OTE=flex297]I would take an Su-35 over the J-10 any day of the week, so much is clear.
If you want to compare cockpits then do not mix 20-year old Sukhois with FC-1s that only exist in several prototypes. I will show you a cockpit of a Chinese F-7P in service with PAF to see how advanced your aircraft really are..
http://www.mig-21.de/deutsch/technikausruestung.htm
at least 70% of posters here are not native English speakers. Including me…[/QUOTE]
so everyone have to have english same level like you? that do not make sense, you are not teacher.
you cannot take Su-35 because it never even go into air force of Russia, it is just like blue angels now. you can take it but it will get shot down fast.
and yes I can use that Sukhoi because it is the one everyone but MKI is using. the FC1 cockpit is cockpit that Pakistan will get next year, so no difference. You do not see Su-35 going to enter service of any air force even in 5 years! by 10 year it become old news when JSF and F-22 become big. China will have J-12 prototype already.
also people keep saying Russian economy bounce back.. it is not the same.
Russia economy go down with Gorbashop, then go down with Yaltsin even worse for 10 year then only go back up in 2000 because of oil, that is all! just oil. Russian economy rely on oil and raw resouce, banking and finance stuff is too risky and will not develop there. It cannot compete with China. China from 1980 only growing and never stop growing, it never drop below 9% GDP grow. it have almost 30 years of growing when Russia only have 6-7 year, but China growing is more diversify and do not rely only on oil and resource. there is many manufacturing and technology too. and yes Chinese cars cannot be compare to other minor car from emerging market, any one can make car, but Chinese cars is one of largest car producer in world with Geely, Chery, etc. You do not see Russia go far with Lada, it is like old decade. Chinese car still have some improvement, it is not best in quality like Swedesh Vulva or Japanese Lexus but is getting there fast!
also you guys is also hippocrit, first you say China get J-10 from Israel now you say Russia, it seem the only thing you want to do is put China down because you cannot accept reality. you have to realize the reality. China is only partnering with Russia because of US, but in the end, Russia is still Russia, they make war with China when they have Imperial King, and they still make war with China when they become Cummonist, all on old Chinese land too! sometime things do not change.
AdmarilZhengHe, do you have any useful contribution to this forum? All I see is endless bashing of anything that is Russian.
Like it or not, without the Russian hardware PLAAF would be nothing! If it weren’t for the Sukhois and Lyuka-powered J-10s even Taiwan alone could defeat PLAAF in a short time.
the problem you and other people keep saying is that you use example from 20 year ago but not current things.
of course in on time, China have to use many Russian airplane to catch up, but it do not stay like that all the time. If you look now, China do not order much Su-30 like 10 year ago, they do not order as many ship or submrine, etc because now they can do their own. J-10 is only temporary. You do not know, but there is new engine called WS-10 that replace Russian engine in J-10, also new engine will come out for FC-1. in only 5 years China can make a full Chinese version of Su-27 with improve engine (WS-10 is goign to be more efficint than Russian one).
the logic you use is like this
american make first car assembly line, so they have to be best inc ars now.
but htat is not true
America first to do it but Japan, China and Korea now make better cars
30-40 year ago, China use many Russian tank, but now they use almost only Chinese tank. The Navy no need sovremmy now, because 169-171 is better and stealth.
I compare JF-17 instead of J-10 because difference between J-10 is much bigger than Mirage 2000 and JF-17. J-10 is obviously better, but harder when coparing with JF-17
Empty 6,411 kg
Loaded weight 10,072 kg
Maximum takeoff weight 15,474 kg
Mirage
Empty weight: 1(7,600 kg)
Max takeoff weight: (16,500 kg)
The important question is China has been working alone or working with Russian help?
Russia has flown new aircraft since the Break up of the USSR, new aircraft are the Tu-334, Yak-130, Su-47 Berkut. Su-30MKI. MiG-1.44 and has the fastest bomber and largest combat aircraft the Tu-160.
but this examples all started from USSR times.
MiG.144 is rooted in 80s
Su-30 is base on design from 70s, just upgrade
Tu-334 start in late 80
etc
and guess what
Tu-334 – only 5 order
Yak-130 – not even in production
Su-47- 1 airplane no interest
MiG-144 – 1 airplane no interest
Tu-160 – new airplane base on old Soviet era incomplete one.
only Su-30MKI is doing good and u have to thank you to India for that one
you is right that China do not have same variety, but half they do not need.
China do not need Tu-160 because we have no plan to bomb USA, only Muslim people do. China is not aggressive like USSR, we just want old land back.
Every post by this guy has been bashing Russian equipment while saying China’s own weapons programs are superior. Why are they still buying airframes and engines from Russia? Its hilarious cause his points are baseless.
