dark light

firebar

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 644 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2556875
    firebar
    Participant

    If it’s not beyond 90 degrees, it’s not really a Cobra…

    Not as MiG-29 do it, but it was an early form.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2556882
    firebar
    Participant

    Abosolutely ridiculous. Firebar, I concede defeat to your stupidity.

    You are too emotional. Be more tolerant to other opinions.
    I only have said that we can not see, from video, that it is full fledged service aircraft.
    May be it is, but it is not evident from video. That is all.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2556888
    firebar
    Participant

    Read Airspacemag Aug-Sept 2006 issue article Raptor Rocks

    I am posting some snippets from that article

    Shower was joined at Oshkosh that day by Col. Thomas Bergeson, who entertained us with high-speed, excruciatingly loud passes in another Raptor while Shower flew off to collect his airplane for its next stunt. One of them he calls “the helicopter.” The airplane is falling straight down, but rotating in a spin. This is one of Shower’s favorites—the guy must have a stomach made of titanium.

    The jet can sustain over 30 degrees per second of yaw, he marvels. “Thirty degrees per second in an F-15? The beeper’s going off and I’m in an uncontrollable spin. But in an F-22, it’s totally controllable, and you’re just going ‘dit da dit da duh,’ ” he hums. “And I’ll push the pedal the other way, and it will just stop and go 30 degrees in the opposite direction.” Shower laughs in gleeful disbelief that an airplane will allow him to have this much fun…..

    He’s seen demos and videos of performances by the Russian MiG 29 and Sukhoi Su 35, and admits that their maneuverability is probably on a par with the F-22. “I can do everything they can do and vice versa,” he says. “We can all do some pretty neat stuff. But I love this part of it: That’s all they have. They don’t have the stealth , they don’t have the supercruise, they don’t have the integrated sensors, the avionics. We have an aircraft that does everything a fighter pilot has ever wanted to do. It has it all—you can tell by the price tag,” he says, (about $137 million per copy, or $338 million if you count in all the Air Force’s research costs).!

    I do not doubt this. I only say that MiG-29 and SU-27 do that maneuvers absolutely confidently in International Airshows, which F-22 can not duplicate yet.
    Of course, it is TVC aircraft and when fine tuned, it is going to do it also.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2556890
    firebar
    Participant

    Just like it couldnt do the COBRA about a year ago . Firebar i wasnt talking about limitations like what you mentioned , do IAF pilots routinly do kilbits in DACT ?? the limitations i was talking about were G load and AOA limiters which are placed during peacetime to preserve airframe life .

    All right, but ask Israeli pilots which, in F-15s, took part in simulated combat with Luftwaffe Mig-29 in Sardinia, how they fared ?

    Note that it was downgraded Mig-29 with tuned down engines.

    Regarding service limitations of AoA, this is not imposed as a measure to preserve airframe life.
    Every fighter has its own AoA limit, beyond which it is prone to departure.
    Look at, for instance, F-18 manual. It says that beyound 50 to 55 degrees AoA, the clean F-18 will surely depart and will end in a Falling Leaf from which escape is almost impossible.

    There is no such constraints for Mig-29 or SU-27.

    Regarding 360 degree instantanius back flips the word is still out , DOZER the demo pilot for the raptor said that he has seen most of flanker displays and that the raptor can pretty much the same with its TVC , and that they wont be displaying its full Airshow manueverability untill 2008 when they actually set out to a big air show the likes of Farnborough ( probably RIAT ) .

    I would say that it is not safe for F-22 yet to demonstrate Cobra maneuver in International airshows. To do it, the fighter has to be absolutely safe from departure. It is not easy to acomplish at 90 degrees AoA.

    Where did u not get the fact that the pilot has said that the F-22 has perfromed the COBRA in operational conditions with 8 missiles and a representative fuel load , and no special modifications were made ??

    Why is it so hard for you to believe something that has been laid out so simple!!!

    I believe it. But this is not enough. The pilot has to be able to repeat this maneuver every time without fear that his aircraft will depart.
    Only then it will be ready for International Airshows.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2556897
    firebar
    Participant

    Firebar,
    I do not know where you get your aeronautical background or even your information but you seem to be incorrect.

