dark light

David Legg

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 151 through 165 (of 233 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Is this a Miles M.16 Mentor1 ?? #1087774
    David Legg
    Participant

    L4433 is a Miles Mentor I. According to Air Britain it flew with the Station Flight at Manston, It was taken for repair (no reason given) on 18/10/40 and there is no further trace of the aircraft.

    Regards,

    kev35

    The above info is from Air-Britain’s RAF Aircraft L1000 – N9999. Peter Amos’s simply fantastic Miles Aircraft – The Early Years, also from Air-Britain, adds a little more…

    c/n 475 L4433 To 19 Maintenance Unit, St Athan, 9/5/1939. To Station Flight Manston, 7/6/1939. To Phillips & Powis Cat. B 10/10/1940. Upgraded to Cat. E, 18/10/1940. (Cat.B = Beyond repair on site; Cat.E = Write-off)

    in reply to: IDFAF Catalina #1093444
    David Legg
    Participant

    As you suggest, BuAer 64017 has no histiorical link with the IDFAF but was acquired for the IDFAF museum to represent one of the three that it did operate.

    N94574/G-APZA was definitely c/n 1619/BuAer48257 and not BuAer08099 and it certainly served with the IDFAF but I have no proof that it was serial 3401. I have no tie-ups between IDFAF serials and the previous identities of the three Catalinas it operated.

    This subject is something of a minefield – if you are researching these aircraft, I would be interested in corresponding with you by PMs.

    in reply to: Catalina FP-112 18th Nov 1943 #1099161
    David Legg
    Participant

    Many thanks for that – happy to have been of help.

    in reply to: Catalina FP-112 18th Nov 1943 #1106956
    David Legg
    Participant

    Oops my error it was 490 thanks for the links to the photos very interesting. I wonder if anyone out there has a higher resolution version of the second Jui photo with the squadron crew in front of the Catalina.

    Here’s hoping – thanks again Mike

    Mike – I may be able to help you with that photo but need a day or so to track it down in my collection. I’ll get back to you, probably via a PM

    in reply to: Cat Question #1122823
    David Legg
    Participant

    The consensus seems to be two per wing, so I’m guessing the text in question is wrong. As usual a big thanks for all the help.

    I wasn’t aware that torpedoes were carried, that must have been an interesting sight.

    Although a load of four DCs (2/side) was the norm, lighter DCs could be carried in order to increase the number of rounds which is why ‘inkworm’ will have read of, for example, a stick of six DCs being dropped.

    On the subject of torpedoes, these were not carried routinely by RAF Catalinas although they were trialled.

    in reply to: Saro Princess as a patrol bomber? #1133141
    David Legg
    Participant

    I’ve had a quick look at both the Putnam book by Peter London (Saunders and Saro Aircraft since 1917) and the booklet by Bob Wealthy (The Saunders-Roe Princess Flying Boat Project) and neither have any reference to a patrol bomber role. There are various other proposals mentioned including the AEW variant referred to above as well as a twin-hull version, a landplane and the re-design that would have resulted in the Duchess jet flying boat. Also mentioned is the still-born plan by Aero Spacelines to use the three Princess ‘boats, Guppy-like, to transport Saturn V rocket components. There was also serious consideration given to US Navy use of the Princess as a nuclear powered testbed. Bob Wealthy’s presentation notes for a talk given to the Hamburg branch of the RAeS in June 2010 mentions the Glenn L Martin Company in this context whilst the recent book by Robert E Bradley (Convair Advanced Designs) states that Convair looked at the feasibility of a nuclear test bed too. But nothing about a patrol bomber!

    in reply to: TSR-1? #1154623
    David Legg
    Participant

    At least there doesn’t seem to be any doubt about the source of the designation for the TSR-3 but what were the Tom Storey Racer 1 and 2 or did he just continue on where others had left off?

