dark light

Greenday1

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 121 through 135 (of 258 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2041505
    Greenday1
    Participant

    So French may not have much of an objection to integration of Harpoon…as long as PN is willing to pay.

    Of course not. What do they care what missiles PN uses in its subs? They will obviously try and resist so that will force PN to buy Exocet. But money talks, Bull**t walks. If we pay for the intrgeation and make the issue a deal breaker, they will relent.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2568899
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Muns
    “As for its avionics, the aircraft is fitted with Italian Grifo S-7 fir-control radar system. “

    Source for this is in thread above is just 4 months old.

    Only thing that MAY be degraded on F-16 is its offensive ECM pod memory library. NOT its ability to aquire and destory Indian MIGs with the AMRAAM C5.

    J-10 purchase was given goahead last year by Pakistan cabient accoridng to press reports (you can search for these yourself, cant be bothered to feed you).

    Like wise. Please dont try and compare the Magic 2 with the latest blocks of AIM-9L/M

    You can search for the stats yourself. AIM-9L/M range is 12 miles, Magic 2 is 8. Magic 2 has been out iof production for years now and is being repalced in French service by MICA. In fact India may be one of the last operators of this. AIM-9L.M is STILL BEING ORDERED BY NATO.

    I have provided evidence that JF-17 for PAF may have Western avionics to the forum jester who claimed it will all be Chinese. This despite the evidence I have posted and he fact that the ACM of PAF has himself stated on seveal occasions in the past year that JF-17 will be equipped with western avionics. SAGEM and Grifo are the most likely suppliers.

    In fact our Italian chums are marketing the specific radar for JF-17 in this brouchure.

    http://www.selex-sas.com/datasheets_ga/Grifofamily.pdf

    Now what? Can we accuse them of secretly spreading propaganda and being cunning Pakistanis!?

    This very family of radar is already in use by Signapore in its F-5s and they have integrated AMRAAM. If its AMRAAM or SD-10 for the JF-17. Lets not pretend Indian Harriers will stand a rats chance.

    I agree, MIG-29s will be a big threat.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2568926
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Still no sources to back up a word you say?

    Fine. Job done, if you cant accept facts, not my problem.

    Ciao

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2568931
    Greenday1
    Participant

    OK, you have still not placed one shread of evidence to support your claims. I have posted several peices showing that yes, JF-17 prototypes will have Chinese radar, but PAF examples will be equipped with western avionics. You claimed otherwise. I have proven you wrong. Now you want to know “what” avionics. That I do not know. Its clear you have been proved wrong. All you can do is now rant. Sources include Reuters, APP and Pakistani press.

    I orginally sought to prove that IN wont be handle the PAF without EXTENSIVE support from the IAF. You claimed that Indian Sea Harriers would take on the bulk of the PAF.

    Thats one big massive joke.

    F-16 Block 52s with AMRAAM C5
    J-10 with SD-10
    JF-17s with unspecified avionics and missiles

    Right now, even PAF F-7s and Mirages would take care of Indian Naval aviation.

    The IAF will be needed. The only thing an IN carrier would do for the Indian Navy would present a massive morale problem if ever it was sunk.

    Please enough about IN Sea Harriers taking on the PAF. SU-30s yes. 30 year old Sea Harriers no.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2568970
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Right. I really cant argue logically with you if you deny basic proven facts.

    First you said PAF cant integrate western avionics in Chinese aircraft. I have proven this is not the case.

    “Miscellaneous Systems

    The F-7MG has several modern avionics upgrades. These include a Stores Management System, which is essentially a useful cockpit-pilot interface to help establish the status of stores including configuration, fusing and weapon codes etc. A voice warning system, colour video recorder, elaborate cockpit lighting and a more precise and jitter–free AOA probe are nice-to-have improvements. The colour EFIS includes two displays, one for the attitude and the other for the heading and navigation sub-systems like ADF, VOR, TACAN, ILS etc.

    The PAF pilots used to advanced cockpits like the F-16 were quick to point out several ergonomic improvements and had detailed discussions with CAC design bureau. Switchology changes and relocation of several instruments led to a much improved cockpit; it has been suggested in a lighter vein that a nomenclature change to F-7PG2 might just be in order. (‘G’ incidentally stands for ‘gai’, meaning ‘improved’ in Chinese.)

    Radar

    The F-7MG was originally designed to have the GEC-Marconi Super Skyranger. At the time of initial PAF trials the radar was not ready. Trials were held again several months later after the prototype radar was installed. In the event the radar did not come up to PAF specifications and GEC-Marconi was not able to surmount the problems associated with the small nose cone, including antenna size and equipment air-conditioning which was insufficient.