    Let’s start with the F16.

    You stated:

    The perfect aerodynamics is far more important than Fly-by-wire controls.
    Look at F-16. It can not do more that 26 degrees because it aerodynamics do not allow it. Despite Fly-by-wire. This can not help.
    Or look at Tornado ADV. The same applies to it.

    Whilst you didn’t have much credibility to begin with, do you actually know the reason why it is limited 26 deg AOA (BTW, you can override this during a deep stall condition for recovery).

    Unstable, AFT Cg. The FLCS keeps the plane flying level. If it was there it would flip OVER. It has nothing to do with aerodynamic capability of the aircraft.

    Doggy, you have to understand that F-16 is service limited to 26 degrees AoA because it was found that at about 30 degrees AoA it has strong propensity to departure from controlled flight. This often end in a flat spin.

    This is aerodynamic characteristic of F-16s unstable configuration.
    There is no FBW system which can correct this, and allow more AoA.

    Regarding Tornado ADV, it is not unstable, but again, FBW controls can not substitute for a bad aerodynamics.

    There are no Alpha limits on the Raptors, you only use AOA that you can CONTROL which means the ability to maneuver the plane at these high AOA.

    Every fighter has its AoA limit. Do not delude yourself.
    That is max AoA from which it is possible to surely recover the aircraft without departure.

    The Flanker and even the Fulcrum suffers the same problems at high AOA. They have don’t have that much control in the ‘post stall region’. The MPO switch enabled, low speeds, light weights and changed Cg, give these planes the ability to put their nose up past vertical (90-100 degrees) in less than three seconds. While losing a lot of speed, control authority goes to NIL as you get closer to ZERO airspeed.

    They have no problems at all. These are only fighters which have such high controllability at high AoA that they are able to demonstrate Tail slide and Cobra maneuvers before crowd in international airshows regularly.
    Remember that american pilots say they are amazed with MiG-29s or SU-27s contlollability at high Alpha.

    This maneuver isn’t about aerodynamic qualities of an airframe but the unstability margin.

    Do you understand that unstability has a bad influence on high AoA flights.

    At 60 Alpha, the F22 has more control authority than the majority of operational fighters. This includes the Flanker, Fulcrum, S Hornet, Hornet, .etc.

    It is your wish.
    Do you know that Russian fighters do a Super Cobra and Hook maneuvers, again on International Airshows. These are totaly out of the grasp of F-22.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2557320
    firebar
    Participant

    Wow, you really can’t read can you?
    There are no public numbers on the Raptor’s transient AoA

    .
    Of course there are. Read Aviation Week. It had 60 degrees max transient. There are many articles about that.
    Do anybody read Aviation Week here ?

    From the video, in a normal service Raptor, the pilot was able to reach about 120 degrees AoA. It is not a test plane. This was at an airshow in a jet loaded with 8 missiles and almost full tanks.

    We can not see that from the video.
    Is there any source to confirm that ?

    Raptor pilots say that they have no problem doing any of the post-stall manuevers of the Flanker series.

    You are too optimistic about Raptors abilities, are you?
    For one thing, it can not do a Super Cobra, like SU-37. A full turn about lateral axis.
    Note that it was demonstrated on Farnborough airshow.

    I want a Raptor to do it.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2557322
    firebar
    Participant

    Go watch the video.

    I have a video of F-14 doing Cobra maneuver , to about 80 degrees, during tests in 70-es.
    But service F-14 can not go beyond 50 degrees.
    That is the point.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2557327
    firebar
    Participant

    No they are not a whole generation ahead. The Raptor’s fly-by-wire system is far, far more advanced than of the any Flankers. I would say that the FBW system has even more to do with pointability than thrust vectoring.
    Doing a 360 around a lateral axis deos not mean it’s the ultimate, most manueverable jet.

    The perfect aerodynamics is far more important than Fly-by-wire controls.
    Look at F-16. It can not do more that 26 degrees because it aerodynamics do not allow it. Despite Fly-by-wire. This can not help.
    Or look at Tornado ADV. The same applies to it.

