dark light

jackjack

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 1,733 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2377353
    jackjack
    Participant

    During the fights, both sides have tried all possible conditions, from the most favorable to least favorable. And both sides scored kills and losses, just like at every exercise. Especially at Dubendorf, it’s hard to beat the Swiss because they know every damn corner of their land and will beat your F-22s even with old Mirage IIIs and F-5Es suddenly appearing from some hole between the hills, the plane is by far not everything that counts!

    But that doesn’t make the F/A-18 a better dogfighter than MiG-29. From what I have read, MiG can point its nose every bit as hard as the Bug and only slightly less than Mirage 2000, which is the rumored No.1 performer in this field. But contrary to the Bug, MiG doesn’t bleed energy as fast and regains knots much easier which gives it a fair 50/50 chance on initial encounter and exponentially growing chances on all following maneuvers, where the excess energy help the MiG jock to dictate the conditions. That’s all even without the HMS.

    My link shows an article in Swiss paper Blick which was unfortunately removed since then, yes. But if you are actually eager to know, then you see enough references about the outcome.
    The article is called “Die F-18C unterliegt MiG-29G in der Schweiz”, which means “F-18C beaten by MiG-29G in Switzerland”. If that is not enough, you can observe the reactions of the posters which clearly indicate the outcome, even if we cannot read the article itself anymore.

    If saying that MiG-29 is a better dogfighter than F-18C only means “spouting crap due to lack of respect towards US equipment”, then I will gladly continue spouting this crap even further. And there is nothing you can do about it, sorry.

    you realise of course that the euro’s didnt update their FCS untill they did their upgrades just recently ?

    if you can be bothered to look, you will see a great roll improvement about 2003/4 when it went from ~35 to ~55 AOA
    page 26
    http://dspace.mit.edu/bitstream/handle/1721.1/36378/16-885JFall2003/NR/rdonlyres/Aeronautics-and-Astronautics/16-885JFall2003/70D5449E-60FA-4C95-B80B-D4B19D12C222/0/sohl_mit_brief.pdf

    in reply to: MMRCA News and Discussion IV #2379044
    jackjack
    Participant

    I have quite a different view on the topic.

    The only two aircraft that really fit the bill are the Rafale and Shornet.

    Both can be operated from the next Indian carrier.

    Both improve overall fleet efficiency with their jamming capabilities like no other contender.

    Both fulfill the self-escorting strikefighter role like no other contender.

    Both have armed forces behind them that are actually commited to further development. (Maybe Gripen can compete here)

    Who wins in the end depends on tech transfer and the quality of the offered Growler light in my opinion.

    Personal choice would be Rafale. Integrated with cheap US PGM’s + French weaponry as alternative choice + commonality with M2K at least weapons wise.

    there are several sources that the f-35 b/c is going to be an allowed sale for the indian carriers
    so i cant see any SH or rafale for the carriers
    the land crafts are still up for grabs

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2379277
    jackjack
    Participant

    scorpion you are trying to score a point that isnt there

    in reply to: Rafale News IX #2379418
    jackjack
    Participant

    i meant just for the 60 uae, it wasnt worth doing a frame change because of cost, if brazil came in as a joint fr uae brazil, then it would be better

    i thought f414 just slipped in, looks like i was wrong, it isnt an option

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2379715
    jackjack
    Participant

    read my post again
    “outside of usa and most of the time within, the f-22 flys with radar reflectors for security, its only in war mode it runs its true RCS”
    the word ‘most’ allows for secured exercises within usa

    i dont know what they do to the top, all i know is there is a hot and cold rcs
    if you tell me how all the rcs tech works on a f-22, it may explain it
    while you’re at it can you tell me why the f-35 has 2 layers of ‘electrified mesh’ ?

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2379812
    jackjack
    Participant

    In an unverified story, French M2000 didn’t seem to have troubles locking on F22, even though its radar is considerably less powerful than APG63.

    you’re only showing what you dont know, outside of usa and most of the time within, the f-22 flys with radar reflectors for security, its only in war mode it runs its true RCS
    i have no doubt the m2000 saw it, even airport radar picks it up at distance

    in reply to: Rafale News IX #2380700
    jackjack
    Participant

    i think most of what you say is accurate, you are open to discussion and not fanboy rantings and i have said to others what you have posted on occasion

    the passive mica shot and gps weapons, we arent of the same opinion but we are close
    we disagree on AC, you think it is possible that the rafale has it, i think its just the subs

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2380979
    jackjack
    Participant

    cola, have you got the link to your f-16 claim and how it relates to the production f-35 ?
    no its not said to be better, the f-35 has the ~same sub & transonic as the f-22 and the f-22 takes the lead in supersonic

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2381000
    jackjack
    Participant

    cut it anyway you want, LM have just that its “better”

    in reply to: Rafale News IX #2381008
    jackjack
    Participant

    i know france is happy as is, but UAE want a bigger engine, it might be easier to fit the f414, they only want 60 planes, is it worth doing all the work ?
    if brazil want 9 ton too then it would be worth it

    in reply to: Rafale News IX #2381039
    jackjack
    Participant

    you’re probably right but that wasnt the impression i got, you might want to check that if you’re not sure, as i dont know

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2381049
    jackjack
    Participant

    has there been any guns dogfight between phoons and teens reported ?

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2381064
    jackjack
    Participant

    so we accept every thing EF say, but LM are liars, LOL

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2381070
    jackjack
    Participant

    if they use it in airshows they probably do, did the rafale say about TVC ? thats the only guns dogfight i’ve seen reported

    but as far as the f-16 and fa-18 goes the f-35a is better

    g – longer better
    acceleration – shorter better
    http://a.imageshack.us/img138/4146/image4u.jpg

    in reply to: Euro-fighter F-35 fight heats up! #2381078
    jackjack
    Participant

    ok, if you have seen it on the video’s or read it, it does, unless you’re guessing like me
    the reason i mentioned the f-22 is because of rafale and i think the rafale would take the phoon in a guns dogfight

Viewing 15 posts - 166 through 180 (of 1,733 total)