dark light

HAWX ace

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 674 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Military Aviation News-2015 #2229634
    HAWX ace
    Participant
    in reply to: Impressive Weapons Load 2 (again) #2236028
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    The fuel tanks are most likely empty to save weight for the photoshoot to be possible.

    in reply to: How would you re-build the Argentinian military aviation? #2243867
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    Su-24M2 has combat radius of approx. 600 km in LO-LO-LO attack profile (with 3 tonnes of bombs & missiles), enough to go from Argentina to Falklands and back. Low altitude means impossible to be detected from land radar station, except when the Su-24M2 will be less than 40-60 km from Falklands. So a unique Su-24M2 could simulate LO-LO-LO/LO-LO-HI attacks with air-to-surface missiles to Falklands, returning 50-100km from Falklands, without being intercepted by Eurofighter. Then the Su-24M2 would return to Argentina in supersonic speed and high altitude, being almost impossible to be intercepted by Eurofighters scrambled some minutes after the Su-24M2 was detected.

    The presence of Su-24M2 could force UK to have AEW airplanes and/or more Eurofighters and/or frigates as radar pickets, i.e., to spend a lot more in Falklands air defence.

    Even if one entirely accepts your scenario, there is a saying describing it just perfectly: “A single cuckoo bird is not enough to bring the spring”. If Argentina decided to spend the lions’ share of its defense budget for that single “cuckoo bird” (the Su-24 sqn), it wouldn’t be able to afford anything else.

    in reply to: F-35 News, Multimedia & Discussion thread (3) #2246979
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    Excuse my long post…

    Bang for the buck is horrendous, & it remains to be seen if SA is all that much better than competitors, whether WW support works (good luck to greece when they have to send their F35 to the upgrade shop in turkey), low cost of upgrades (haha low cost & F35 in the same sentence).

    I doubt that is ever going to happen. Lockheed Martin would have to bribe everyone, even the last conscript airman for such a deal to go through.

    Looks like the EU citizens will be providing bailout payments to Greeks who will, in return, go shopping to the US to get the most expensive and the most useless fighter in existence today… Yes, you can bet on that.. 🙂

    even if someone was willing to fund Greece for such a procurement, which seems already impossible, I don’t see that happening.

    Buying more F-16s instead of the Typhoons was a smart move on their part.

    It was a smart move indeed, but it was also an extremely lucrative one for those who participated in it.

    Nonsense! Greece is entirely independent. The Greek government can do whatever it wishes.

    The Greek government cannot do whatever it wishes; as with any government, it can only do whatever it can pay for. If somebody else does the paying part, he can then intervene at any time, which is hardly indepedence.

    Useless for Greece, not useless in general… That means not fitting their doctrine, structure and budget… When was it last time Greeks needed to penetrate anyone’s air defenses to strike a high valued target? Was it ever?

    Rest assure, there are quite a few high value targets in Turkey.

    Before that, HAF was tasked with penetrating then WP member Bulgaria’s airdefences. At the time it was hardly an easy task. But you are right that in terms of doctrine the F-35 does not suit our needs, especially our current needs.

    There’s not a hope in hell of Greece buying F-35 in the near future. No money. Even before the world banking crisis they had to scrap their intended Typhoon purchase due to lack of funds.

    The Eurofighter purchase was not scrapped due to lack of funds at that time; it was scrapped mainly for political reasons: Mr Sarkozy strongly insisting in selling his own toys and UK proving to be in love with Turkey over Cyprus much, much, much more than with Greece. Later on it proved the right thing to do after all, judging from the purchase outcome in Austria.

    Only way I can foresee Greece buying F-35 would be if Turkey had it in service and it proved to give them a big advantage over the non-VLO aircraft in Greece’s fighter fleet.

    That’s true, but then again we are talking at least beyond 2025. Many things could be different by then.

    Greece was never particularly big or rich, yet throughout its NATO service it could maintain a more than respectable and quite capable actually, Air Force with diverse assets maintaining about 300-350 front line NATO fighters up to the 2000s. Well all that is gone now and the spectacularly high F-35 price is not going to allow that to change.

    One thing that most people don’t understand about Greek military procurements is that unlike other NATO members we were not preparing for war against the Warsaw Pact as much, but rather against a fellow allied NATO member. This understandably is incomprehensible to a neutral outside watcher, but it’s the truth. This is why we did not scrap our military after the Cold War, like the other European nations.