Man in space? Russia until recently was the only country regularly sending people to the International space station because the space shuttle fleet was grounded. Was that 40 years ago?
please do not do member bashing. you only have problem because you only pick out my words that is critical of Russian industry. I even say that Russian produce good airplanes until 1970s. You need to realize the reality.
also point about living standard of China is not related to this. you must not have been to shanghai, hong kong, beijing, chongqing, etc. new building everywhere. i will show pictures but maybe in general’s discussion thread.
also the Tu-160 that is new one is just continuition of two incomplete one in Tuplev Kazan. You can pick out some project that is new and okay, but vast majority of Russian military stuff is not okay and base on used model.
Also China use to import alot from Russia, but now China can do its own, notice that it do not order as much anymore. no new soveremeeney or T-80 in a logn time. this will go to everything else too.
I don’t see why not, they’re comparable in terms of capability and performance. It’ll come down to support, pilot training, and effective employment of weapon systems.
but one is upgrade of 2nd generation aircraft. other is new 4th generation aircraft
Full of BS as usual. Your posted Su-35 cockpit is 15 years old while your posted FC-1 cockpit is not even in series.
BTW, do something about your grammar.. Feels almost like encrypted messages.
it is not BS because you maybe do not realize but Su-35 is becoming old airplane.
this one may surprise you but this is Su-27 cockpit, but it is still use today
FC-1 cockpit is futuristic type and will be out next year in PAF service.
do not mind my English, I am not native speaker and this forum is not only for American and English people. I think it is not good that you criticize people who try to make effort in their English language.
J-8F/H are still being converted and inducted. They even inducted J-7Gs this year! CAC still has a production line that had to be converted from J-7 to J-10. These old aircrafts aren’t going away anytime soon.
I know that is why I say I hope.
SOC:
if you do not like FC-1, do you at least agree FC-1 can challenge India MiG-21M.Bison?
yeah Paraguay has six? Tucanos and four? Xavantes, it´s a big threat…..
no it is gorilla warfare in the jungle that is problem. Not airplane
just look at new export Su-35 cockpit and than compare ur cockpits floating around.
ok so you see for yourself
FC-1 cockpit
Su-35 cockpit
at least one generation different.
also the proof you guys use is not so good. Tu-160 in production? no it is incomplete one from Soviet time, it is not new. Russia is only exporting left over and spare stuff from Soviet day like unused Fulcrum. Russia is poor, all the engineer left for better paying job to other countries that is why they have alot of project that exist but going nowhere. you can bring them up but it is not good because it is not going anywhere.
Type 99 is example of how China surpass Russia. so the ships is too. It seem you rely too much on examples from Soviet era when we are talking about now. So what Russia send man in space.. that is almost 40-50 year ago, China send a man in space too. China space program is healthy.. Russia cannot even maintain Miers space station and when it work, it dont work. like i say before, Russia is stagnating.
Also Russia know they like Boning, they have to buy Boning so to modernize, no one want aircaft except they is Boning or Airbus
When wil Vatican become Muslim? interesting!
When wil Vatican become Muslim? interesting!
Russia has over China still a lot of advantage, it is not true that the gap is a small one, almost all the Chinese Jet have Russian tech in one way or other and many are basicly Russian aircraft build in China. Russia has almost thousends of Satellites launched and many many more cosmonauts launched.
The Russians are not lagging behind as you are saying with respect the west, modern russian aviation has avionics made in Russia that do not yield to western equipment, in fighter technology the Su-34, MiG-31 and Kamov Ka-50 have little competition.By exception of the Russia, Ukraine, the EU, the US, canada and Brazil no other nations operate civil jet airliners in the range of 90 to 440 passengers built domestically.
And in nukes no other nation has more Nukes than Russia, the Russian economy is growing fast, it is an illusion of many that think Russia is a weak nation, it is not, it is still a power with enough strength
Here is the reason why Russia is leading over China
i do not see how it lead over China.
You show many Airliner but who is buying them? the world want Airbus and Boning, not Tuploev. Even Russian buying Boning. China alraedy start producing airliners and had built one a few decade ago. Chna hve better marketing power in civilian sector than Russia.
The bombers you post..when is last time they make it? they are all old left over and all the engineer who make it, no longer work for Russia because Russia have no funding. its technology will stagnate now while China rise fast.
The economy you have no understanding in. Russia only grow because it export oil and raw resource, all other industry is dead or uncompetitive. China has much more diversify economy and can afford to feed engineers.
Already China surpass Russia in MBT and IFV, when new Chiense and other engine go into production, J-10 and FC-1 no longer have any Russian in them. WZ-10 show omre promise for attck helicopter than Ka-50
Excuse the ignorance….but does Brazil have any serious enemies?
yes, Brazil fight big war with Paraguay and almost fight Argentina two time. very bad.
so why do they not consider Gripen this time?
Saudi Arabia take no loss really, it is big benefit.. Eurofighter cost many moneys for the type of aircraft it is. Maybe they need to consider East instead.