Q: The visit of HH prince Khaled Bin Sultan assistant minister of defense to Paris where he met with the French minister of defense, does that has any relevance to the French media reports during HH crown prince visit that the kingdom is considering to buy French Rafale aircrafts? Has the kingdom agreed that a bridge will be erected between Abu Dhabi and Doha that passes across Saudi territory and that a Qatari pipeline to Kuwait will be placed across Saudi territory?
A: We have long-established relations with France in the area of defense. The visit of HH Khaled is made upon an invitation from the French government in continuation to the cooperation talks between the two parties. Regarding Rafale aircrafts, nothing is announced. You may contact ministry of defense and aviation for details.
http://www.mofa.gov.sa/Detail.asp?InSectionID=3953&InNewsItemID=36934
seems tha red shark exercises made more influences in saudies minds than hopes of a british tornado “saudi patient” member there!
“According to the data I have “
Smoke on the WAATERRRRRRRRRRR!!!
Le ridicule ne tue pas!
These are the clows who will fly that piece of junk called Mirage. 🙁
maybe it’s time to stop drugs! junky mate
the only stuff more mature the eurofighter that the british call typhoon lol, have over rafale is crash, delays, flaws, overweight , obsolescence!
what is the plot, why saudies wouldn’t choose a US or UK plane?
politics what?
Bush do what he want, and the saudi gov is fighting bin laden too, so speculations about politics ares so stupid!
Rafale/Typhoon:
Top Speed: M 2/M 2,02
Top Speed at S/L: 1390 kph (M 1,14)/1390 kph (M 1,14)
Supercruise: M 1,2/M 1,2-1,3
Ceiling: 18000 m/18000 m
Climb rate: >305 m/sec /~315 m/sec
Climb time to: 40000 ft in <2 min/42000 ft 1,5 min
G-Load: – 3,2 to 3,6 g/+9 g /-3 G/+9 g
g-acceleration: 10-12 g/sec /15 g/sec
ITR: 32°/sec />30°/sec
STR: 24°/sec /25°/sec
Operational AoA: 32°/30°-35°
Rollrate: 270-290°/sec /250°/sec
range on internal fuel: >2100 km/2600 km
ferry range: 5593 km/3700 km+
max. CAP range: 1853 km/1389 km
Scorpion, u r a such funny guy , really!
i like yours datas, very funny!
you should get a job to flug revue!
if the russian decide to build a stealth aircraft, with actual techologies, it will be far cheaper than F22 and they know alot about aeronautics too!
now Russia isn’t an enemy, and it would be nice to see the exeptional russian abilities to make formidable planes going on!
“”What I want to say is most, if not all modern fighters today could fullfil the tasks which Rafale can or will be able to fullfil, if it would be required””
no, i say that rafale will do it 2 times better to do AoA and AoG simultanously, eurofighter will not, Why??????
because you’ll have to reconfigurate you plane to have the same performances than a rafale mate, Rafale will haven’t need to change asraam by more amraam or to remove tanks to put SCALP or mixing both with fews effect, Mica do the job of an asraam and amraam meaning each time you put 2 missiles a short and MVR rafale will economise one point and lot of weight, an more you even can launch it and recalculate the targeting later, you eurofighter can’t fiht with this reality!
that in france they call Omnirole!
“”I will come to that topic later in the part 3 of my comparison.
Only one thing. There was a nice report from a french journalist flying in the backseat of Rafale B302. He claimed the takeoffweight was 16,4t with a 1250 l tank and 4 MICAs.
So let’s subtract 16,4 t minus 1,4 t (should be the weight of tank and for MICAs). So you have 15 t.
Oh it’s becoming interesting let’s subtract 4,3 t of internal fuel and we have at least 10,7 t empty weight for a Rafale B.
oohps weight topic again “””
Scorpion you are a gugus wasting his time requoting false or biased datas!
you even forget that the eurofighter was deigned for quick air attack alert from the red, it’s first role is AoA superiority, Rafale first rolme is AoA, Strike, carrier and nuke and was designed with that in mind, your talks about multi role is so ridiculous, the F18 was designed in mind to replace the tomcat, and reveleted as a good swing role plane later!
don’t be childish!
how could you eurofighter would do the same rates of mission, doing the same as a Rafale that have 2 more weight points under wings, where do you place your tanks and SCALP? dumby! a Rafale will always have the edge of payload and best versatility, i remind you that Rafale have 14 points 5 weight “heavy load”, eurofighter have 13 with 3 wet!
and pls don’t speculate a weight of Rafale on the B302, you looklike more ridiculous!
for your information the B302 is a tester, i mean this planes is fulfilled with control devices and systems checkers, all tester ares around 10% heavier, since the plane history started!
so i like you all pointing the 13g g limit of the eurofrighter, good, but your pilot would be prying to have side stick and a 32° seat to cope with all this G “limit”, lol, he would dream to be into a rafale, isn’t it?
you liltle buggers try to convince with a short leg overweight plane who crashed and was delyaed, that politicians don’t beleive in no more, who lost challenges around the world against older fighters, with a 80’s type cockpit, a stick between the legs without modern anti g device, poor charge and wet points, and a mechanical sensor that ares usual in this type actually on fighters, with a bit upgraded FLIR/IIR systems to be the F22 challenger, or Rafale one, hey, vous nous faites beaucoup rire!
seems you have lots of time to waste for stheril blah blah! do it!