    As for the numbers, HAF had always tried and mostly managed to acquire seven fighters for every ten THK did. So if HAF had 300-350 operational front line fighters up to the 2000s, at the same time THK would have 450-500. This ratio hasn’t changed dramatically so far and I doubt it will change in the future – numbers may be dropping in HAF, but they also drop in THK. For instance initially they claimed to buy at least 120 F-35s. Today nobody knows how many will be bought, and out of those bought, how many will be flyable at any given time. We withdrew some sqns due to age, but so did THK; We lose a few frames in accidents, but THK in time loses more over Kurdistan. We can’t buy new frames, and THK has been postponing their own buys in turn and so on.

    in reply to: HELLENIC AIR FORCE NEWS & DISCUSSION #2247594
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    A HAF detachment recently visited Israel for joint exercises. They practiced High Value Airborn Asset Escort, air to air missions and air refueling.

    http://www.haf.gr/newsmedia/2014/12/2014-12-15_sunekp_01.jpg

    http://www.haf.gr/newsmedia/2014/12/2014-12-15_sunekp_05.jpg

    http://www.haf.gr/el/news.asp?id=9614

    in reply to: Military Aviation News-2014 #2248755
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    US approves Chinook CH-47D sale to Greece

    That’s nice indeed, but it’s highly unlikely for the sale to move on, given the projected changes in the political background.

    in reply to: Rumoir: Greece to lease Atlantique 2s? #2249255
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    Herard a rumour that Greece is to lease Atlantique 2s as well as some frigates from France.

    Is this true?

    I note on Scramble’s Greek orbat page that the P-3B’s of 353 MNAS are listed as withdrawn from use.

    If this was true at some point, it is not anymore since
    a) The HN has opted to modernise its aging fleet of P-3Bs instead (link). It’s uncertain if the project will move on and when, or what it will include after all but what is for sure is that Atlantiques are not an issue anymore.
    b) There will be elections in February, and the projected new government has clearly indicated that will drastically cut defence spending anyway.

    As for swerve, I wouldn’t worry about him. He has repeatedly demonstrated way too much ignorance with even the most basic historic aspects in the area to be taken seriously.

    in reply to: Did India buy Qatar's Mirage 2000s so that Pakistan couldn't? #2250593
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    This is what happens when you use Wiki as a source dude….

    PAF is heavily involved with the Qatari air force, but no planes to buy their Mirage 2ks, and India made an offer that was rejected (again I could be wrong on that though), but they are certainly not in Indian service.

    Makes much more sense for India to buy 12 planes it can easily integrate into it’s current Mirage 2000 fleet then Pakistan inducting a totally new type with only 12 examples.

    However if Pakistan is (was) under embargo or under the strong possibility of being embargoed, this point is nullified. In that case, any country would try to acquire virtually any kind of military hardware and in any quantity possible.

    HAWX ace
    Participant

    But … Tom Clancy taught me that fast jets eat helicopters for breakfast. 🙁

    Tom was right; but the scenario described in his book is hardly the case in everyday real life.

    HAWX ace
    Participant

    How useful would attack helicopters actually be in the presence of sophisticated fighter and SAM threats?

    What can an attack helicopter do that a Harrier can’t?

    fly backwards thus retreating from the enemy but with weapons systems still facing them.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Kpol9nVe_OU

    HAWX ace
    Participant

    Did Kawasaki already got permissions to sold Civilian versions of C-2 ? Sold it as Civilan or Military versions basically will not really matter for Transport aircraft like this. It’s about the same anyway.

    Although an old post, just for the record, selling a civilian version and converting it for military use is hardly unprecedented for Japanese military hardware. Check YS-11s for instance, sold as airliners to Olympic Airways, then handed over to HAF.

    in reply to: Superior CAS platform: B-1 or A-10? #2213359
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    B1-B with 144 SDB IIs and hours on station, along with SAR for seeing through dense cloud/fog.

    Has this ability ever been actually tested in real combat conditions?

    in reply to: The 'JUST A NICE PIC…' thread #2222747
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    This video is unavailable, who had downloaded it before it was erased?

    It still streams normally. Maybe it’s your IP?

    in reply to: The 'JUST A NICE PIC…' thread #2223248
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    https://ptisidiastima.files.wordpress.com/2012/07/vf23-copy.jpg

    in reply to: Impressive Weapons Load 2 (again) #2228659
    HAWX ace
    Participant

    it’s interesting to mix Sidewinder with ASRAAM. I’d think you could mount six aim-132 instead.

    Maybe it’s because of stockpile limitations…

Viewing 15 posts - 31 through 45 (of 674 total)