dark light

Seawinder

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Propeller types for Spitfire XII and 24 #977573
    Seawinder
    Participant

    Just to flesh it out a bit more.

    R.13/4F5/6 Prop, RA.10108 Dural blades

    R.13/4F5/6 Prop, RA.10107JT Jablo blades

    R.14/5F5/2 Prop, RA.10129 (JT,RTS or JCS) Jablo blades

    “Did Rotol change the colour of their ID disks after the war?” Not after but during the war. Sometime about 1942-43 Jablo blades standardised on the pink/red disks. Prior to that Jadlo blades with a Rotoloid covering used a white disk. Just to confuse matters the white disks were later used to signify Dural blades.

    The colour of the disks on Jablo blades range from a dull matt pink to a the more common dull matt red depending on which subcontractor made them. The colour illustrated in the photo of the IWM Spit 24 is possibly a bit too intense although I should take some of the blame for that as I spent a very pleasant day Duxford advising them on the blade markings.

    Anne

    Hi Anne. Glad to have you weigh in on this. I was in fact aware of the late-war change thanks to the information you and others shared in earlier threads including the one I started about the Spitfire Mk. IX props. I’m definitely going with red for both the XII and 24 kits I’m currently building. It’s really a shame that decal producers (both kit and aftermarket) persist in providing mainly yellow disks for Spitfire blades. The only exception I know of in 1/48 scale is the Techmod stencil sheets, which provide several colors, including the light blue I used on the Mk. IX.

    Cheers.

    in reply to: Propeller types for Spitfire XII and 24 #978057
    Seawinder
    Participant

    I’m sure they did at some stage, which I guess adds to the confusion! (I can’t remember if the post war disks have been discussed in detail here).

    Anyway, here’s a resized picture I took of the IWM MK.24 propeller, which has the ID disk in Red.

    Cheers

    Paul

    That nails it down. Thanks so much for the great photo!
    Pip

    in reply to: Propeller types for Spitfire XII and 24 #978224
    Seawinder
    Participant

    Thanks, Paul. That pretty much confirms what had I thought. Now the only question is, did Rotol change the color of their ID disks after the war? If not, it would seem that the Mk. 24 had red/pink disks, as did the Mk. XII.

    Cheers,
    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1049545
    Seawinder
    Participant

    Just as a follow-up, I decided to go with light blue for the prop labels, and happily a sheet of Techmod Spitfire stencil decals included a whole bunch of disks in pink and light blue with various markings. I used the ones with a “B” which looks rather like the ones in the photo of FY-V. I also reshaped the prop tips to a more rounded configuration as shown in the photo.

    http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/jj243/pnmoss/Prop.jpg

    Thanks, everyone, for the discussion and information.
    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1055654
    Seawinder
    Participant

    No, there were alloy bladed (four bladed) versions.

    If my information is correct, some IXs with Merlin 61 engines had alloy bladed props, while others had wooden blades. IXs with Merlin 63 engines and beyond all had wooden blades. According to http://www.spitfires.ukf.net, EN349 (first flight 2/3/1943) was the first IX with a Merlin 63, while EN498 (FF 4/15/43) was the last one with a Merlin 61. As one can see, there was a period of two months or so when IXs were being produced with both engines. The change-over to wooden bladed props must have happened during that time, at the latest, if not earlier.

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1055665
    Seawinder
    Participant

    There is no trace of any disc ever having been on our alloy blade.

    Some lettering and numbers at the root still clearly visible above the collar. No disc, though. I am as certain as I can be that there never was.

    So, that gives me an escape route if I can’t make up my mind what the proper disk color should be. Thanks!

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1056856
    Seawinder
    Participant

    R5/4F5/4 props were also used with the Merlin 61 but in this case I would say you are correct in thinking that the aircraft in question is fitted with Dural blades which brings me onto the question of colour. The only actual answer I have is…I don’t know.

    I doubt it’s yellow as that is well established as the colour for Waybridge blades at the time of the picture.

    White? Well at some point in 1944 it is adopted for Dural blades, could it have been used before that date?