“Rafale was developed for carrier operations to and as a multirole fighters”
no no, Omnirole , multi role are first designed around one main mission, and have abilities to do others!
Rafale was disigned for AoA, AoG, Recce, Carrier operations, Nuke operations.. at the first draws..
and Scorpion, Dassault anticipated all missions and futur devices coming up , they placed ballasts and mock up into the rafales from the first flight! all that to set up the roll CoG and all aerodynamics comportment of the plane!!
Flug is german and janes british, all journalists ares ex national aerospace ingeneers, that get them close relationship with thier ex compagnies, in return to downgrade the challengers performances, its obvious in each countries!
When Dassault speak about 10t plane, i will repreat for the last time, it’s because Rafale have so much derivated that putting 7 weight is ridiculous, anyway it’s classified!
now reprocess all your datas about typhoon performances!
typhoon TW ratio, with 5 t “fuel and weapons”
180kN/(16.3t*9.8)160kN=1.12
same with Rafale and the actual M88-2E4 more powerfull…
155kN/(14.1t*9.8)137kN=1.13
can reprocess the ITR and ROLL rate etc etc etc for me pls?
good
“typhoon replacing 9 specialised aircrafts??? there ares planes sweeping the soil??? “
Tmor, pls, don’t get me all type and brand of aircrafts!
ares you all dumbies or what?
when i talk about specialised aircrafts, i don’t speak about brands, i’m talking about Missions specialised planes and roles, so what the diferences between a Tornado, F18, F16 etc etc etc etc launching an air missile??
Rafale will replace Mirage IV recce, the SEM and the Nuke Mirage 2000..
is the typhoon doing same? lol
“Whatever some journalist saying that typhoon’s MMI, radar, data fusion are better than Rafale’s (using the pretended customers point of view), this point is quite unclear… End of debate ?””
yes it’s worth that last times eurofighter presented for international export chalenges, the clients focused on it and prefered the challengers!
hey hey, sorry, it’s coming funny!
Typhoon is 13g limit???
well even the MoD discuss about the g limit of the typhoon +9/-3
Rafale G limit ares +11/-3.6
typhoon replacing 9 specialised aircrafts??? there ares planes sweeping the soil???
where the typhoon was designed for aircrafts carrier, or strikes? recce?
i don’t speak about somes of the roles of a aircraft will be able to do, i talk about the first design, and it seems that the eurofighter was designed as an air superiority jet, not a striker or others roles in mind first, as the rafale was designed as a omnirole fighter, being equal to all task he will have!
it seems that you are talking about sensors fusion, the F16 block 60, F15 K and M2k – 5 -9 ares sensors fusion, what is your point?
i talk about the fact that integrated sensors and software of rafale give it the multitask abilities to strike and follow land maps while simultanously able to AoA any thread, it’s the only one in the next gen fighter to do it, you say that captor is able of 70* angle “to what distance?? “, it’s ridiculous comparated to a fixed array, as i said if dassault was for a “captor mecha like” radar system , they would put a RDY 2, i don’t even talk about the doppler’s modes and speed sweeps diferences between a old tech as captor and an electronic array as RBE2!
beleive me, if the captor was a title winner, all the yanks and others would put back an old mecha antenna on their products!
The thread is not dead !!!
Have a look, i got a discussion with a spanish guy about eurofighter against F16. When i asked him if the EF2000 was able to sustain 9g… look at what he answered me :I’m sorry, this was a bad joke… I found it there : http://www.f-16.net/f-16_forum_printview-t-145-start-60.html
near the bottom of the page (search for LeeRichardson).Wasn’t very funny ?… 😮
remind me when the M2k-5 of the cigognes did thier first sorties in 2001 Nato florene TLP, the F16mlu was pale foe, so the first minute is alway in the hands of Mirage boys, so eurofighter shoul deal the F16 as quicly!
“”I know about the capabilities of OSF thanks. By the way PIRATE is also fully integrated within other sensors. That’s called sensor fusion realizied via the AIS in the Typhoon and via SNA in the Rafale. Short all data (OSF/PIRATE, SPECTRA/DASS and CAPTOR/RBE-2 as well as MIDS data will be processed and fused together. The pilot sees a complete tactical picture with informations from all sources and the single systems can interact with each other as well.””
what are you talking about Scorpion, i don’t understand, the Dass is an evolution of actal FLIR systems, what i say to you is that OSF have twice the devices coupled with a cam and all other sensors, say me where the DASS Pirate do a better integration???
say where your captor will point when plane will comes from 10h and another to 14h ??
the best fighter is the first to kill, i don’t say the rafale will be the first, i say you that Rafale was developed with more needs at his basement about replacing 7 specialised aircrafts than typhoon eurofighter or whatever you want!
university of shefield, pls scorpion, there are about 80 university working on doppler signals, Thales is just at the final stage, if it isn’t already fitted on somes rafales, ONERA is working on since 1986…..
Scorpion for you the eurostuff is best, good, its cool, for you!