Qsaark, has been the instigator in this thread and is now posting full posts on his obscure and fallacious version of a thousand years of Indian history and incidental wrongs that happen everyday in every country to garner some support for his defective ideas.
If you want, pick a country and ill post links too for homicides and the gruesome like that exist annually. No country is a utopia and psychologically defective minds exist in all communities. The problem with pakistan is that such homicidal tendencies are inherent due to a pervading extremist form of islam that’s being taught in the madrassah’s.
Hundred’s of muslims are dying every month in pakistan due to radical suicide bombings and attacks…but this doesn’t faze qsaark. Red mosque anyone?
Benazir Bhutto died yesterday and he explains it as she was a conspirator to a “foreign” agenda. 🙁
As recently as 1971…where close to a million poor muslims were massacred by superior pakistani muslims …still has qsaark harping that all is well in pakistan and among their teachings. One lInk Qsaark….just one :
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hA4vsk3urO4
Its the numbers qsaark, the large numbers that occur in pakistan daily as oppose to the incidental crimes that occur in any nation.
I could also with my basic knowledge of Indian history refute point by point the defective arguments qsaark has put up…but whats the point? He has specifically chosen this thread to distract from Indian missiles and have it closed . Open up a new thread qsaark as farooq as pointed out and the debate shall go on there. Unfortunetly the chance is slim as he knows the mods will sweep down and close any further discussions on this thread.
Nick_76, i would just like to add that i think you’re posts are well articulated and informative. Im sure it takes a lot of time and effort to research and rebutt reflex arguments that seem to crop up in indian threads and the effort is well appreciated. Most of your posts and links are worth archiving and you have my thanks. Think you’re fast running out of people to debate with tho…dropping rather fast after a few reflex posts.
And back to a rather interesting thread.
Originally Posted by coldfire2005
Dassault to Offer Rafale for India Fighter Deal
For me, The Rafale seems to be the peferct choice for the IAF acquisition. Love to see it in IAF colors. Not because the IAF has already got a impressive track record with the Mirage and the ground infrastructure alreadly exists. The IAF will be continually able to upgrade the Mirage to 2005 and beyond. The IN also might be interested in a Rafale M for the the naval carriers.
Add the support said by the french to initially integrate a Kaveri onto the Rafale and vice versa onto the Tejas.
The Tejas along with the Rafale and MKI would make a awesome fleet.
It can’t happen soon enough…….
Tejas Makes Successful First Flight With Stores

Less the distractors, the Tejas keeps moving ahead. The same folk kept arguing about the Dhruv entering service and now with 70+ Dhruvs and WSI Dhruvs coming in….not suprisingly a few changes of words have occurred. My personal view is that India will see itself churning out Hundreds of Tejas as it see’s it’s threat perceptions increase all around it.
Along with Mki’s, The new MRCA, Upgraded Mirage 2005, and upgraded Mig 29’s. We’re talking about an extremely formidable fleet.
Emminent Plans for Hot Pursuit along with it’s Cold Start Docrine.
From Above :
Tejas Prototype Vehicle (PV-1) made a successful first flight with two 800 Ltr drop tanks slung under the wing stations. The flight is significant on several counts. This is the first time Tejas carried any stores other than the Air-to-air missiles which are part of its operational clean configuration. The flight also proved the functionalities of the on-board Stores Management System (SMS) as well as the Control Law (CLAW) of the Integrated Digital Fly-by-wire Control System in the ‘Heavy stores’ mode. Accordingly, today’s flight achieved a significant milestone for the programme, taking it closer to operational clearance for induction into service.
Tejas PV1 was flown by the National Flight Test Centre Test Pilot, Wg Cdr N Tiwari and the Test Director for flight was Wg Cdr M Prabhu. A Jaguar trainer aircraft of ASTE Air Force flown by Wg Cdr RR Tyagi and Sqn Ldr Sangwan was used as chase for this landmark flight.
The flight lasted for about 45 minutes during which the mobile telemetry developed by the National Flight Test Centre for out station flight trials was also checked out.
Some amazing shots from aeroindia.org




In other news taken from last thread and various members who attended the show (Rak, Shiv, Harry @ BR )
Tejas prototype PV4, is to take to the air in a few months….twin seat.
