Seems the Russians have something of a track record for downing airliners themselves, so that isn’t unique to Ukraine.
Without resorting to idiotic conspiracy theories, why on earth would Ukraine be firing SAMs? The Russians hadn’t given the rebels and aircraft. It was the Ukrainians that were regularly losing aircraft to SAMs.
Already answered that:
And yes the USN also downed an Iranian airliner in 1988. The only difference in the Russian case was that the airliner had strayed off course by some distance.
Why would the Ukrainians need a high altitude air defence system so close to the front line given Rebels didn’t have any air capability at all? on the other hand rebels were shooting down jets with regular frequency.
Quite simply because they feared intervention from Russia, or maybe they just wanted to turn the political tide in their favour by shooting down an airliner. Until that point, the EU was hesitant with sanctions, so only the Ukrainian Nationalists stood to gain from the incident.
Meanwhile, ‘moderates’ in action:
Moderates LOL.
Syria: US ally’s razing of villages amounts to war crimes
A fact-finding mission to northern Syria has uncovered a wave of forced displacement and home demolitions amounting to war crimes carried out by the Autonomous Administration led by the Syrian Kurdish political party Partiya Yekîtiya Demokrat (PYD) controlling the area, said Amnesty International in a report published today. The Autonomous Administration is a key ally, on the ground, of the US-led coalition fighting against the armed group calling itself the Islamic State (IS) in Syria.
‘We had nowhere else to go’: Forced displacement and demolitions in northern Syria reveals evidence of alarming abuses, including eyewitness accounts and satellite images, detailing the deliberate displacement of thousands of civilians and the razing of entire villages in areas under the control of the Autonomous Administration, often in retaliation for residents’ perceived sympathies with, or ties to, members of IS or other armed groups.
Human Rights Watch accuses Syria rebels of war crimes
Human Rights Watch said Friday that Syrian opposition fighters committed “war crimes” and “crimes against humanity” in an Aug. 4 assault, killing at least 190 civilians as the rebels began a large-scale offensive to take back government-controlled areas in Latakia province, where many members of President Bashar al-Assad’s Alawite sect live in rural villages.
So where’s the criminal investigation? Come on! When they thought Assad conducted a chemical attack, they were very quick to dial the Hague but these mass executions don’t seem to have raised an eyebrow because the perpetrators are facing in the right direction.
Because Almaz-Antey provided that information to the Dutch Safety Board. Do a Control F search for bow-tie in the report.
http://cdn.onderzoeksraad.nl/documents/report-mh17-crash-en.pdf
The 9N314M warhead according to data from Almaz-Antey has the Bow-tie fragments
The 9N314 warhead according to data from Almaz-Antey has no Bow-tie fragments.
Bow-tie fragments were recovered from the body of the Captain of MH17 and also from the cockpit.
Cubic, Irregular and Bow-tie warhead fragments were all recovered from human remains.
Strangely the Russians can’t work out where the Bow-tie fragments come from ????
If it wasn’t such a tragedy it would be a farce. So just what are the Russian hinting at here? Of course they are leaving it very vague but it suggests that the bow-tie fragments were planted. An absolutely ridiculous suggestion but it diverts attention and blame away from direct Russian involvement.
Well either way, the Ukrainians had both versions in operation and they’re no stranger to shooting down civilian airliners, even in peace time. They’re also the only party that benefited politically from the shoot down and hence the only party likely to have done in deliberately. So any criminal investigation would have to focus on them.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siberia_Airlines_Flight_1812
But this time geopolitics has raised its ugly head and the lives lost were Western Europeans, which are worth more than other lives:rolleyes:, so there’s a major stromp about it.
Almaz is saying what it believes to be the truth as it is based on the type of projectiles that are in the old warhead versus the newer one & the nature of the holes that the missile that shot down MH 17 made.
And they have conducted a full scale test, which the Dutch investigation didn’t. The test also showed that the missile was travelling in the opposite direction due to the distribution of shrapnel. The Dutch didn’t consider this evidence but if it becomes a criminal case, then there will be no ignoring it, unless it wants to be seen as a kangaroo court.
But then no previous shoot down of a passenger plane has ever become a criminal case. Ukrainian SA-5 04/10/2001 didn’t, USS Vincennes 03/07/1988 didn’t.
The claim is dangled like a red herring but in reality the 9M38M1 used to down MH17 could easily have come direct from a Russian source.
Do they all have the same warhead type though? The statement they gave, said the warhead type was changed in 1986.
http://pivopotam.livejournal.com/395481.html
I think we should move any further debate to the MH17 thread though.
Funny that this article is rarely mentioned.
http://breakingdefense.com/2015/07/dunford-mulls-f-35b-ioc-decision-4-bs-take-out-9-attackers/
Dunford Mulls F-35B IOC Decision; 4 Bs Take Out 9 Attackers
70 ‘moderates’ which the US trained defected to Al Nusra, so yes, Al Nusra likely has those weapons now. The rest were killed, so again, terrorists probably have those weapons too… even assuming they were given to moderates.
