dark light

Malcolm McKay

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,306 through 1,320 (of 1,462 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: T-28 Trojan In Combat #1260309
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    The Laotian was imprison after he landed rofl

    Someone defects to your country (you seem to be a bit more supportive of the North so I’ll just go with that one…) and you laugh because he was put in prison?

    Am I missing something here?

    I would hope you wouldn’t wish ill upon anyone who wished to defect your country. I certainly wouldn’t wish ill upon anyone who wished to defect to the United States which is my home nation.

    Rather depends on why someone defects – if a criminal “defects” to another country to avoid prosecution in their country for say, murder, theft, assault, etc. then imprisonment must be the option followed by judicial repatriation to their home country. I suspect that stealing an aircraft is theft in anyone’s language.

    Kindly remember the international agreements on hijackers – most are returned to the country whose aircraft they hijacked. Otherwise we would have more international anarchy than we have now.

    As to the other implication – the reality is that the North Vietnamese were the moral winners. If we westerners had done the right thing and supported the Vietnamese rather than the illegal return of the French then Ho Chi Minh would not have been driven into the arms of the Russians. As with Cuba we have never learn the important lesson – stay out of civil wars and national uprisings against colonialist oppressors.

    in reply to: scare tactics…. #1262106
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    The RAF installed a rearward firing flamethrower in the bomb bay of a Beaufort. It never went beyond the trials stage though.

    Best wishes
    Steve P

    That’s because they forgot to open the bomb bay doors before firing it boom boom 😀

    in reply to: scare tactics…. #1262637
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Try:

    Thanks James – the exact words had completely escaped me.

    in reply to: scare tactics…. #1263035
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    I am reminded of the Duke of Wellington’s remark about his troops which went along the lines of –

    “I don’t know how the French feel, but they certainly scare me”

    in reply to: Largest wooden propeller???? #1264269
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    My source, the Guinness Book of Records 1985 edition, says the Linke-Hoffman R II flew in 1919 at Wroclaw, Poland as an airliner, with 4 x 260 hp Mercedes piston engines driving 22 ft 7.5 in. dia. propellers at 545 rpm.

    Actually those 4 engines were geared to drive only one propellor – no wonder it was so big.

    If the photos of this aircraft didn’t have people in them to give the scale – it’d look like a generic WW1 two seater observation aircraft – the thing is huge.

    in reply to: Largest wooden propeller???? #1264273
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Largest IMHO is the propellor of the Linke-Hoffman R.II, a WW1 German bomber. Diameter was 23 feet.

    This aircraft actually flew in 1919.

    in reply to: scare tactics…. #1264950
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Well although it doesn’t quite meet the question I say the thought of going to war in a Blackburn Botha scares the waste substances out of me.

    😉

    in reply to: Hurricane's claims to fame #1282439
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Much as I hate to admit it, probably somewhere behind the Brewster Buffalo. Did any of the FAA Buffalos manage to get to North Africa after Crete? Best wishes Steve P

    According to the Kagero book on the Buffalo (written by Andre Zbiegniewski) – 3 got to Egypt via Cyrus but vanish without trace after the quick reequipment of 805 Squadron with Martlets. A fourth aircraft was left behind on Crete and captured by the Germans.

    in reply to: Building a Chipmunk from scratch #1283217
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Building a Chipmunk is easy – start with something larger. A dog and cut away all the bits that don’t look like a chipmunk.

    😀

    in reply to: Largest Calibre gun #1284839
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    It is the Malaria it carries that is the danger… in fact the only more deadly animal on earth is man.

    It’s a pity that we never had the Martin Malaria or the Martin-Baker Malaria. Or how about the Messerchmidt Malaria.

    While we on the subject the Hawker Hernia and the Short Smallpox spring to mind.

    🙂

    in reply to: Hurricane's claims to fame #1286534
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Do we have an advance on the MiG 21 for our jet contender?

    That’s a hard one – it’s certainly been seen in more places that Paris Hilton. But let’s not ignore the Hunter. Europe, South America, Middle East, Far East and India/Pakistan with guest appearances anywhere the sales team went.