The LSP production series 1 is to be handed over this month, with another 4 to join this year. The rest will join next year.
Production of the 1st 20 is to commence this year with 24 F404 GE IN 20 having being ordered.
Weaponisation is to begin this year with the EL – 2032 radar for which 4-5 sets have been ordered.
MMR is slated to join on LSP 3 this year.
Tejas will make its first night sortie this year as well
PV2 is undergoing modifications for Elbit HMDS & R-73 integration
Lots of info set to come out but from whats arrived, it definetly seems like the Tejas is roaring sky high….
What is sad and worrying is the amount of repeat postings and data already available on the LCA (tejas) that people refuse to accept and instead will readily believe any non existent data on the J10 to be superior.
So much so that any discussion involving the LCA and members like scooter and sea lord have not posted any data to back their opinions but constantly banter on the messenger instead of the wealth of data that he provides.
Infact with repeated answers to their queries they refuse to accept published information from the manufacturers ADA and HAL or even the intents of the users being the IAF. Infact they screamed and hollered the word failure….failure….failure for so long that they can’t and won’t see past it.
I see it as their fear to accept what will be a potential and insurmountable threat…and they hope they can dismiss it with often repetitive statements.
Everyone seems to harp on the various problems of the LCA so let me reiterate what a casual reader seems to garner on the LCA tejas :
1) Primary problem : Too long to develop : Money for the design and go ahead were only released in 1993! Thats 14 years with a couple of years lost in the middle due to sanctions.
In the meanwhile the LCA tejas has created a huge aviation industry that produces technology and upgrades across the whole fleet of combat aircraft and creating new aircraft like the IJT in record time.
2) Secondary problem : Engine : Again Initial production series is to go ahead with GE engines and later examples will be fitted with Kaveri. Recent reports indicate that is has asked for foreign collaboration to complete the project much earlier than previously planned with snecma being the fore runner. Infact much of the work is done and what remaining is finetuning.
3) Radar : Again foreign collaboration with the Israelis to get it completed on time. If not an Israeli substitute is on the cards.
4) No’s : We have 28 aircraft to be delivered by 2010 with more clearly to follow with the IAF’s insistence and push to get the project done as pointed out many times before.
5) MKI’s and MRCA : Dump the LCA and order more of MKI and MRCA shout the prosecution. Personally i think its fear of what the LCA represents…..not only is it a potent fighter but its started a whole aviation industry for fleet wide upgrades…many of its sub systems are even flying in the MKI which is among the world’s best fighters and will be shall in the MRCA. If India can make most of these inhouse it will be able to integrate and produce hundreds of state of the art combat aircraft inhouse than potentially spending billions more to buy that capability.
6) No’s again : India wants hundreds of combat aircraft in the near future. It’s already building 190 Mki’s and looking to buy 40 more. It wants to buy 126 MRCA comabt aircraft and it needs hundreds of LCA to reach it’s target of 40 squadrons to arrest the decline of phasing out older aircraft. And i haven’t even mentioned all the upgrades or even the 5th gen aircraft collaboration with russia starting this year.
For all purposes hundreds of combat aircraft are going to arrive be produced in India in the very near future.
The way i see it…..the only failure is not the aircraft….but the failed states that seems to be cropping up around India…..that’s causing this reaction to spend billions to upgrade it into the dominant force across the Indian Ocean…..
According to this logic, the USAAF crews in the WWII bombing German or Japanese cities were terrorists, as well? AFAIK, they made no difference between ball bearing facilities, shops, funerals or theaters and we all will agree that attacks on civilian infrastructure were deliberate, not accidental.
Yes, it was a terrorist attack on a large scale and numerous debates have gone on since then whether it was necessary. Lets not forget it was a race towards who was going to develop the atom bomb first. The Germans had already shown their indiscriminate killing of civilians wherever they invaded including multiple and random V2 rocket bombing acts on london city.
And lets not forget the Japanese atrocities on civilians over much of south east asia at the time.