    One possibility which I have no real evidence for is light blue. This is listed in 1944 as being in use to identify hollow steel Curtiss blades (remembering that Rotol electric props were licence built Curtiss designs). Could it be that it was originally used to identify any metal Rotol blade?

    Anne

    Ooh, blue! That could be neat! I agree that yellow is unlikely since it seems to have been used consistently for spruce/fir construction, and white in 1942 was being used for Jablo wood. If blue, looks like a very pale shade. Bottom line, whatever I choose, it’ll be hard to prove me wrong. Thanks again for the help.

    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1057034
    Seawinder
    Participant

    What markings were used, or if any markings were used at all, on Dural blades pre 1944 appears to be one of the great unanswered of Rotol propellers and I’m sorry to say I don’t have the answer.

    Could it be that the props shown in the photos on the ever wonderful Britmodller are not of R3/4F5/2 propellers with Dural blades but R5/4F5/4 props with RA 10046RTS Jablo blades? In 1943 these would have a white disks.

    Tony T’s images are of Hoffman blades (checked by Dowty Rotol) which use a similar marking system but are not representative of the markings used during the war.

    Anne

    Hi Anne. Thanks for the response.

    Is there any particular reason to suppose that the props are NOT R3/4F5/2’s? According to “Spitfire: the History,” that was the specified prop for Merlin 61s, plus the shape of the prop tips is clearly unlike the typical Jablo blades (see pic in post above).

    I agree that the pictures Tony T posted do not reflect wartime markings.

    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1057044
    Seawinder
    Participant

    The shot of the MK VII in the Britmodeller post is of EN474 in the US.

    I photographed this machine prior to restoration in 1972 and subsequent installation in the Smithsonian.

    It has a dull red disc and is not a dural (aluminium alloy) blade.

    Mark

    The photo I’m talking about shows BS451, a Mk. IX of 611 Sqn.:

    http://i274.photobucket.com/albums/jj243/pnmoss/BS451.jpg

    The disks are clearly a similar color to the spinner and/or the prop tips.

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1057794
    Seawinder
    Participant

    I have seen magnesium blades (or evidence thereof!) on earlier Spitfires (eg IIa) but not sure if they carried these on to later mark Spits.

    Have just checked out metal blade we have. It has no disc – yellow or white!

    Bummer! The photo I’ve seen shows small, light-colored disks just outside the spinner (closer to it than the typical placement on wooden blades). I’ve read that white became the indicator for Dural blades, but it was used earlier on Jablo wooden blades with Rotoloid covering before the change-over to pink for all Jablo wooden blades. Yellow seems to have Rotol’s designator for spruce construction, but could they also have used it for Dural as well?

    In any case, thanks for checking.
    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1058197
    Seawinder
    Participant

    I honestly cannot recall, but will ask my colleague who has it in his workshop.

    I think the discs are still there, and seem to think they were yellow. The aircraft in question was lost in 1943.

    An odd feature of this blade is that the tips were red and yellow instead of just the four inch yellow tip – but I suspect just a ‘one off’.

    That’d be great, Andy, thanks! I can hold off on the prop for a week or so, and I’ll go with yellow in the absence of any further information.

    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1058203
    Seawinder
    Participant

    I took these on the Mk19

    http://www.britmodeller.com/forums/index.php?showtopic=50088

    Hi Tony.
    Yes, I saw those over at britmodeller. They’re lovely pics, even with your mug, but they’re also postwar markings. I don’t believe the Rotol logo appeared during the war.

    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1058664
    Seawinder
    Participant

    I do have a Dural (Rotol) blade from a Spitfire IX with extant markings.

    It isn’t here, but I can organise pics if it helps.

    I would so much appreciate knowing what color the small disks were just outside the spinner. I’m working on a 1/48 early Spit IX and would like to get it right.

    Thanks!
    Pip

    in reply to: Need help with a Rotol propeller #1058668
    Seawinder
    Participant

    Here’s mark V’s other post with piccies

    http://forum.keypublishing.co.uk/showthread.php?t=77470

    Hi Tony.
    Yes, I’ve read all the threads I could find at this forum about Rotol labeling, but everything I’ve found relates to wooden bladed props, not Dural.

    Pip

Viewing 14 posts - 1 through 14 (of 14 total)