Turkey overestimated itself. now there is no going back as Islamist will not leave it alone.
Russia hasn’t issued the warning yet.
http://diplomacy.bgnnews.com/china-joins-15-others-issuing-travel-warnings-for-turkey-after-ankara-bombing-haberi/10230
http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/10/13/us-mideast-crisis-syria-turkey-idUSKCN0S71BF20151013
Turkey warns U.S., Russia against backing Kurdish militia in Syria
Turkey has warned the United States and Russia it will not tolerate Kurdish territorial gains by Kurdish militia close to its frontiers in north-western Syria, two senior officials said.
“This is clear cut for us and there is no joking about it,” one official said of the possibility of Syrian Kurdish militia crossing the Euphrates to extend control along Turkish borders from Iraq’s Kurdistan region towards the Mediterranean coast.
Turkey fears advances by Kurdish YPG militia, backed by its PYD political wing, on the Syrian side of its 900 km (560-mile) border will fuel separatist ambitions among Kurds in its own southeastern territories. But Washington has supported YPG fighters as an effective force in combating Islamic State.
“The PYD has been getting closer with both the United States and Russia of late. We view the PYD as a terrorist group and we want all countries to consider the consequences of their cooperation,” one of the Turkish officials said.
Turkey suspects Russia, which launched air strikes in Syria two weeks ago, has also been lending support to the YPG and PYD.
“With support from Russia, the PYD is trying to capture land between Jarablus and Azaz, going west of the Euphrates. We will never accept this,” the official said.
It’s Sidewinder AIM
9L (Lima’s).
Ah right. It was the ‘LIMA’ that confused me. I heard M-9 Leema.:stupid:
What? If they could already get their hands on it, then they wouldn’t have needed it to be given to them… free of charge. After this war ends, assuming it ever does, these decisions will come back to haunt people.
Pffft, staggering logic. Ever heard of vans?
What’s the missile on the Hawks he mentions at 34:00?
I found a brilliant interview of an ex RAF Tornado F3 pilot talking about his DACT sorties with 2 F14s and 2 F-18s against 2 F3s and 2 Hawks when on detachment. Very interesting plus a great story of what happened after the sorties!
http://www.aircrewinterview.tv/new-page/
When’s the bit about the F3?
Its not like they gave them an Sa-11 and hundreds of tanks and other armored vehicles or anything…
The SA-11 was Ukrainian. Russia doesn’t use that model anymore. So it could only have been taken from the Ukrainian regime (assuming it was the rebels), the regime which surprisingly quickly slotted into place immediately after the armed coup where shots were fired at protesters and police by armed elements from the protest.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-31359021
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-26333525
From first link:
“I didn’t shoot to kill”
“I was shooting downwards at their feet,” says a man we will call Sergei, who tells me he took up position in the Kiev Conservatory, a music academy on the south-west corner of the square.“Of course, I could have hit them in the arm or anywhere. But I didn’t shoot to kill.”
Sergei says he had been a regular protester on the Maidan for more than a month, and that his shots at police on the square and on the roof of an underground shopping mall, caused them to retreat.
There had been shooting two days earlier, on 18 February. The 19th, a Wednesday, had been quieter, but in the evening, Sergei says, he was put in contact with a man who offered him two guns: one a 12-gauge shotgun, the other a hunting rifle, a Saiga that fired high-velocity rounds.
He chose the latter, he says, and stashed it in the Post Office building, a few yards from the Conservatory. Both buildings were under the control of the protesters.
When the shooting started early on the morning of the 20th, Sergei says, he was escorted to the Conservatory, and spent some 20 minutes before 07:00 firing on police, alongside a second gunman.
His account is partially corroborated by other witnesses. That morning, Andriy Shevchenko, then an opposition MP and part of the Maidan movement, had received a phone call from the head of the riot police on the square.
“He calls me and says, ‘Andriy, somebody is shooting at my guys.’ And he said that the shooting was from the Conservatory.”
Shevchenko contacted the man in charge of security for the protesters, Andriy Parubiy, known as the Commandant of the Maidan.
“I sent a group of my best men to go through the entire Conservatory building and determine whether there were any firing positions,” Parubiy says.
So let’s see, protesters armed by an unknown entity, new government very quickly slots into place with immediate support from western countries, even prior to any election. You don’t need to be a genius to join those dots.
The US did supply terrorists in Syria with TOW missiles however, which hardly bodes well for buses, trains and taxiing planes in the future.
US replenishing the stockpiles Russia destroyed in the last days.
Russia should bomb these locations. Stingers on the way to endanger russian pilots.
That’s just crazy. There is no guarantee or likelihood that that they will stay out of terrorist hands.