Read my post carefully prior to launching your missiles.. I have said, that not all of them are gonna be used in combat…
Heres another missile then, I am pretty sure not every F-15 in the USAF inventory has seen combat either, but they are still needed to enable the air force to field enough planes on the actual frontline, for every aircraft in combat I expect you would need at least another 2 as training/overhaul/attrition are also taken into account
No reason to get disturbed. The program ain’t gonna be killed anytime soon.. Is it for you, as an average US citizen such damn important to have 30-40+ more Raptors above your head? WHat difference does it make, except increased defense budget, which is going to be missed in the civil sphere?
We all know they ain’t gonna be used in combat all, anyway..
yeah Flex, just like the F-117, B-2, F-15E have never been used in combat either………..
Coming all the way to the Northsea then?
Scaring the other side which whom you are in disagreement of the consequences resulting from possible non-cooperation is of course essential for power projection. Strange to question that even though I did not speak of scaring anyone, but about this purchase being more a symbol of nationalism (erased by the moderator) than of being essential to the Indian Navy. I really doubt this small a squandron of aircraft could without support of other forces (primordially large numbers on the ground) could do anything in Africa. What could such aircraft possibly do in a chaos ridden situation of coup except making nice recon flights to provide some intelligence? For flight operations on the Maldives you don’t need carrier based aircraft as that country is right around the corner viewed from India. Same story with Bangladesh. Rather peculiar to spend billions on a carrier just for being a good will ambassador, there are more cost-effective means to do that.
The Vikrant and its Harriers certainly never gave India the power projection capabilty it needs, I dont see the MIG-29s being a huge quantum leap over those…
Lets not forget alot of these African countries that may have a coup also happen to have MIG-29s, SU-27s and the like…..and in terms of power projection, your “beat” stops right where the South Africans on one side and the Aussies on the other, want it to…..
I have not even mentioned the US and two future RN carriers…
I am getting “Dr Stranglove” type images of a Cowboy riding a nuclear bomb and going “Ye Ha”! Is that bad? 😮
The last Genie’s W-25 warhead were retired in Dec1984 and dismantled by 1986. Dirty little stinker, pure plutonium fission. One of the few nuclear warheads operated by the National Guards then. Today Guards and Reserves regulary train with nuclear warheads. Bush was here.
There were a couple of incidents involving the W-25, esp in Canda. A John Clearwater wrote a book about it in 1998 or so.
wow, Bush already had his finger on a nuclear trigger way back then as an ANG pilot? Scary…….. 😀
A question best put to Gary D. O’Loughlin and Woolf P.Gross of Northrop Grumman, which is why I mentioned the manufacturer’s statement.
Should’nt be impossible with an uprated engine, reduced payload and modified undercarriage. The Alize, using the full streach, could take-off without Catapults or a ramp, from Foch. The question is how much that would cost?
Do you have a link or details of the new E-2C version, first time I have heard of it, and why was it not offered to France?
Arabs aren’t the problem. Of the 66% of our consumption that is imported, Arab and/or Persian Gulf states account for around 25%. Clearly we don’t rely all that much on Arab oil.
http://www.eia.doe.gov/neic/rankings/crudebycountry.htm
And ANWR’s reserves are projected as anywhere from 9 to 16 billion barrels. If it is only 9 billion, we could ignore Arab oil for around 10 years. Think about what that would mean for us, and what would happen to oil prices worldwide in the interim. During those 10 years, we can either reduce our consumption of oil through getting rid of SUVs and developing more nuclear power plants, and/or gradually increase our imports from non-OPEC/non-Arab nations. End result: we can write off the Middle East once and for all, as both an oil supplier and a terrorist hotbed.
Sean
I may be wrong, but I think US reserves will run dry way before the Arab ones and dependency on Mid East oil will increase not decrease….
It was almost the other way around. (Then again, the Mirage gets constantly thrashed by the MiG-29A in a2a DACT) The SHAR performed very well against the Mirages of No.1 sqn. but is severly limited in other feilds. It is hardly comparable to the MiG-29K or Rafale in most regimes despite it’s excellent performance close-in. That alone makes a world of difference for the Gorshkov.
The ADS is also slated to get the MiG-29K. Now SHARs are’nt exactly going to add training value to that are they? :rolleyes:
Same could be said of the Sea Eagle and the Tu-142 and Il-38 but that did happen. The R-77 could be accomodated (despite weight) but the nose requires considerable modification, even for the EL/M-2032. The latter is in no way equivalent to the Barsik and only two or at the most four BVRAAMs can be accomdated – half the load on the MiG-29K.
AMRAAMs are still privy equipment and India is’nt even a regular Raytheon Customer. Speaking of the latter, they seem pretty confident of a reduced-payload STOBAR E-2C variant. If we could speculate on a whole bunch of things (hull condition, what the IN *may/could/should have* bought etc etc, we might as well speculate on that as well. 😀
Harry
If the French had to extend the flight deck of the Charles De Gaulle to enable it to operate the E-2C, please explain how it would operate off the smaller Gorshkov…….?
Oh BTW These 125 A/C are meant for the strategic command , which means they will be used for delivering N-Weapons and strategic defence of Imp Installations.