    Mirages IIIs also have been spread far and wide. However these days there aren’t the same real classical theatres of war that we had in WW2.

    in reply to: 43 Squadron chequer markings #1286576
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Interesting, it does look white doesn’t it. Why didn’t one of those erks prop up the top wing for the photographer?

    in reply to: Hurricane's claims to fame #1286583
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    I’m trying to find the John Houston film ‘Battle for the Aleutians’ which gives the lie to this generalisation.

    Damn 😮 sprung as it were with a generalisation. Just for you I’ll concede that the Aleutians are technically North America, 😉

    But even your good self must concede that Hurricanes had very little, if nothing, to do with that campaign. It was our gracious, if slightly late, allies the Septics. And they were using their own equivalent of the Hurricane – the P-40.

    Now in North America proper as distinct from that curvy bit at the bottom left hand side of Alaska, the only aerial activity was the odd Japanese balloon, and one overflight or two by Japanese seaplanes launched off submarines. So I really believe that my original statement holds true. 🙂

    The major fracas was the self induced battle of Los Angeles which saw the forces of all that is right committed against the forces of all that is imaginery.

    Now back to my other statement about the Hurricane being a little lacking in the aesthetic sense – well it was :rolleyes: (so there :p ). However you will note that I did not say that this slight lack of classical beauty detracted in any way from its ability. Its a little like the coarse rejoinder about mantle pieces and fire stoking 😀 This is a matter best left for forums of whose existence I know not. 😮

    I have conceded its ubiquity but like some celebrities, is being seen almost everywhere a blessing or a curse? 😉

    in reply to: Hurricane's claims to fame #1286862
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    So no-one’s got a type with broader service? (VoyTech’s excellent points regarding the definition of ‘theatre’ and ‘fighter’ notwithstanding.)

    Look you’ve won me James 🙂 But, and here I go qualifying again (I know its reprehensible 😮 ) but as a trained historian with several postgraduate degrees (I know I’ll have fire and brimstone, not to mention vile epithets hurled at my hoary but unbowed head 🙁 ), I have always taken what you might call the strategic as distinct from the tactical view.

    And while the Hurricane is indeed a noble beast, if a little lacking in the aesthetic sense (its a conformation issue), I feel that the real advances by our noble lads did not take place until it was replaced by more serious, in 1942 terms, kit. It held the line in a few cases and retreated rather quickly in others (well the people who actually did the fighting did). But as the French would say c’est la guerre .

    Now in view of its ubiquity I am now going to go to my spare room and personally stroke each of my representative selection of Hurricanes until they purr 😉

    Personally I’ve always like the humpbacked beauty but others couldn’t wait untill they got more modern equipment.

    in reply to: Hurricane's claims to fame #1286935
    Malcolm McKay
    Participant

    Can’t leave the qualitative alone, can you Malcolm. 😉 Which bit of “…fought on more fronts, in more countries and in more theatres than any other fighter in history.” Let’s try and explore a new arena, rather than rehashing the same old… Hmmm?

    Gee James, qualifying is most of the fun of an argument :p What are you trying to do – stick to cold hard logic? The last time I did that on this forum my qualifications, parentage and sexuality were called into question 😀

    The noble Hurricane fought about eveywhere it was possible, I agree but (here I go qualifying again) North American service doesn’t count really. Apart from a couple of Japanese balloons, b****r all happened in aerial combat terms in North America. The greatest danger in North America from aircraft was student pilots falling on the hapless populace.

    Without raising the, no doubt sensitive and righteously angry, hackles of the Canadians there AFAIK no incidents of aerial combat taking place in Canada or in the immediate coastal waters. Now that will open a barrage of the abovementioned insults (whoops contradictory argument 🙁 ).

    Yes I am prepared to conced its ubiquity but as to its strategic effectiveness that is another matter.

    Happy now.

    Damn but this fun 🙂

Viewing 15 posts - 1,306 through 1,320 (of 1,462 total)