I personally believe that if the Germans or the Japanese developed the bomb first, they would have used it on civilians that they were fighting against.
going by what you said this also makes US and many allied countries terrorists also.for instance last night on the BBC documentary show panorama they were following the actions of a british commando unit fighting the taliban and they were under siege in a village in hellmand and called in artillery strikes and air strikes on “suspected” enemy positions.this was in a village which was populated and not abdanoned,regardless of weither or not taliban fighters were killed in the strikes,innocent civilians homes were being destroyed in these attacks
So the way i see this is a british commando unit got stuck fighting their known enemy in a WAR situation and probably called in air strikes becasue they were in a hole and would have died if not. Their intel in this war scenario told them that the enemy was located at a certain positon and asked them to bomb that area.
While it may be unfortunate that civilian homes and civilians may have died in the encounter, the commando’s did not ORDER the strike on the civilians. In war its unfortuante when civilians are caught in the cross fire, but such is the nature of war. Everyone knows this prior. We can all induct and try to minimise the damage with gps bombs, precise artillary shelling but no equipment is infallable.
If the commando’s ordered indiscrimanate shelling of civilian homes and random killing without an objective, yes they would have been seen as terrorists and be court martialled. They would and can still have to answer for their crimes.
To an extent i agree with Meat, Random acts of mass indiscriminate killing on populations without any warning of how and when to prepare designed to scare and create terror for alterior motives is terrorism and should be distinguished from unfortunate casualties of war.
If the taliban and their support groups stuck to fighting their guerilla warfare on combat troops sent to fight them instead of blowing up buildings and buses with civilians thousands of miles away, i for one would not call them terrorists.
2 cents.
Can someone give me some specs as to how good the chinese radar is? As in range and targets acquired. Air to ground capability etc.
Also some specs on the SD 10 instead of the usual its better than the R 77 cos it’s newer and possibly has a better seeker?
Tried googling the above but usually ends up here or in a chinese forum with links to generals quotes saying its good/very good/much good etc.
Otherwise the whole discussion above becomes pointless….with members hollering the jf 17 has datalinks, a radar, and sd 10 so it must be better than the mirage…..where we know all the facts.
Even if we post facts to the mirage, it’ll always end with who knows the capabilities of the JF 17. Its got datalinks, ECM and now DSI as well….looks like they are trying to model after the JSF…..aaaaahhhhhhhh JSF!…..hence the plane itself now has more street cred and more points.
New Delhi, Nov. 7 (PTI): The State-run Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd has signed an MoU with Rolls Royce, a leading global provider of power systems and services, to collaborate on engine component design and manufacturing in India.
The MoU, which would allow a broader partnership between the two companies, could potentially include a variety of work in India relating to design, manufacture and assembly of components for Rolls Royce engines across various aerospace segments, an HAL release said here.
The MoU was signed at a ceremony in Bangalore on Sunday.
HAL currently manufactures under license the Rolls’ Adour engine for the Jaguar deep penetration strike aircraft of the Indian Air Force. The Adour-871, to be manufactured by HAL, would also power the Hawk Advanced Jet Trainers for India whose deliveries are likely to start next year, it said.
Rolls Royce and US-based Bell Helicopter Textron are also partnering on a proposal to the Indian Army for its Shen Helicopter programme, for which it has offered the Bell-407 helicopter powered by Rolls Model 250 engines. The Shen programme involves the purchase of up to 197 helicopters and a significant number of engines to be manufactured by HAL.
The Rolls Royce, which has had a 70-year-relationship with India, has set up its new wholly-owned subsidiary in Bangalore for the growing volume of engineering work it is sub-contracting to India.
HAL has been a contributor of ring forgings to Rolls Royce for its Trent family of engines and is also involved in repair and overhaul of several Rolls engines like Avon, Dart, Gnome and Adour.
Posted by Harry, BR :
Mig 29 KUB rollout (from Vayu)

For those who haven’t seen it previews: (credits to Singha an Rocky for links)
Mirage 2000 in Les Chevaliers Du Ciel – It’s My Life
Some info from BR.
The TRDD-50MT engine could be used to power India’s development of a UCAV as posted above.
Russia to power India’s Lakshya
Russia to power India’s Lakshya
October 26, 2006 20:25 IST
Russia will supply rocket engines for India’s unmanned aerial vehicle Lakshya under a $100 million deal although transfer of technology under license could be withheld due to international ban on missile technologies, a media report said on Thursday.
