dark light

Indian1973

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 256 through 270 (of 1,845 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The mighty Kirov vs the mighty Iowa #2054351
    Indian1973
    Participant

    I believe all the Iowa’s Tomahawks were the land attack model. and since it has no organic helo or UAV, the harpoons cannot be targeted beyond the radar horizon. the Kirov unfortunately has 3 organic helos to scout up some meat for the raptor….

    so I think its like a vision impaired guy with a stick -vs- a guy with a telescopic rifle.

    The Iowa is truly great in its own era and role and did a ok job in ODS-1 pounding the crap out of shore fortifications but it just aint the ship to deal with Kirov.

    > So can the kirovs 20 granits deal with the Iowa’s massive armour?

    I think so, esp if the Granit do a popup and terminal dive like the harpoon does.
    even 5 solid hits from Granits could mission-kill a CVN, 20 is scary.

    in reply to: The mighty Kirov vs the mighty Iowa #2054357
    Indian1973
    Participant

    Tomahawk ASMs are long retired. did the Iowa ever field Harpoons ? I am sure there is space, but one just has to go with standard fit. Kirov has the heaviest SAM and CIWS armament among naval ships and should not have a issue with a few harpoons.

    26 miles ? the Kirovs heavy ASMs have a range of 100s of miles.

    if you teleport them to within 10 miles of each other and let them loose, then Iowa has a chance but again the Kirov can also smack the Iowa from 10 miles with ASMs.

    in reply to: The mighty Kirov vs the mighty Iowa #2054361
    Indian1973
    Participant

    this has been discussed. in open waters, the Kirov launches its ASMs with midcourse update from its organic helos and sinks the Iowa.

    if the Iowa corners the Kirov in confined water and somehow evades the barrage of
    ASMs, then kirov has no chance.

    in reply to: F-16 Block 50/52 Vs Mirage 2000-5mk2 #2618471
    Indian1973
    Participant

    why not be realistic and add in the two R530Ds which the Viper has to avoid first, then the R73 (yes india has supposedly with some difficulty integrated it in non-HMS mode).
    the Mirage also has a higher top speed and lighter wing loading.

    these 1-vs-1 dogfights are just what PAF hopes for, but sorry thats not how the game is played in real world.

    in reply to: Indian Navy – News and Discussion #2054440
    Indian1973
    Participant

    to start with they will start with smaller number of A/C and add in more as experience is gained in the sardine packing technology.

    in reply to: Indian Navy – News and Discussion #2054622
    Indian1973
    Participant

    first official plate cutting for ADS was done today
    http://www.keralanext.com/news/indexread.asp?id=177102

    and IN chief making some noises about larger carriers , minister sez two new shipyards
    planned
    http://www.deepikaglobal.com/latestnews.asp?ncode=27101

    in reply to: MiG29M2 Vs Mirage 2000-5mk2 #2619252
    Indian1973
    Participant

    u are right. so we have onlee have around 45 of these cubs. I wuz thinkin 75.

    in reply to: MiG29M2 Vs Mirage 2000-5mk2 #2619315
    Indian1973
    Participant

    aditya I believe IAF has six mig29 sqdns, not three. pls check scramble and correct me if wrong.

    has anyone taken a closeup look at Mig25 and Mig31 fuselages ? how do their fit n finish compare to say a Mig27 or Mig29 ?

    in reply to: PAF news and speculation #2619324
    Indian1973
    Participant

    fwd airbases are useful for recovering of returning a/c low on fuel or damaged, short range air patrols etc. since the Bisons and some Jags/Mig27s will continue to use them I submit its not really necessary to attack the Bison bases if the PAF is solely interested in helping the PA out. Bisons wont be moving fwd to do ground attack. the Jags/Mig27s are what they need to watch out for – and they are getting IFR probes also .. we have seen photos of Jags with probes now.

    the ‘center of gravity’ of IAF is shifting to bigger and safer bases deep in the interior.
    some fwd bases are a ridiculous 5 min flying time from the border which is just a invitation to surprise attack.

    in reply to: PAF news and speculation #2619346
    Indian1973
    Participant

    experience has shown that its very hard if not impossible to put well prepared airbases out of commission for more than a few hrs. all countries have well drilled repair crews, machinery, quick setting concrete and utility helos for such situations.

    Its easier to defeat flying fighters than seek them out hiding on the ground unless one has 101% air superiority like the US did in recent campaigns.

    in reply to: Chinese HN cruise missile is attacking(picture) #2048372
    Indian1973
    Participant

    > So far I have not seen one disinformation about any chinese military equipment

    har de har har 😀 the J-10 finally stablized into its final form after God knows how many
    thousands of PSed “visions” by enthusiastic people.

    in reply to: BEST AND WORST MOVIE AVIATION SCENES #2622135
    Indian1973
    Participant

    Fail Safe (1964) was a good one.

    not caricature or comedy like Dr Strangelove.

    in reply to: IAF- news & discussions- MARCH 2005 #2622138
    Indian1973
    Participant

    hmmm so if Elta can make it operational in 3 yrs would be a good fit for Mig29 upg, Mirage2000H upg, Su30 and even the LCA at some point.

    in reply to: Indian Navy – News and Discussion #2055350
    Indian1973
    Participant

    some snippets….

