dark light

steve_p

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 596 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Aviation Archaeology/Wreck Recovery. #1191190
    steve_p
    Participant

    Like many high ground sites it is on open ground with access from many directions if you dont mind a walk.

    This is just scaremongering claptrap. The site is on a hillside miles away from a public road. It is too remote and uninteresting to be visited by anyone other than estate workers or aviation scrap dealers. I suspect that the limited pilfering that has happened here has been done by estate employees who are housed near it during the stalking season. Do you, the guys from Waddingto or the estate owner really believe that anyone is capable of manhandling a Lancaster mainwheel – complete with smooth tyre – the six miles or so to the nearest road without the assistance of the estate?

    So I maintain that all sites should be cleared and if needed a simple memorial marker placed on site.

    Do you trade in aviation wreckage by any chance, and why did you name this particular site? It seems to me that naming this source for Lancaster parts on a public forum is not exactly the smartest thing to do if you are concerned with the well-being of this crash site. I just get the feeling that you are more concerned with selling parts than preserving the sites.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Convince the MOD for a Recovery Licence……. #1163215
    steve_p
    Participant

    Just a thought, how do the families involved feel about this? I’m not convinced that it is always best to re-open old wounds, especially when those involved will be quite elderly.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Convince the MOD for a Recovery Licence……. #1164152
    steve_p
    Participant

    Most deaths were recorded in England and Wales, notable exceptions being US service personnel, Free French and some other European volunteers (not Polish and Czech though).

    All of the crew of the a/c I came across are on the GRO register but I have not got copies of their death certs.

    I have not checked to see if some none recovered crews are on the GRO, I think there was a seperate register for them within the GRO.

    Thanks for that, Alan. I have used the parish registers pretty extensively for Scottish crashes. They are generally pretty good and often give a far more precise location than the RAF records. Only downside is that some of them have been scanned poorly and are unreadable.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Convince the MOD for a Recovery Licence……. #1164177
    steve_p
    Participant

    Interesting theory

    They gave a certain deep sea recovery team permission to recover the remains of HMS victory and there was/is evidence of crew buried in the sand

    I doubt if there are any immediate family relations of the crew still alive. 😀

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Convince the MOD for a Recovery Licence……. #1164180
    steve_p
    Participant

    There is one site in Wales that I know for a fact all of the crew were recovered from, one is still recorded on Runnymede though. I got that from the ORB of the RAF station that dealt with the crash, they found the last man several days after “near the crash site” but still he stayed on the missing list.

    Wasn’t it usual for all deaths within parishes in England and Wales to have been recorded in a Register of Deaths. This was certainly the case in wartime Scotland. If a body was recovered, a note would have been made of the cause of death, the location of the incident, and who took responsibility for the body. Have the MoD looked at these records?

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Dambusters remake Lanc unveiled #1184659
    steve_p
    Participant

    I’m getting into an area where I’ve got no idea what I’m blithering on about!!!

    Thats probably similar to what Barnes Wallis said to the chairman of Vickers when he handed over the drawings of the Windsor. 😮

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Hurricane Pilot Photo on E-Bay…. #1186218
    steve_p
    Participant

    Can’t find it – link please?

    This any good? Used the ended items search.

    http://cgi.ebay.co.uk/WW2-Photograph-BRITISH-SOE-LYSANDER-RARE_W0QQitemZ270380247474QQcmdZViewItemQQptZUK_Collectables_Militaria_LE?hash=item270380247474&_trksid=p3911.c0.m14&_trkparms=66%3A2|65%3A13|39%3A1|240%3A1318|301%3A0|293%3A1|294%3A50

    I’m not convinced that its an ASR Lizzie now, one of the chaps looks remarkably like a squaddie.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Hurricane Pilot Photo on E-Bay…. #1186530
    steve_p
    Participant

    If it has a Dinghy with it, surely SAR rather than SOE?

    Thats the point that I was trying to make.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Hurricane Pilot Photo on E-Bay…. #1187022
    steve_p
    Participant

    There’s a nice shot of a SOE Lysander presumably about to transport a dingy to France. The shot of French resistance fighters in Paris has appeared in countless books.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Crocodile F2B #1187025
    steve_p
    Participant

    I’m not at all convinced that the two photos have been taken using different film stocks. The reason for the lighter roundel blue in the lower could equally have been due to direct sunlight hitting the airframe in a particular way. The quality of light and the background looks the same in both photos so, could both of the photos have come from the same Photographer/camera?

    There are a hundred and one reasons why tones differ from photo to photo, type of film stock used is only one of them.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Crocodile F2B #1187454
    steve_p
    Participant

    The B/W tone in the second indicates that orthochromatic film was used. This lightened blues and darkened reds so, based on the similarity of the dark toned red with the fuselage squares, leads to the conclusion that they are red.

    Err, I’m maybe missing something but wouldn’t black squares look like that as well, regardless of what film type was used?

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Any ideas as to what this is from…? #1190788
    steve_p
    Participant

    Ok, a bit more on Short Type 184 (Improved) N1635. It was built by the Phoenix Dynamo Manufacturing Co Ltd, and was on the books of 424/5 flts at Newlyn when it stalled and spun into the sea at Mounts Bay on 27.9.1918. The two crew members (2/Lt TL Harding and 2AM WF Fox) were both slightly injured. Given the ability of these aircraft to float after crashing, it is quite possible that the wreck was salvaged, and the serial removed as a souvenir.

    Info from the excellent Air Britain Royal Navy Serials 1911-1919 tome.

    Style and colour of the serial are wrong for a Defiant.

    in reply to: Any ideas as to what this is from…? #1190911
    steve_p
    Participant

    Also, a Short 184 carried this serial. More probable than a Defiant.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: Martin Baker MB3 and MB5 #1190952
    steve_p
    Participant

    Aeroplane Monthly, October and November 1973, carried a nice two-part article on the Martin Baker designs.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    in reply to: World's Oldest Independent Air Force #1191064
    steve_p
    Participant

    Can you quote the failed to return rate of these 3 Squadrons?… I heard the loss rate was 0.0000%….

    That is simply incorrect. If you research the records of Rolf Harris you will find that his Boomerang never came back.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 596 total)