dark light

Indian1973

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,711 through 1,725 (of 1,845 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • Indian1973
    Participant

    not what I read in indian media. it was designed from day1 as
    a top-attack projectile and fired on targets in armd warfare center, ahmednagar for user trials. it swoops up and hits the tank turret-top directly rather than the more complex overflying it and releasing penetrator darts at 90′ like swedish BILL does.

    I believe efforts are still on (maybe with israeli involvement) to
    master a MMW guidance radar for Nag-MMW version which would
    enable engagements in very hostile conditions (IIR doesnt cut it in sandstorms, heavy rain or such…)

    the missile is much heavier and bigger than konkurs/Milan which
    infantry carry around . it is not a infantry weapon – only a BMP2
    chassis and helicopters can carry it.

    Indian1973
    Participant

    in the next few years indian army will first add about 50-100 armed Dhruv helicopters – 4 nag ATGMs (with infra red imaging seeker – fire n forget), 3-barrel gun under nose, night vision. in
    the light anti armour role. Nag has a range of 4km and is top-attack once beyond 1km. it has already cleared user trials.

    in 5 years the LCH which HAL is presently working on will appear.
    it is a tandem-two seat derivative of Dhruv and was shown in
    crude form last year in bangalore defexpo03. looks like a rooivalk / tigre style dedicated attack chopper. the armanent will likely be the same but will be more armoured, nimble and survivable, having some israeli avionics . again around 200+ are likely to be ordered because army has 20 divisions and each
    needs some, strike divisions need more.

    the Mi35s will be retired within the next decade. Alouette-IIIs
    are long in tooth and will all be gone. Mi17V armed with the
    Vikhr atgms(iirc) are coming in quantity now.

    thats the comparison going fwd. Mi17V in medium logistics and
    hi-altitude attack, Dhruv and LCH-Dhruv for light logistics and
    gunship. a new LOH(light observation heli) tender is out to
    vendors for license making a light helicopter for scouting duties
    (kinda like kiowa warrior?).

    old UH-1s, AH-1s and unarmed MI17s do not look impressive
    in comparison today and certainly not in future.

    Pak needs to get modern helicopters to have any hope of matching indian quality and quantity. I suggest something like
    Rooivalk + AH1Z in attack role with latest hellfire ATGMS and
    loads and loads of Mi17 to improve their weak logistics.

    but they dont have the budget for it from internal resources
    and USA doesnt seem interested in lavish aid packages lately,
    just loan bailouts and reschedules.

    in reply to: MiG-29SMT flight tests with 'Zhuk-MEh' #2661408
    Indian1973
    Participant

    they can get off the GCI bandwagon if A-50s are available in
    numbers , otherwise whats the option? the limited older airborne
    radars didnt permit much freedom for anything else. only Mig31
    and the big new Su30 radars permit some fighter ‘wolfpacking’

    in due course yes, but right now they need more flying hrs more
    than anything.

    in reply to: MiG-29SMT flight tests with 'Zhuk-MEh' #2662091
    Indian1973
    Participant

    maybe on Mig29K too ?

    in reply to: Indian Air Force Pictures #2662122
    Indian1973
    Participant

    I dont like the ugly bank of switches in top-right of front cockpit.
    wonder what they are for…

    in reply to: IAF begins Mi-8 phase-out #2662126
    Indian1973
    Participant

    Mi8/17 and UH-1 family looks ageless. the Alouette-IIIs will also
    be around forever!

    in reply to: Oh oh- Russian AF in Uncontrollable Decline #2662131
    Indian1973
    Participant

    > Also right now it might be time to relinquish Chechnya.

    why? every part of ones country is worth fighting for, you dont
    put an economic value on it. its a matter of principle.

    also leaving chechnya would hugely encourage the islamists and
    soon they would start biting all over the place….

    in reply to: F-X Brazil news : US offers Brazil 48 AMRAAMS UNRESTRICTED #2662133
    Indian1973
    Participant

    all this “Selling only to democracies” is a hogwash. when taiwan
    and s.korea were under authoritarian rule, plenty of US gear
    was sold..though I am not familiar with the exact systems. Iran
    under the Shah was being built up as the most powerful of the
    US allies in the region – F14s, phoenix missiles etc. and under
    the late Gen Zia ul Haq pakistan received a $3+ billion plus mil
    aid package including F16s, sidewinders, ships, harpoons, P3,antpq36 and so on.

    US prefers orderly authoritarian regimes to unruly democracies
    and will help whoever does its bidding, the pedigree doesnt
    matter 😮

    in reply to: FC-1 thread (news and pictures) #2662757
    Indian1973
    Participant

    no offence intended, but if a project is closed and PRC policy
    is not to disclose much, its best NOT to get into fights based on
    scraps of info + guesses that leak out. its better to wait until
    PAF gets the bird and some PAF high-up comments on what it
    has.

    russia produced some great planes like Mig31 and Su27 with
    no public news releases.

    in reply to: IAF- news & discussions- MAY 2005 #2662902
    Indian1973
    Participant

    it can carry a giant 2-ton ECM suite based on the users reqs if
    thats what you want. I am sure even the basic version had good
    satnav gear for blind navigation over the arctic regions.

    It can approach at mach2 at 50kft and let loose ALCMs and ASMs
    and escape at mach2. now if these ALCM is a 500km range bird
    what are you going to do about it ?

    you’d need a large airwing and AWACS to protect naval SAGs
    against this kind of threat…precisely why the USN invested in
    the E2 + F14 combo.

    others will need to take their chances on shooting down or
    decoying Klub/brahmos etc in the envelopes of their SAMs.

    how about 6 Klubs in internal rotary launcher and 4 under the
    wings ? thats more warload than a talwar class frigate and able
    to fly 2000km at a high speed….

    in reply to: FC-1 thread (news and pictures) #2663273
    Indian1973
    Participant

    given the sheer size and power of the Mig31, has anyone
    considered the idea of mounting say 24 AA-12 in triple or quad packs on this bird ? using height x high speed it ought to be
    able to dart in at 70,000ft, use lookdown-shootdown mode of
    its PA radar launch missiles and leave with near immunity in
    cross-border slash-n-run tactics !

    in reply to: FC-1 thread (news and pictures) #2663355
    Indian1973
    Participant

    why would Thales and Tecnacorp be needed for the FBW system
    if as other posters say its all a done deal for the PRC and they
    have got it to plug-n-play status ?

    thales/others could be needed for Pak specified avionics, radar
    or weapons but it has nothing to do with FBW.

    in reply to: US for better strategic ties with India #2663373
    Indian1973
    Participant

    is SNIPER significantly better than Litening-AT and follow ons ?
    most IAF a/c in strike role are getting Litenings…

    in reply to: FC-1 thread (news and pictures) #2663539
    Indian1973
    Participant

    if its the non-FBW version undergoing tests now, I very much doubt anything in 2005 will be sporting FBW. when are they going to complete the basic version then move on to FBW unless they have already started testing FBW in parallel long ago?

    and if they started with FBW there was no reason to go with
    the basic version as acc. to chinese posters here the PRC has long
    mastered FBW via versions of J-8 and J-10 😉

    the probable timeline is the non-FBW version gets delivered in
    2008 and then around 2012 you get a FC1 with full-digital FBW
    if PAF wants it.

    in reply to: IAF- news & discussions- MAY 2005 #2663547
    Indian1973
    Participant

    tu22m3 is not a big deal, what kind of ALCMs russia is willing to
    release is more important…

Viewing 15 posts - 1,711 through 1,725 (of 1,845 total)