ships, no new planes, actually not anything was orderd for 2004 and hardly anything will be ordered in 2005, because if ordered it has to be accounted for inside 2005 and there are no money left………..)

    Stormeagle, I cannot share your pessimism… The Air Force is rapidbly gaining on the THK and next year the balance of 3rd generation a/c shall be 1,1:1 for THK, but then again we have M2000-5 and F-16 Block 52+ which the Turks don’t have. Not to mention AAW a/c (THK to get them after 2007)

    Also the navy shall receive the type 214 subs, which represent an almost strategic, if I might say so, naval weapon for the area.

    I agree though that, in a few cases we would act quicker and more decisively (AAW frigates, patrol corvettes, patrol aircraft, etc)

    in reply to: Cyprus Pocket Navy – Photos #2063561
    dienekes
    Participant

    WHat kind of Naval vessels does Cyprus have that could possibly counter the Turkish Navy?

    My friend, it would be vain for Cyprus to try and counter the TN in sea superiority.

    The best strategy would be to use a combination of coastal ASM batteries (Exocet, already in service), helicopters armed with medium/long range ASMs, possibly UAVs for BTH target acquisition and, finally extra-fast patrol boats armed with short range missiles + guns and an adequate coastal defence, in order to prevent any landing efforts.

    In fact this could be an interesting scenario: how would you defend an island (actually, 2/3 of an island 🙁 ) from an invasion by a superior naval force?

    in reply to: Scorpion Class patrol boats.. #2063574
    dienekes
    Participant

    I’ll take a look at the other models in the collection!

    OK, and please post any other interesting pictures you might find!
    🙂 🙂 (of the 20380 corvette for example… :p)

    in reply to: Israeli Helicopter carriers #2063576
    dienekes
    Participant

    They did consider getting an LPD-like vessel, but now is seems like they want more corvettes instead.

    IIRC, it was an overly ambitious program to construct a 10k ton helicopter carrier/cruiser, with heavy AAW and land attack weaponry.

    It seems there are some sane people in the Israeli Navy though, so this plan was cancelled.

    It now seems that the Israelis shall get a number of ~3000 ton frigates, probably based on the American LCS project.

    in reply to: Scorpion Class patrol boats.. #2063578
    dienekes
    Participant

    Yes they do… Picture of Nakat has shown that already. So, it would indeed not be impossible to have the Uran launchers exchanged for Yakhont ones.

    Thanks Severodvinsk!

    A point I am a bit confused about, is the various designations for the Kashtan system (-1, -M, etc). In the Almaz brochure it says that the Scorpion will be equiped with 2 Kashtans (which is probably impossible anyway). Is there a version of the AK-630 called Kashtan also? Perhaps a version with add-on missiles?

    in reply to: Hellenic Navy (News & Views). #2063580
    dienekes
    Participant

    Future frigate for the HN

    Does anybody care to comment/elaborate on this subject:

    The HN is in need of up to 5 new frigates untill the year 2015. The minimum set by the Navy is 14 frigates/destroyers, and the only ships with some capability in 2015 would be the 4 MEKOs and the 6 modernized Standards. Thus, 4-5 new frigates must be acquired till then.

    The options are a version of either LCF, Type-124 and FREMM. To those I should add perhaps a future MEKO design.

    What are your views? 🙂

    in reply to: Stealth Ships #2063595
    dienekes
    Participant

    HAve you guys seen the new Mexican Navy Stealth Ships????

    I’m trying to find info on them, can you guys help out?

    You probably mean the Sierra class OPVs. Here is a link:

    Sierra Class

    This is my first post in this forum, and I’m very glad being here! 🙂

    A question of my own: has anyone any info about the South Korean and Venezuelan (build by Bazan) “stealth” FACs?

    in reply to: Scorpion Class patrol boats.. #2063597
    dienekes
    Participant

    Seems to carry Uran though… Picture Courtesy of Guy Toremans, taken at IMDS2003, so this one is likely to be an export version?
    Note the waterjet propulsion, which is also used in the larger version with helicopter.

    Fitment of Yakhonts seems possible (1*2 missile VL canisters each side). Although I don’t know whether Yakhonts come in single missile canisters.
    :confused:

Viewing 14 posts - 31 through 44 (of 44 total)