    According to British Homebuilt Aircraft since 1920 by Ken Ellis and published by Merseyside Aviation Society in 1979 (2nd edition), the Storey Wonderplane was designated TSR-3 with TSR standing for Tom Storey Racer and the ‘3’ as it was ‘one up’ on TSR-2. By implication, he had not built any predecessors, at least not of his own design

    in reply to: Hawker P1127 ex Dunsfold #1091114
    David Legg
    Participant

    Brooklands?

    in reply to: UK 'B' Series registrations… a question… #1093410
    David Legg
    Participant

    Thanks for the info David, I assume it wore this because of being evaluated by a British firm?

    Correct.

    in reply to: UK 'B' Series registrations… a question… #1093442
    David Legg
    Participant

    Surely B class markings are only applied to British built aircraft and manufacturers?

    In fact there are plenty of examples of aircraft of foreign manufacture being allocated ‘B Conditions’ markings. A random example illustrated in the aforementioned Air-Britain Digest article was the Romanian-built IS28M motor glider that was used by Slingsby for evaluation and testing. It flew as G-7-100.

    in reply to: UK 'B' Series registrations… a question… #1094538
    David Legg
    Participant

    The correct term to describe such identities is “markings used for flights under B conditions”. The oft used expression ‘Class B registrations’ is incorrect. ‘B conditions’ markings have been used in the UK since before WWII by manufacturers to test fly experimental and production aircraft before the allocation of formal nationality marks. They are still in use, albeit by a somewhat smaller industry. I can recommend the excellent article by Phil Butler on the subject in Air-Britain’s Digest magazine for Summer 2002 which gives a great deal of historical and present day information on this fascinating topic. Many years ago, the same author along with D S Revell produced the book Under B Conditions for the Merseyside Aviation Society

    in reply to: Catalina FP154 of 210 Sqn #1112475
    David Legg
    Participant

    This is fascinating stuff. My grandfather joined 210 in 1942 and in November went to Gib.
    Coincidentally, I am up to this part of his memoirs. Just after they got down there, his friend Ted Sleigh died in a porpoising accident (swell related).

    This was Catalina I AH559/N lost on take off in appalling sea conditions on November 4th, 1942

    in reply to: Catalina FP154 of 210 Sqn #1112847
    David Legg
    Participant

    Hi Moggy,

    The crew casualties were:

    F/O M J French
    Sgt E McKim
    P/O G E McNaughton RAAF
    Sgt C Field
    Sgt G J Orton
    Sgt G T W Gibson
    Sgt E J Smith
    F/Sgt R J G Campbell
    Sgt E H S Marsh
    Sgt I L MacLean

    Regards
    Ross

    Ross – although I do not know which details are correct, I merely point out that the book I mentioned states that the crew members as recorded on the Air Force Memorial to the Missing at Malta differs slightly to your list above, namely that Sgt E McKim was Sgt E Makin and that Sgt I L Maclean was Sgt I L McLean

    in reply to: Catalina FP154 of 210 Sqn #1112861
    David Legg
    Participant

    David, DA-D was tasked with escort to convoy SV8 rather than an A/S patrol but all the other details give are correct.

    Regards
    Ross

    Ross – many thanks for the additional info. The direct quote from the book I mentioned was “FP154/D left for A/S patrol SV8…” which can be interpreted as an A/S patrol with convoy SV8 and not that the A/S patrol was named SV8. That was my thinking anyway

    in reply to: Catalina FP154 of 210 Sqn #1113251
    David Legg
    Participant

    Moggy – FP154 was a Catalina IB built by Consolidated Aircraft Corporation at San Diego. It initially served with 212 Squadron before passing on to 210 Squadron. The excellent book To the Ends of the Earth – 210 Squadron’s Catalina Years by Mike Seymour and Bill Balderson confirms that FP154 got airborne from Gibraltar at 08:12 on 22nd March (1943) on A/S patrol SV8. At 14:45, base recalled the aircraft to base by 19:15 and received R for this signal at 15:23. The Catalina had to take avoiding action to miss high ground and houses near the town of Sagres in misty conditions. The aircraft stalled and crashed into the sea very close to the town. Of the ten man crew, all died but only two bodies were recovered.

    If you need more information such as delivery details to the UK prior to service and more details of the deceased, let me know.

Viewing 15 posts - 151 through 165 (of 233 total)