    The PAF eventually retrofitted their F-7Ps and F-7PGs with the FIAR Grifo-7. To say that miniaturisation technology is at its best in this marvellous Italian radar would be an understatement. An excellent pulse Doppler radar with respectable ranges and a medium order azimuth and elevation scan, the system is married to the all-aspect AIM-9L Sidewinder, making it a lethal combination.”

    http://www.pakdef.info/pakmilitary/airforce/index.html

    AVIONICS: Expected to be of domestic and/or Russian origin for Chinese squadrons and Western type for Pakistan Air Force. FIAR Grifo S7 pulse Doppler multirole radar will be most likely selected for Pakistani version. Other avionics will be Pakistani made and/or from SAGEM. A cockpit layout shown by TECNA Corporation which is working in close association with the Pakistan Aeronautical Complex to establish a full Systems integration capability at Kamra shows 3 large multi-function colour displays, an Up Front Control Panel and a smart Head-Up Display (HUD). The Pakistani version will also feature a HMS. In the second half of 2005 prototype #4 with the complete avionics package is expected to undergo extensive flight testing for qualification of the avionics arid weapons. Ultimately it is expected that the aircraft would be fully certified in the year 2006. “

    http://www.pakdef.info/pakmilitary/airforce/index.html

    From App.com.pk today.

    Pak Air Force to receive first batch of JF-17 thunder aircraft next year

    Chengdu, China, May 10 (APP): The Pakistan Air Force will receive the delivery of first batch of JF-17 thunder aircraft sometime next year, Chief of the Air Staff, Air Chief Marshal Tanvir Mahmood Ahmed said.

    Talking to APP here Wednesday after the success of first maiden operational test flight of PT-4 aircraft, he said the Air Force plans to induct more than 100 Fighters (JF-17) Thunders, jointly produced by China’s Chengdu Aircraft Industry Corporation and Pakistan Aeronautical Complex, Kamra.

    Lauding the efficient performance of the prototype-4 aircraft, he said it will be equipped will ‘state-of-the-art’ avionics, radar and weapons integration systems. Small batch production of the single-seat, single-engine JF-17, will begin in China next month.

    Pakistan and China had been negotiating with different companies inviting them to buy the avionics package for the JF-17 aircraft. It would be economic model. The Air Chief said there is no aircraft in the world which has such good value for money.

    The exact price cannot be determined at this stage, but he said he was sure the aircraft will be almost nearly half of the price of any other fighter aircraft. And capability-wise, it would be better than some of the most modern aircraft in the world.

    Answering a question, he said, ” We are confident that many Air Forces in the world will prefer to buy it, when it will go on mass production.”

    About PT-4 combat aircraft, he said the project is a important milestone in development of aircraft industry in the two countries. It carried the new and modified airframe. Minor changes we might have to do after testing the aircraft, he said adding “ Now we have final shape of JF-17 (thunder) and it is hoped that this particular aircraft will get into production.”

    Commenting on the depth of Sino-Pak relationship, he said it proved time-tested over the years in various sectors, including the Defence production sector. “ These relationships are based on mutual trust, faith and friendship. JF-17 programme has provided a big incentive to this relationship.

    He hoped that collaboration between the two countries enjoy would give more strength to their aviation industry. “ We are discussing some other projects with our Chinese counterparts.” The success of the JF-17 thunder joint programme will usher a new era of strategic partnership between the two friendly countries in the aviation sector. He termed the success of the PT-4 maiden flight a big achievement in the aviation history in the recent years.

    He noted that trial flight has laid a solid foundation of further cooperation between the two countries to meet future challenges

    By Mayed Ali

    LAHORE: Air Chief Marshal Tanvir Mahmud Ahmed will attend the formal first operational flight ceremony of the JF-17 (Thunder) fighter aircraft, a joint venture of Pakistan and China, at Chengdu on May 10.

    The air chief marshal will witness the first aircraft (prototype 4 or P4) taking off from the People’s Liberation Army Air Force airbase in Chengdu. He will be heading a 10-member delegation of the Pakistan Air Force to see the first-ever Pakistan-China joint production lifting off. With this take-off, the aircraft will enter into formal production at Chengdu Aircraft Industry Corporation (CAC) in Sichuan. The CAC is the second largest aircraft industry in China. The Pakistan Aeronautical Complex (PAC), Kamra will start the production of the aircraft in June 2007.

