You can´t have a one sided descision and it is hard to judge for the entire tiime frame.
For the western side runners-up are :
F-86 Sabre (no doubt about it)
F-104 Starfighter (to arm many NATO Forces, although unpopular with the USAF)
F-4 Phantom (NATO workhorse and my favorite)
F-15 Eagle
F-16
WarPac :
MiG-15 (the early jet)
MiG-17 (early but long lasting and much loved)
MiG-21 (developed from pure daylight F-104 like plane, to quite a capable all weather fighter)
MiG-29 (bringing 4th genration aircraft to the WarPac. At least quie on paar with the latest the NATO had when it entered service)
SU-22
I like your list but I think you are over looking a great aircraft from that time period: The Douglas A-4 Skyhawk. The US Navy used them for every possible task, fighter, bomber, tanker, trainer, etc. The Israelis used them with great success, and they formed the back bone of the RNVAF.