I dont think that will strictly be the case, should IAF tactical commanders need them to strike at enemy air bases or help with air defence then I am sure this will be the case. I doubt they would just be assigned two specific roles and not be used on a much more flexible basis…..
when are the QF-4s going to be retired and substituded by QF-16s?.
with countries spending $40 million plus on the latest versions of the viper I dont see that happening for a long time…
And your arguments about political deals is just wrong Steve and Sev, its just not the way it works in INdia and I do not expect you guys to understand, simply because you do not live there, ther was never any political will to buy an aircraft carrier and then push the deal, it was always the IN pushing the deal, had politicians pushed the deal, the opposition would have jumped and the Govt would have been changed on the spot, Indian politicians are really smart when it comes to politisizing aquisitions, not that smart when it comes to pushing things under the carpet or even I would argue, having strategic vision, I am sorry but that is the reality in INdia, do not compare a different country to the countries you know about, you cannot have a rationale debate based on “your opinion” of INdian politics, unless you have studied it for years, you really do not know, you get more brownie points for attacking the Gorshkov as a carrier rather than a ship with a bad hull (disproved by countless official IN checkups) and so called political interference.
Absolute nonsense! You dont need to have a phd in Indian politics to contribute to a debate about it.Reading articles, the internet and plain logic can suffice. A reasonably intelligent person can work it out. Your attitude is patronising , the sort of “only I understand my country” attitude. You yourself make no hesitation in debating about US,UK and Pakistani issues. Try not to take offense, just MY opinion…
loading the 6 C-130s to Indonesia
Pakistani troops on their way to Indonesia and Sri Lanka
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4142539.stm
Foreign NGOs seek Andamans access
Homeless tribals on Car Nicobar island in a makeshift camp
International aid agencies are urging the authorities in the tsunami-stricken Andaman and Nicobar Islands to let them join the relief effort there.
Much of the Andamans is off-limits to foreigners because of security concerns and to protect aboriginal tribes from outside influences.
A senior Oxfam official says the policy means that “valuable time” is being lost in the aid effort.
More than 6,000 people in the area are confirmed dead or missing.
But there is no confirmation of the fate of at least 10,000 others still unaccounted for.
‘Accelerating miseries’
“This closed-door approach of not allowing [foreign aid agencies] is delaying relief efforts,” Shaheen Nilofer, the head of Oxfam’s operations in eastern India said, the Associated Press news agency reports.
ANDAMAN AND NICOBAR
About 400 islands, 38 inhabited
Islands are peaks of submerged mountain range
Indian territory, area of 8,249 sq km
Population around 370,000, about 100,000 in Port Blair
Number of tribes, including Jarawas, Onges and Shompens
“Valuable time has been lost because of this delay. [India is] accelerating the miseries of the poor people… Somewhere, someone has to be responsible.”
Medecins Sans Frontieres was the first international aid agency to get relief supplies to the Andamans.
The BBC’s Subir Bhaumik, in the capital Port Blair, says the supplies are still lying in the airport there.
MSF’s head of operations in India, Stuart Zimble, told the BBC: “We remain optimistic the government will allow our team of doctors to get to the outlying islands and administer medical care.”
Some 400,000 people live on the Andamans archipelago, which comprises more than 300 islands and islets and some 200 rocky outcrops.
The ban on foreigners visiting much of the Andamans is partly because India has an important military base on Car Nicobar island that was devastated by the tsunami, with heavy loss of life.
In addition the islands are home to a number of tribes who make up some of the most primitive peoples on the planet.
Foreigners are not allowed access to the areas where they live.
“We can understand the sensitivity of the Indian government, but we are prepared to work together with the administration,” Stuart Zimble said.
“We want our doctors to team up with local doctors and spread out into the islands so that we can save a many people as possible.”
Cholera fears
US officials say they will begin a major relief work “the moment we have permission”.
The Indian military distributing aid on one of the islands
“We hope we will be allowed to join the relief effort,” Souribh Sen of the US consulate in Calcutta told the BBC.
A team from the United Nations children’s agency, Unicef, now in Port Blair, says the authorities asked them to bring supplies of oral saline and lactate, indicating fears of outbreaks of cholera.
The Indian army said on Sunday that planes had dropped food and water to tsunami survivors on all the inhabited islands in the Andamans and Nicobar chain.
Outbreaks of disease have been reported on remote southern islands.
Our correspondent says aid workers have been worried about possible outbreaks of water-borne diseases because the tsunami polluted wells and other sources of drinking water.
Difficult conditions
Earlier on Sunday, the military commander in charge of the relief effort said the most remote locations had now been reached.
More than 3,000 people were evacuated to the mainland and relief camps in Port Blair on Friday.
Relief efforts in the archipelago’s 38 inhabited islands have been hampered by the destruction of most of the islands’ jetties.
The island chain, close to the epicentre of last Sunday’s earthquake, has also felt a number of aftershocks.
Easing compensation
On the Indian mainland, aid operations are stepping up in the south.
A mother in Tamil Nadu mourns for her lost daughter
The BBC’s Daniel Lak in Tamil Nadu says the last remaining bodies of the estimated 10,000 from the region are being cremated or buried.
Clinics and vaccination centres are being set up while government officials say they will ease rules on compensation for people who have lost livelihoods or members of their families.
Our correspondent says that in the port town of Nagappattinam, one of the worst affected areas, much of the aid is arriving from informal sources such as businesses, community groups and individuals.
The death toll there is expected to climb as Indian navy vessels and scuba divers comb river and sea bottoms for missing fishermen who were at sea when the tsunamis hit.
One problem plaguing the aid effort, say relief workers, has been the number of official visits by dignitaries and high government people.
Each visit takes hundreds of police officers and workers to coordinate, people that might better be part of the direct relief effort.
What you said is common knowledge. Great to see even you knowing it!
Now what relevance do the ATGM’s have wrt the PN’s frigates? :p
Think they maybe used on the choppers on the frigates, which makes sense, why waste a harpoon or exocet on a small patrol boat when a much cheaper and smaller ATGM will do. I think US P-3s can carry maverick