    Pakistan is expected to get the first batch of four JF-17s Thunder (Chinese FC-1) in the first quarter of the next year (in March probably). The CAC-PAC joint venture has an accumulated cost tag of $500 million, while the aircraft will have a price tag of $15-20 million, depending on the specifications. Pakistan and China have shared the cost on the project equally.

    Once developed and fully operational, the JF-17 might find potential markets in the third world countries. Egypt, Burma, Bangladesh, Zimbabwe and Nigeria are closely watching the evolution of the aircraft.

    The Thunder is a handy aircraft, a perfect alternative for sophisticated platforms at an affordable price. It has a top speed of 1.6 mach at low altitudes. It has a Russian RD-93 engine. Having a good weight-power equation, this light-weight aircraft will have a great manoeuvrability. It can attain a ceiling of 16,500 metres, and has a ferry range of 3000 kilometres. The aircraft has seven standard pylons (hardpoints, including four under the wings, two on the wing-tips and one under the fuselage), enabling the platform to carry multiple weaponry for air-to-air and air-to-ground missions. It can carry a maximum weapon payload of 3,800 kilograms. This multi-role JF-17 can operate in all weathers, day and night and is fitted with two coloured multi-function displays (MFDs) and a head-up display (HUD), besides having the provision of helmet mounted display.

    As for its avionics, the aircraft is fitted with Italian Grifo S-7 fir-control radar system. The PAF is already using the older versions of this system in its existing fleet of Mirage 111s, F-7Ps and F-16s. The aircraft will use the Chinese SD-10 BVR (Beyond Visual Range) medium-range missiles besides short-range air-to-air armaments. Though the exact range of the missiles has not yet been made public, it is expected the system (the radar and the integrated missile) will enhance the PAF’s existing potential from around 60 kilometres to around 100 kilometres. The aircraft will be able to carry guided bombs (including laser guided bombs) by virtue of the Infra-red Navigation System and Global Position System (INS/GPS) installed on the platform. It’s dual digitally controlled fly-by-wire (FBW) system will enhance its control and firing capability. The prototype to be flown on May 10 has been modified with work done on its air-intakes, strake and vertical fins, besides modifications in the fuselage.

    ISLAMABAD – The Pakistan Air Force is expecting the delivery of its first multi-role combat aircraft modelled on China’s FC-1 Xiaolong in early 2007, a spokesman said on Monday.

    The Air Force plans to induct more than 100 Joint Fighter-17 (JF-17) Thunders, jointly produced by China’s Chengdu Aircraft Industry Corporation and Pakistan Aeronautical Complex, to replace a fleet of ageing Mirage fighters.

    “The programme is on schedule and the fourth prototype would be tested by the end of April,” Air Commodore Sarfraz Ahmed Khan said. The flight will be used to test the aircraft’s avionics and weapons integration.

    Small batch production of the single-seat, single-engine JF-17, will begin in China in June and the aircraft would be delivered to Pakistan in early 2007, Khan said.

    Serial production of the aircraft would start at the Pakistan Aeronautical Complex in Kamra by June 2007, with aim of supplying both the Pakistan Air Force and export markets.

    Pakistan and China had been negotiating with different companies to buy the avionics package for the JF-17 aircraft, which at $12 million apiece is half the cost of an F-16.

    BAE Systems Plc BA.L was one option being considered for sourcing the avionics, according to defence and diplomatic sources.

    (Reuters) 10 April 2006

    Yes, IAF will be needed to counter PAF Falcon 20s, Erieyes and P-3Cs. You have proved my point. Indian Naval aviation will be insufficient to take on PAF Southern Command.

    I have given my sources. Now you can put up or shut up.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2568995
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Dude
    If PAF went to the effort to integrate Grifo, AIM-9L and western avionics and RWR on its entire F-7 fleet which has proven very successful. You are now saying we just will not bother doing this with the next fighter that will be our mainstay? Your assumptions fly in the face of facts and past experiance.

    Pakistan has had 20 odd years experiance modifying Chinese aircraft with western missiles and avionics. Are you naware of this?

    I can post numerous sources proving that JF-17s avionics fit is still being selected amongst WESTERN firms.

    “all reports indicate that instead a Chinese fit has been chosen”

    Thats completey incorrect. You are know just speculating and perhaps even hoping this will be the case. For the initial 16 yes, but thats it.

    As of July 2006, ACM of PAF indictaed a contract for flight refuelers has been signed.

    Yes, both sides will use ECM jammers. Pakistan has both US and Eurpean jammers in service.

    Bottom line. A JF-17 equipped with either AMRAAM or SD-10 will be enough to counter INs upcoming assets. Be they Sea Harriers of MIG-29s.

