dark light

Tom Kilkenny

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 42 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: 70 years ago tonight – Nuremberg Raid #934799
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    I used to think average losses of 4% (someone will let me know if I’m wrong) for each operation seemed not unsustainable but it’s incredible to think they were able to maintain operations night after night, week after week. While the odds for the individual might have seemed reasonable for one trip, a tour of 25 or more meant, of course, that you were statistically unlikely to make it. The maths is frightening!

    in reply to: POW Photos WW2 #933065
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Given the German predilection for taking photos I’d be surprised if POWs didn’t find themselves being snapped many, many times! Doubtless someone will know if there’s any records with photos available online but more interesting (to me anyway) are photos of recently captured airmen. There’s one in the most recent ‘Britain at War’ of a chap shot down during a rhubarb operation over France. I found myself wondering what must have been going through his mind at that moment with the terrible realisation dawning that he was no longer a free man!

    in reply to: Cosford Aerospace Museum Early 80's #996644
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Don’t they all look a lot better outside! I know, I know…

    in reply to: Why goggles? #978520
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Thanks everyone. It makes sense to me now!

    in reply to: Identifying an overflying aircraft at night #515084
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    An ATP? It’s a turbo-prop aircraft, isn’t it? If that’s what it was, apologies for mis-identifying what I heard as piston-engined. I confess I was hoping for something a bit more exotic!

    in reply to: Identifying an overflying aircraft at night #515350
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Thanks everyone for the responses. Let me know if you find anything Shane!

    in reply to: Who betrayed the Bomber Boys? #1021262
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    By the end of the war, those in power regarded the indiscriminate bombing of German cities as an embarrassment: that much is clear.

    On a less contentious note, I thought the makers of the programme had made a decent effort to find some less familiar newsreel to illustrate the argument.

    Tom

    in reply to: Who betrayed the Bomber Boys? #1033633
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    By the end of the war, those in power regarded the indiscriminate bombing of German cities as an embarrassment: that much is clear.

    On a less contentious note, I thought the makers of the programme had made a decent effort to find some less familiar newsreel to illustrate the argument.

    Tom

    in reply to: Beaches of France by Connie #1081295
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    What a little gem – and the last couple of shots of the Connie are especially wonderful. It has such a personality! Will anyone in 50 years think the same of a 757 do you think?

    in reply to: General Discussion #263152
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Sorry, I’m not sure if you are agreeing or disagreeing with me there?

    Agreeing with you that some people pay taxes, a significant proportion of which goes towards education, and then choose to pay for their own children to be educated privately. Not agreeing to any suggestion that this was somehow unfair on the poor darlings!

    Tom

    in reply to: The current state of affairs #1851563
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Sorry, I’m not sure if you are agreeing or disagreeing with me there?

    Agreeing with you that some people pay taxes, a significant proportion of which goes towards education, and then choose to pay for their own children to be educated privately. Not agreeing to any suggestion that this was somehow unfair on the poor darlings!

    Tom

    in reply to: The current state of affairs #1851890
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    As Creaking Door says:

    “It is a bit like private education; those that send their children to private schools still pay their taxes and the state school system has fewer children to teach. The private schools all pay their taxes too.”

    And you could say that they pay their taxes to educate the teachers, nurses, doctors, police officers, firefighters, refuse collectors and street sweepers (not educated privately) that we all need to make society operate.

    Tom

    in reply to: General Discussion #263561
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    As Creaking Door says:

    “It is a bit like private education; those that send their children to private schools still pay their taxes and the state school system has fewer children to teach. The private schools all pay their taxes too.”

    And you could say that they pay their taxes to educate the teachers, nurses, doctors, police officers, firefighters, refuse collectors and street sweepers (not educated privately) that we all need to make society operate.

    Tom

    in reply to: East Anglia Film Archive now online #1065191
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    If you’ve not had a look at the Honington film yet, you should! Warning: you’ll be hooked so don’t plan on doing anything for the 25 minutes or so the film runs for!

    in reply to: Dambusters Declassified – BBC2, 17th Oct 8PM. #1105658
    Tom Kilkenny
    Participant

    Found it really interesting. Thought Martin Shaw a decent choice as presenter too. Always good to see that ‘stars’ share our interests!

Viewing 15 posts - 16 through 30 (of 42 total)