dark light

Gollevainen

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,351 through 1,365 (of 2,664 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040110
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Beg pardon, but thats hard to believe considering:

    It doesen’t matter if you post a list of russian gas turbine ships when none of them has the same GODOG arragement as in 052s.
    The arragement calls for two powerfull gasturbines, orginally indended to be LM2500 but they have to substitute for much inferior engines. This wasen’t done becouse they suddenly decided to go for better to worse, but the 1989 incidence in Tiananmen made the US engines unavailable. Thus they had to seddle for two somewhat same class (but with 48 000 hp against the 55 000 hp of LM2500) ukrainian engines.

    As the designing of chinese warships, bigger warships is somewhat in the “children’s shoes” as we say here, there really wasen’t any other solution for the new 052B/C class ships. Those ships (or any ships of that size) should have had IMO either GOGAG or GOGOG arragment with four gas turbines, but the limitations in chinese shipbuilding and development area prevented this.

    Adding that couple of knots isn’t worth the cost and trouble if not required specifically by operations

    Apparently that what chinese are now forced to say and think. But if the solution would have been good, why did those classes ended up with only two ships being build per class? The need for modern DDGs didn’t just suprisingly stopped, nor some equipment change would be the reason for such a long delay (just look the 054A status). It’s quite clear that China isen’t going to replicate that shipdesign any longer and I think thats a good choise.

    in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040139
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    What tactical advantages will appear if their top speed will be 32 knots instead of 29?

    they will be faster… :dev2: :dev2:

    My using the words “for example” indicates that the top speed isen’t the only proplem. There are rumours of operational proplems with the propulsion system onboard 052B/C. And underpowering isen’t only affecting the top speed…You can imagine it yourself…what happens when you put Ladas engine to Mercedes Benz???

    But this sort of thinking “so what if it’s few knots slower, few missiles weaker, few generations older” is just trying to be optimistic about the actual ship floating, it wont however make it anyway better…

    in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040147
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    I’m not sure what problems you guys have with that propulsion… They most likely have their reasons to build it with that propulsion.

    Yeas quite forcing reason, it was only availble option. But that doesen’t make it anyway better. The first 052 type destroyer, 112 (luhu class) had two LM2500 gas turbines but when they where unvailable, the seccond ship, 113 had to seddle for two Ukrainian turbines with inferior performance. The unvailability of good enough gas turbines led to the Luhai class which fielded old steam turbines. The steam turbines are even with chinese standarts, an ageing solution so thรบs they where forced to follow (apparently the chinese shipdesign pace isen’t yet fittted for the rapid need of large surface combatants previously beeing abcent in PLANs plans) the 052 series with the underpowered gasturbine arragment. Altough the gas turbines in 052B/C are improved ones (tough still ukrainian) compared to the 113, they are still underpowered and for example the ships top speed is only 29 knots.

    in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040167
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    I agree there will be a new chinese destroyers, but I doupt (or at least hope) they are not the 052 series (due it’s defaults mainly in propulsion matters) but some totally new design…about the time to bring on the 055!!! :dev2:

    in reply to: Russian Navy : News & Discussion #2040168
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    JEESUS didn’t they teach the idea of the edit buttom in those fancy soviet universities??? ๐Ÿ˜ฎ :confused: :rolleyes: ๐Ÿ˜‰ ๐Ÿ˜Ž

    Mod’s should propaply look these two presidents IP’s…I bet they are strickingly similar…

    has anybody seen this Russian airbomber of the picture below???if someone has informations for this aircraft please tell me

    one of the oldest and most succesfull hoax in internets military community. It was said to be a tu-180, soviet shtealth bomber but was in fact photoshoped pic of Tu-160 made by some guy for his quizz…(not me, but some collegue ๐Ÿ˜‰ )

    in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040172
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    That CGI has been around at least since 2003, and it’s nothing more than some private persons proof of adequate CG skills, nothing more. I could draw you half a dozen similar concepts and most of them being far more realistic than that one. You shouldn’t waste your speculations over these kind of pics becouse they hardly represents anything real. Sofar there isen’t even solid enough proof that there would be some “052D” project in the first place…

    in reply to: Yet another request for pics… #2040312
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Thank you, the modernised Capitan romani class actually founds in the destroyer section in http://www.marina.difesa.it/storia/Almanacco/Parte05/Navi0532.htm

    in reply to: General Discussion #350982
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Yeah thats what I would have suggested. thanks… ๐Ÿ™‚

    in reply to: North Korea Pics #1945519
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Yeah thats what I would have suggested. thanks… ๐Ÿ™‚

    in reply to: General Discussion #350986
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Don’t hesitate to ask more, I will gladly tell you what I remember from those times.

    well this migth be rather hard to answer but I will ask it anyway.
    Have you got any Idea of how Finland was wieved among the warsav pact countryes? Becouse I remember that during the Prague Spring, someone made demand for Soviets to let Chekoslovakia to be “similary free as Finland is let”. Its unnaturally huge thing for us finns to know wheter we were held as part of the east or west during the cold war. Many westeners have admitted seeing us under Soviet arm, but how about in the East?

    in reply to: North Korea Pics #1945523
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Don’t hesitate to ask more, I will gladly tell you what I remember from those times.

    well this migth be rather hard to answer but I will ask it anyway.
    Have you got any Idea of how Finland was wieved among the warsav pact countryes? Becouse I remember that during the Prague Spring, someone made demand for Soviets to let Chekoslovakia to be “similary free as Finland is let”. Its unnaturally huge thing for us finns to know wheter we were held as part of the east or west during the cold war. Many westeners have admitted seeing us under Soviet arm, but how about in the East?

    in reply to: General Discussion #351414
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Ac/DC is good too but I find their drum comps quite boring ones…to my cassual listeners ear they sound the same…the band could be pretty amazing whit more creative drummer onboard

    in reply to: NMT New Music Thread for DISCUSSION about musical stuff #1945697
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    Ac/DC is good too but I find their drum comps quite boring ones…to my cassual listeners ear they sound the same…the band could be pretty amazing whit more creative drummer onboard

    in reply to: PLAN Thread (Pics, news, speculations…everything) – 2 #2040559
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    by the way, the pic of the 956em is touched or PS work…you can spot the orginal back ground in some places clearly differing from the nice green hills atop….

    in reply to: Best Shot Of Your Favorite Naval Fighter! #2040719
    Gollevainen
    Participant

    :dev2:
    http://www.fas.org/man/dod-101/sys/ac/row/su33_2.jpg

Viewing 15 posts - 1,351 through 1,365 (of 2,664 total)