dark light

Aurel

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 316 through 330 (of 939 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: F-22, Typhoon, Rafale, and F16's Block 60 #2436195
    Aurel
    Participant

    I don’t need the ear ache that I’ll get from some of our French chums if I say:

    “I was told that…..”

    But sticking to the less contentious aspects, it sounds as though ATLC is viewed as being more useful than ‘Flag because of who you get to train with.

    The Typhoon blokes seemed to be particularly pleased with themselves, walking tall having “kicked ass and taken names…”

    What kind of exercise is that ? I mean is the red team in any way restricted ?
    If the answer is yes, then your comment could be translated into: “the Typhoon pilots were lucky to fly in the blue team today”.

    Aurel
    Participant
    Aurel
    Participant

    BTW, quite some french seem convince that the USA are throwing all their might at stopping Dassault/France/you name it from selling the Rafale, because of it being one of the main, if not the only, challenger to the F35 which isn’t controlled by them.

    Well, it would make sense. Dassault is probably the last western competitor in the fighter market of post 2020.

    in reply to: Budget and Capability, UK and India compared #2437327
    Aurel
    Participant

    Still, one has to ask if the MRCA is still necessary. I mean there are additional MKI’s on order and soon (TM) there will be LCA Mk II available.
    MiG-27 and Jags are getting updated.
    And as source for tech… well, AESA tech is provided by Israelis and single crystal blades by the Russians.
    Even if India wants western engine tech, this is already obtained via the LCA engine.
    Plus the MKI’s already comes with a modern (partly french) cockpit.
    Are those additional MKI’s not enough to fill the gap till FGFA arrives ?

    in reply to: F-35 News and Discussion #2438503
    Aurel
    Participant

    Even with this very pessimistic number it is the world’s largest fighter programme.

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode IX #2440222
    Aurel
    Participant

    Official first flight doesn’t mean it’s the true first flight of an aircraft.

    in reply to: Tanker Draft RFP party #2440227
    Aurel
    Participant
    in reply to: IRAQ AIRFORCE NEWS (F-16 DEAL AND OTHERS) #2434728
    Aurel
    Participant

    Iraq is a very interesting challenge for any armchair general. I mean you have excellent human resources, potentially the money to buy tons of shiny toys and a very “interesting” neighbourhood.
    My ideas:
    MiG-21: there should be plenty of airframes avaible in workable condition. Issue could be to get enough from the same standard.
    Mirage F1: most probably the hottest candidate to get a basic capability as quick as possible. There are at least some pilots familiar with the type, and some airframes available.
    Su-25: This one could be tricky. The factory in Tbilisi has been destroyed, and I have no idea how many airframes are stored and in a condition to be restored. (Leaving aside the potential trouble of getting spare parts).

    On the bright side: Iraq should have relatively minor trouble to get a capable chopper force. Mi-171 and Mi-24something still roll out of the Kazan factory and are in my opinion still the best choice for Iraq.

    So, my take on the issue:
    1-2 Squadrons of Mirage F1 for airpolicing and for starting fast jet operations again.
    1-2 Squadrons of MiG-21 for pilots and ground crews familiar with Russian aircraft. They are cheap, disposable and will be sufficient for getting pilots some stick time.
    As jettrainers I would go with L-139. Plus adding some L-159 ALCA’s for light ground attack. Very cost effective aircraft in my opinion.

    At the same time, I would look for new aircraft. My personal favourite would Gripen. Relatively cheap, excellent capability for the money you pay, independent weapon choices. Only downside is the engine choice for NG, but hey, nothing is perfect.
    Bell 412, Mi-171 and Mi-24 should mostly cover the needs for rotary wing aircraft.
    All the minor stuff ist mostly covered I believe, with contracts in place for training and liason aircraft.
    Adding some Erieyes to the mix + a Russian made layered airdefence (Pantsyr, Tor, S-300) would round things up.

    in reply to: MMRCA news (including the Rafale bid) #2439171
    Aurel
    Participant
    in reply to: UAE Mirage-2000-9s to be on sale #2439370
    Aurel
    Participant

    Oh yes I see it coming. The Chinese stop selling plastic slippers to the rest of the world, because the evil French and Arabians sold old aircraft to Taiwan.
    The sky is falling !:rolleyes:

    in reply to: UAE Mirage-2000-9s to be on sale #2440257
    Aurel
    Participant

    So what ? It has absolutely zero impact on UAE’s oil exports. China still has a certain demand, so they buy the same amount from the world market as before. Only that now Saudi oil goes to China and UAE’s to the US or Europe.

    in reply to: Saab JAS 39 Gripen Info # 2 #2443392
    Aurel
    Participant
    in reply to: Rafale news VI #2443498
    Aurel
    Participant

    What I find very interesting is the part about the inefficiency of HMS + 9X. Would be nice to learn more bout this.

    Aurel
    Participant

    Scorpion, I beg to differ about Afganistan. While this may become important in the future, both the British and Germans lack airframes for QRA duties.
    You certainly know JG 74’s situation.
    Similar things are true for the British. The Russians were kind enough to remind us about the importance of enough aiframes for QRA duties. The British have the additional burden of Falkland deployments.
    Till there are enough operational airframes available, we have enough matured platforms at hand for deployment to Afganistan.
    By the way, we don’t have any Tornados in Afganistan tasked with a2g, and the British have enough Tornadoes and Harriers.

    Aurel
    Participant

    All that moaning about late a2g weapon integration is absolutely irrelevant for Germany. (And for the UK, too, I believe).
    Priority was Pilot training (done) and QRA (in progress). Till our fighterbomber wings get the aircraft, the necessary stuff will be integrated.
    Until then, priority is to get all wings tasked with QRA duty equipped and operational with Typhoons. (Which is still a problem, because of aircraft given to export customers).

Viewing 15 posts - 316 through 330 (of 939 total)