    With MiG-29 and SU-27, the Russians managed to built aerodynamicaly perfect fighters.
    Even without TVC they are virtualy departure proof, and controllable to more that 90 degrees AoA. This is an outstanding feature.

    The MiG-29 has demonstated, in Farnborough 1989, a Cobra maneuver with 6 missiles under wings !!!

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2557331
    firebar
    Participant

    Can I just make a point on the stupidity of saying something is “limited” in service.
    Do you really think a pilot is going to give 2 ****s about the manual when they has an R-77 or similar boring in? Get real!!!
    In war, peacetime limits go out the window.

    That is the point about high AoA flights. To have a control at very high AoA to evade missiles, hostile aircraft or to bring its weapons to enemy.

    That is why the more AoA , the better. It is not airshow stunt only.

    But every aircraft has its own limit beyond which it will departure from controlled flight.
    For now, the Raptor has 60 degrees limit for service aircraft, if it is not lifted recently. The test pilot maneuvers do not account.
    Is there any recent source to prove otherwise ?

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2557339
    firebar
    Participant

    At the moment there are no limitations vis a vis service aircraft ( these are from my personal experience with talking to raptor maintaince guys and pilots aswell as going through dozer) they are allowed to do whatever they want within the ROE’s of the engagement concerned .

    There has to be limit to Raptors AoA. The only fighters which have no limit of AoA are SU-37 or SU-30 MKI, which have TVC and performed 360 degrees, full turn about lateral axis.

    The Raptor can not do it despite TVC.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2558419
    firebar
    Participant

    Firebar the 60 degrees is very much there , the 60 degrees was for sustained AOA and said nothing for Instantanious AOA .

    The 60 degrees sustained AoA is too much for F-22.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2558421
    firebar
    Participant

    Isn’t the Flanker limited to something like 30 degrees in service? Of course, service limitations dont stop the Flankers.
    And in some videos you can see the ‘FF’ markings on the tail. afaik EMD Raptors are not cleared for full flight envelope anyway.

    The Flanker has , so called, soft limit to about 30 degrees, but it can be pushed any time to 120 degrees, if need be. And that can be done with aerodynamic controls, which is truly amazing.

    Regarding F-22 limitations, I can not find any source which state that service aircraft can be pushed to more than 60 degrees.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2558813
    firebar
    Participant

    I remember that you were claiming 60 degrees max AOA for the raptor about a year back . Go to fencesheck forums and you can communicate with the pilot who performed the RAPTOR COBRA and he likes to take it to about 25 degrees past right angle and hang in there before bringing the nose back . For that particular performance he flew out of langley with a fuel load and 8 A2A missiles , flew subsonic ( airspace limitations) , reached NJ , performed a routine while his wingman did some real neet high speed low alt. flyby’s which were LLLLOOOOUUUDDD according to people there and both flew back to langley . Now if that jet isnt in combat condition then i dont know what else . These are operational jets , in an operational squadron flying operational loads , infact DOZER ( the pilot) says that he prefers this way rather then using a configuration that isnt combat practical. Read dozers remarks posted by myself and Frazier in the various threads related to this news.

    May be the limit of 60 degrees is lifted now.
    Do you have any source, regarding service aircraft limitation ?

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2558815
    firebar
    Participant

    Firebar, that was at an airshow in New Jersey with a production Langley jet.

    Are you sure? Any source?

    Before, you were saying that it couldn’t pass 60 degrees alpha and now you’re saying that it would be unusual if it couldn’t? :rolleyes:

    I said that it is service limited to 60 degrees, according to serious technical sources, Aviation Week etc.
    Do you have any such source which state that it can do 90 degrees Alpha or more, with service aircraft?
    (Please do not state generals.)

    Regarding TVC, you must admit that Russians are a whole generation ahead in aircraft controllability techniques.
    The SU-37, with TVC, can do 360 degrees, a full circle around lateral axis, and it demonstrated this astounding maneuver in airshows.

    in reply to: F-22 Doing A Cobra Maneuver #2558817
    firebar
    Participant

    So? The YF-17 did it first, and it did do it in airshows. Next.

    I would like to see picture or video. I have info that it could do about 65 degrees on tests.

Viewing 15 posts - 196 through 210 (of 644 total)