    Indian Naval aviation will not have any major leap of tech over PAF. We have not even started talking about the Block 52s and J-10s wich may be dispatched as back up for the JF-17s.

    Additionally IN fighters can expect havoc on the EW spectrum from Falcon 20 EW aircraft, Erieyes and P-3Cs. I doubt IAF can spare one of its 3 Phalcon AEW aircraft for the Indian Navy and the Ka AEW choppers simply dont have the range. With 6-7 Erieyes on order, a couple can be spared for over water use for PAF/PN.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2569023
    Greenday1
    Participant

    JF-17s will have inflight refueling, so range may not be an issue. Additionally most scenarios will be the IN knocking on Pakistans door, not vice versa. So The range situation is more relevent to the Harrier and MIG-29s. Not the JF-17s.

    PAF has stated a “Western” avionics and weapons fit in its JF-17s. Initail prototypes may well have Chinese avioncis however.

    BVR may be AMRAAM or latest blocks of the SD-10. Howver, both will comfortably outrange Derby. About their ECM I am unsure.

    It all depends on US attitudes. If they will let PAF integrate AMRAAM. Then it will be relatively easy to get a high spec US or Eurpean radar and do this. After all, it was possible on the RN SHARs.

    Of course we have to factor in IAF atention on Maroor and Gwadar. Thats a privilage I am sure the IAF will not deny us.

    in reply to: BAE clinches 2.5 Billion Pound Tornado upgrade deal #2569050
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Ah, the anti-Islam nuts crawl out of the woodwork again. All religions have their fantatics. Some even encourage widows to burn themselves on their husbands graves, but we are not allowed to mention that are we? Only Islam bashing permitted! Pathetic!

    Since when did any of the last two posts have ANYTHING to do with upgraded Saudi Tornados!?

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2569070
    Greenday1
    Participant

    You can look up stats for the Magic 2 and AIM-9L/M. They are certainly not classidfied and I never claimed they were. The sidewinder has greater range and manourverability, and better ECCM ability. In fact I think Magic 2 production may have ended. You can count Magic 2 users on one hand. All of NATO use the AIM-9L/M

    You are currently unaware of the exact weapons and avionics fit of the JF-17. I would say its very conficent of you to make a sweeping statement that the MIG-29K will better it. You simply cannot look into the future. If a decent western radar and AMRAAMs are placed in it.Then I think it will be more then enough for the Sea Harrier and the MIG-29Ks.

    Greenday1
    Participant

    I imagine it would be similar to the NATO E-3 fleet in terms of markings.

    Would it really be cost efficient to start training member of 13 diffrent countries for just 4 planes!!!!????

    Why not just hire USAF or RAF pilots?

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2569135
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Just to clarify. When talking of the AIM-9L, I am also including the AIM-9-M and its latest versions also in PAF service.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2569138
    Greenday1
    Participant

    PAF paid full wack for its AIM-9Ls. Many in PAF were unhappy with the Magic 2. So much so that we modified the Mirages so that they could fire the Aim-9L instead. Its all aspect ability and range are considered better.

    As well as Block 52s PAF will also be fielding the latest version of the J-10 and JF-17. What avionics and missiles these birds will finally have is still up in the air, so far to early for anyone to say “so so aircraft is better”.

    Chances are 2 squadrons of JF-17s will form air defence over the sea for PAF in the future.

    in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2041581
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Indeed, it will be very interesting what this new boat will contain.
    Pakistan Navu has stated that it wants teh new generation of Subs to help form the basis of its nuclear deterrent.It will be intresting to see if Marlin fits into this picture.

    I think PN certainly intends its Subs to detect Indian subs. PN will not rely just on its P-3C fleet for this.
    Pakistan is in the process of purchasing 8 ships to shore up its surface fleet.

    in reply to: Indian Sea Harriers still to be upgraded? #2569159
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Upgraded Harrier yes. But cetainly not in their present state, which is still late 70s tech.

    With regards to the Magic 2 being equal to the latest versions of the AIM-9L. Afraid I have to disagree. In fact PAF have stopped operating the Magic 2 in favour of using the AIM-9L.

    To quote you earlier, these present Sea Harrier certainly do NOT beat the “bulk of the most liklely opponant”.

    In fact, the sooner the IN gets MIG-29s. The better.

    in reply to: Pakistan Navy #2041587
    Greenday1
    Participant

    Then it might not be superior to the Scorpene after all.

    Newer design. Newer tech. I doubt PN would ask for a totally new sub. Anyone have specs for Marlin or is it still classified?

    I also heard the propoeller blade tech will be far ahead.

Viewing 15 posts - 121 through 135 (of 258 total)