Oh I’m not judging any pilot’s required control inputs here, it’s dangerous zoom climbs and showoff steep turns at low altitude.
Chances are if you were in your own aircraft then you probably didn’t see the other aircraft do what I’m describing anyway.
True, they are interchangeable to a degree. But drag also comes into play. Drag increases at the square of the speed, not proportionally.
If you are not flying at your ideal speed (climb, S&L, or descent) then you are wasting energy. If you shut off your engine at 10,000 ft, and descent at Vne, level out at 1 ft, then you will stop flying well before the guy who descends at say 70kts. Likewise you could not zoom back up to meet him. An extreme example perhaps, but it illustrates my point.
I’m not trying to argue anything here, just want to make some pilots think twice about doing something they are not trained for, which can result in them hurting somebody.
I would expect those that have died trying to emulate the airshow performers probably cannot have a say in this topic.
There’s a reason that zoom climbs aren’t taught to PPL holders, as are barrel rolls after takeoff, loops after rotate, and saying “#%*&#” just prior to digging a hole.
Sure. Staying at low level after rotate to build up the speed, is great if you need zoom potential and to reach a safe speed to avoid an unnecessary ejection. None of the aircraft involved yesterday had ejection seats.
However for the average GA pilot it limits the safe options in the event of an engine failure. Sure, you have lots of speed, and no height, so what are your options? As you asked “I would have thought the earlier you could gain some height the better”. Exactly.
It is more efficient to sustain the recommended climb speeds (best rate, best angle or other compromise). In the event of an engine problem you only need an average push forward to descend at your best glide speed. Then flare a bit as you gently descend into the trees.
If you zoom into a high angle climb, you are increasing your load factor, increasing your stall speed (due to G), getting into an Unusual Attitude, and quickly getting back to (or below) your S&L stall speed, with your nose still above the horizon. Not a comfy place for most pilots that I know.
Similar conditions exist for steep turns soon after takeoff. High G, approaching the increased stall speed, and lack of climb ability. How proficient are you in incipient spin recovery at low level?
Simply put, if you are not trained to do it, and it’s not standard, then it’s not worth risking lives for. Watching the experts do it ‘with ease’ twenty minutes earlier, does not magically give you new super powers. People die trying this.
There’s a comprehensive guide to the current state of the hard working RNZAF in the latest issue of Combat Aircraft.
Whilst it does not speculate on what should be bought in the future, it does outline the roles of the RNZAF and how they meet them.

Mine is in the mail. I hope you can use them.
Cheers, Mike.
Crikey Blokes! What’s garn on ere’ then hey?
I just pop away for a few weeks, and you guys are Orstrailya bashing.
He’ll be fine, just headed off on a walkabout.
When and where is it please?
Ahm not from round ere…….
Save enough for your first 20hrs, and do them over a very short period.
Then the poor frequency won’t matter so much.
Get as much of the theory over and done with beforehand as well.
Top quality photos !!
Great photos Alex – just keep promoting beautiful NZ.
I wish I knew you’d be at Wanaka, I would have caught up with you.
I’m not sure – but it looks to be the style of Jurgis Kairys, from Lithuania.
Luckily no photos were attached.
I bet this never happens with all-female pilot courses…
I’m planning on having a pole of the TD in the near future, and will be glad to post my experiences in the cockpit. Stay tuned !!
Very nice Tony, I only wish that I didn’t have to leave so early.
Looks like I missed some great displays…