Russian jet engine manufacturer NPO Saturn will supply 200 miniature engines to India for Lakshya UAVs in 2007, according to Kommersant.
“The engines for India with 500 kg thrust will be developed on the basis of TRDD-50MT engine, originally designed for Soviet cruise missiles. Its flight resource will be enhanced from the present 45 minutes to tens of hours,” Kommersant quoted deputy commercial director (exports) of NPO Saturn Igor Grigorie as saying.
According to commercial director of NPO Saturn Vasily Danilov, the first one-year contract with India was signed in April and the design and experiment work is already underway.
All aspects of transfer of license for production of TRDD-50MT are under study by FSVTS, which may not give its nod because of New Delhi’s plans to develop a cruise missile with the range of 600 km and capable of carrying 350 kg payload on the basis of Lakshya.
“Such missiles fall under the MTCR and Russia honours this regime. With licensed production India would uncontrollably put these engines on UAVs and cruise missiles,” an official of FSVTS told Kommersant.
The NPO Saturn officials underscored that at present the deal does not violate Russia’s international obligations under Missile Technology Control Regime as it does not involve transfer of technology.
However, in the next stage of the contract India wants licensed production of these engines in the country and the deal could have a rough time, the daily said.
“We do not rule out setting up licensed production and testing facilities in India,” Danilov was quoted as saying by the daily.
As long as India uses these engines for UAVs or drones, there is no problem in their export, Kommersant quoted sources in Federal Service for Military-technical cooperation, the arms export oversight body.
IAF high on spirit of competition
Sarsawa (Uttar Pradesh): The Indian Air Force has just concluded Operation Chakravyuh in Sarsawa, Uttar Pradesh, in which eight helicopter units of the Western Air Command pitted themselves against each other to check out their flying skills and combat worthiness.
From delicately carrying a big container full of water slung under a helicopter, to hovering at the same spot, the spirit of competition was in the air.
The helicopters competed for six days on various parameters including heliborne operations and dropping paratroopers among other specialised operations. The idea was to learn while having some fun.
“The idea behind this exercise is to get together, learn from each other, to help literal flow of ideas and sharing professional knowledge. When we pit ourselves among each other we know if we need to learn more and where we stand,” said Group Captain A S Butola, Station Commander at Sarsawa Air base.
Helicopters that participated in the operations included the small and agile Cheetah, the big Mi-17 transport choppers, the super fast attack helicopter Mi-35 and the indigenously developed Advanced Light Helicopter Dhruv.
It was for the first time that the various routine activities were made part of competitive sport.
“Operation Chakravyuh is a new idea we have started to encourage professionalism and competition against helicopter crew,” said Air marshal V K Verma, Director General (Inspection and Safety) of Indian Air Force.
Later, the helicopters and the pilots were to fly back to Hindon, Leh, Pathankot, Jammu, and Udhampur to begin preparations for the next year’s event.
The Air Force now intends to extend this novel exercise to other commands across the country.
Remember Harry quoting on the above between the Mig and Mirage :
A quick google of DACT between the two receives :
In air-to-air DACT, the Mirage-2000H is no match for the MiG-29A/B but the in consideration of multi-role capabilities, the trend is reversed. Ironically, HAL was close to the license production of either the MiG-29A or the Mirage-2000H/TH in the late 80s. Around two decades later, it will be producing a derivative of either one.
Why not upgrade then to the Mig 29SMT?
Looking at the Mirage squadrons and numbers, im seeing 49 acquired initially with 6 lost to crashes over its 20 year period, making it 43. An additional 10 were delivered in 2004 so overall the Mirage fleet stands at 53.
All are slated for the dash 5 upgrades and most now have refuelling capability as well, my confusion exist as to where the remaining 40 are coming from and who’d be willing to part with theirs…
We got Qatar on with 12 Mirage 2005, leaving a total of 28 to be acquired from France, AdA? Brazil has bought 12 as well.
28 planes and wiki lists france as having 315. What types and from which squadrons and possible year of manufacture would the AdAbe willing to part with?
With an addtional 40 the overall fleet IAF mirage strength would be 93.