    JANE’S DEFENCE WEEKLY – APRIL 06, 2005

    India paves way for arms and upgrade package
    Rahul Bedi JDW Correspondent
    New Delhi

    [Qatar Mirage2000-5]

    “The fighters have 80-85 per cent of their operational
    life intact,” Defence Minister Pranab Mukherjee said,
    adding that talks would start soon. The Emir of Qatar,
    Sheikh Hamad bin Khalifa Al Thani, will make a two-day
    visit to New Delhi beginning on 14 April.

    An Indian Air Force (IAF) team evaluated the nine
    single-seat Mirage 2000-5EDAs and three two-seat
    Mirage 2000-5DDAs two years ago and declared them
    “suitable for induction”. They were acquired by Qatar
    in 1997
    ………..
    Mukherjee said the CCS cleared
    the Rs7.62 billion purchase of 11 Dornier 228 aircraft
    for maritime surveillance, along with spare engines
    and a Rs4.76 billion upgrade for the navy’s fleet of
    14 Sea Harrier Mk 51 multirole fighters. The Harriers
    will be retrofitted by Hindustan Aeronautics in
    collaboration with Israel and equipped with IAI-Elta
    EL/M-2032 multi-mode fire-control radars together with
    advanced avionics and Rafael Armament Development
    Authority Derby beyond-visual-range air-to-air
    missiles.

    The CCS also approved the order of nine offshore
    patrol vessels to be built at Goa Shipyard at a cost
    of Rs10.89 billion. A further six platforms are likely
    to be ordered later.

    The CCS also revised HAL’s intermediate jet trainer
    programme, saying development would now cost Rs4.67
    billion against the 1997 estimate of Rs1.8 billion.
    The project will be completed in nine years instead of
    eight, the committee noted.

    An Rs3.24 billion composite propellant facility under
    the Defence Research and Development Organisation at
    Nasik in western India was also authorised. This
    should produce 100 tonnes of propellant annually for
    the nuclear-capable long-range Agni and short-range
    Prithvi missiles. The CCS further approved
    establishing imagery-interpretation teams to cover the
    army’s 37 divisional headquarters: a capability now
    available only at command and corps levels. This will
    initially cost Rs3.93 billion, plus Rs3.83 billion
    annually for maintenance and operation.
    ———————————

    JANE’S DEFENCE WEEKLY – APRIL 06, 2005

    ——————————————————————————–

    India to begin construction on air-defence ship
    RAHUL BEDI JDW Correspondent
    New Delhi

    India will begin constructing its first indigenously
    designed 37,500-ton air-defence ship (ADS) at Cochin
    Shipyard Limited (CSL), in the southern state of
    Kerala, after years of delays due to technological and
    financial problems. The cutting of steel is set to
    start on 11 April.

    The 225 m-long and 58 m-wide Project 71 vessel, for
    which Rs32.61 billion ($725 million) has so far been
    allocated, is expected to enter service in 2012.
    …………..
    The Naval Design Bureau used a “modular approach” for
    the ADS to reduce construction time and the layout for
    300 of its 2,000 “compartments” has already been
    dispatched to CSL, Vice Adm Prasad said.

    The shipyard will follow the integrated hull outfit
    and painting method for construction and the vessel’s
    keel should be laid in October 2007.

    Steel for the ADS has been sourced locally following a
    steep price hike in Russian steel, which was
    originally under consideration and a principal cause
    for the programme’s delay. Some 20,000 tonnes of steel
    are required.

    The vessel will be powered by four General Electric LM
    2500 gas turbines, producing an optimum speed of 28 kt
    and a logistic endurance of around 45 days. It will
    carry a complement of 1,400 personnel, including 160
    officers.

    Italy’s Fincantieri SpA is providing CSL designs for
    integrating the propulsion system, engine room
    layouts, validation of systems, tests and sea trials.

    The technical part of the Fincantieri contract will
    last two years but assistance will continue until
    commissioning.
    ……………

    In an unrelated development, Vice Adm Prasad said the
    IN would conclude by year-end an agreement with the US
    Navy (USN) to purchase submarine rescue vessels, which
    it is currently lacking. The USN will also render
    assistance to IN submariners in the event of a mishap.

    Negotiations date from 1995 but ended abruptly after
    Washington imposed sanctions on India for its 1998
    nuclear tests.

    The IN has already made a downpayment of $100,000 for
    the rescue vessels and a USN evaluation of India’s
    submarine fleet is under way.

    ……………

    in reply to: IAF- news & discussions- MARCH 2005 #2622172
    Indian1973
    Participant

    anyone have details on Elta’s new El/M-2052 radar ? Flight international Feb05 reported it had entered tests.

Viewing 15 posts - 256 through 270 (of 1,845 total)