dark light

ink

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 346 through 360 (of 1,597 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode VII #2464929
    ink
    Participant

    It’s by far not that easy, they need to develop a significant export potential first. They started with few J-7s and K-8s to less developed nations, okay, now they will need to prove their worth with more demanding clients. As long as their maximum export success is a dozen of Fantans for Sudan and JF-17 for Pakistan, then they still got a lot to catch up. J-10 might be a good aircraft but you need to find someone who will risk it and switch to Chinese aircraft (that includes not only the purchase, but also spares, support, weapons etc.). I wouldn’t bet on it happening very soon.

    If the Chinese manufacturers can cover any income they would make on the export market with domestic buyers they’re going to be alright. Frankly, it might even be better for them because it means they’ll be able to focus all their research and design potential on getting what they want without having to tailor anything to anybody else’s needs.

    Although, I will agree that getting a second opinion on any piece of kit is better than relying on feedback from your own (undoubtedly very conservative) military establishment. Still, I don’t think its 100% necessary.

    in reply to: Russia Air Force's Flanker Doubt #2465201
    ink
    Participant

    Scooter,

    Well, it would have to be a totally new project………..to be viable in the next 15-20 years. IMO

    I think you could be on to something! EADS, SAAB, BAe, Dassault etc. all have plenty of experience they could share when it comes to designing 4th and 5th gen aircraft. Maybe even the Russians could join in. Or maybe that’s going a bit too far. But even without the Russians there’s plenty there to work with. Only problem I can see is the JSF… And the French… And the Germans… On second thoughts – this whole idea is beginning to look like a big headache already.

    in reply to: Iran completes design phase of stealth aircraft #2466930
    ink
    Participant

    Secondly, buying things is often cheaper than making it yourself

    Except that it employs none of your people, develops no new skills or technologies and the money you spend simply crosses your border and vanishes, never to return. Sometimes, its better to make a crap thing yourself than to buy a decent thing from someone else. Depends what you’ll use the knowledge for later. For example, Yugoslavia could just as easily chosen to buy the Mirage 2000 (or similar) instead of producing a similar design itself… Nobody could know the country was about to collapse and the R&D knowledge gained would be of no use to anyone.

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode VII #2468683
    ink
    Participant

    wrightwing,

    Your links don’t work.

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode VII #2475461
    ink
    Participant

    I’m inclined to agree with the Commander here.

    in reply to: Iran completes design phase of stealth aircraft #2476945
    ink
    Participant

    Much more interesting, in my opinion, is the claim of having designed a BVR IR AAM.

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread Part II #2046819
    ink
    Participant

    News?

    MOSCOW, January 26 (RIA Novosti) – The guided missile cruiser Moskva, the flagship of Russia’s Black Sea Fleet, has conducted computer-simulated missile attack drills in the Mediterranean, the fleet’s spokesman said on Monday.

    The designated targets were a naval ship and coastal facilities. All tasks set for the exercise have been accomplished,” the spokesman said.

    Moskva is a Slava-class missile cruiser designed as a surface strike ship with some anti-air and ASW capability.

    The sixteen SS-N-12 Sandbox nuclear-capable supersonic anti-ship missiles are mounted in four pairs on either side of the superstructure, giving the ship a distinctive appearance.

    The cruiser is on its way for an unofficial visit to the port of Messina in Sicily on January 27-30. The visit is timed to coincide with the 100th anniversary of the Messina earthquake and Russia’s participation in international relief efforts.

    In addition to the Russian vessel, U.S., British, German, Spanish and Danish warships will take part in events to mark the anniversary.

    The Messina earthquake had an estimated magnitude 7.5 on the Richter scale and was followed by a tsunami that struck many coastal cities with 40-foot (12-meter) waves, causing more destruction. The earthquake and tsunami killed two-thirds of the city’s then-150,000 population.

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread Part II #2047618
    ink
    Participant

    Yea, I spotted that too but I don’t understand why that mission is urgent enough to cut the repair work short. Only thing I could come up with is that the Vinogradov is going to need replacing early for some reason.

    EDIT: But even if that is the case, why all the ‘hype’ about a “mission of state importance”?

    in reply to: Russian Navy News & Discussion Thread Part II #2047625
    ink
    Participant

    KALININGRAD, January 21 (RIA Novosti) – Russian missile destroyer Admiral Chabanenko left a naval shipyard in the country’s Kaliningrad exclave on an urgent mission after having hurried repair work carried out, a shipyard spokesman said on Wednesday.

    Admiral Chabanenko urgently left the Baltiisk naval base on January 20 after receiving orders for a mission of state importance,” Sergei Mikhailov said.

    According to a Russian Navy source, the warship will join the Admiral Vinogradov missile destroyer from Russia’s Pacific Fleet, which is currently on an anti-piracy mission in the Gulf of Aden.

    Chabanenko docked for repairs at the Yantar shipyard on January 15 after its recent Latin American tour-of-duty. The original repair schedule, including the overhaul of the propulsion system, envisioned the work being finished by the end of February.

    The Northern Fleet destroyer accompanied the Pyotr Veliky nuclear-powered missile cruiser on a tour of the Atlantic and the Caribbean, participating in joint naval exercises with the Venezuelan navy, passing through the Panama Canal, and visiting a number of Latin American countries, including Cuba.

    The Admiral Chabanenko, an Udaloy II class missile destroyer, entered service with the Russian Navy in January 1999. It is Russia’s only multipurpose destroyer and is intended to be the counterpart to U.S. Arleigh Burke class ships.

    Designed primarily as an anti-submarine warfare platform, with a long cruising range and underway replenishment capabilities, Udaloy class ships provide support to surface task forces.

    The Udaloy II is modified by the replacement of the SS-N-14 Silex anti-submarine missiles by the SS-N-22 Sunburn anti-ship missiles, reflecting a change in emphasis from anti-submarine warfare to surface combat.

    What’s so urgent?

    in reply to: The PAK-FA Saga Episode VII #2484610
    ink
    Participant

    Note in how he has cleverly used the “should begin” caveat instead of simple saying “will begin”. Don’t get your hopes up to much guys, he’s obviously felt the need to cover his back for a reason.

    All the reports about Ivanov’s comments have been translated by online translation software – note the number of lexical and grammatical mistakes – so it cannot so easily be ascertained whether he said “should” or “will”.

    And in any case, even if the first flight is delayed to 2010 it would not be the first time a development programme of this kind suffers delays. I really don’t know why everybody is so hung up on whether this programme runs on schedule. What really matters is that it is clearly a much more serious attempt at producing a truly next generation combat aircraft than we have seen from Russia/the SU in a long long time.

    Also encouraging is the modernisation of testing facilities to adapt them to tests of a 5th gen aircraft.

    in reply to: MiG-23 useless ? #2492019
    ink
    Participant

    Good comments flex.

    in reply to: A new RuAF news thread #2493336
    ink
    Participant

    MOSCOW, January 15 (RIA Novosti) – The state will earmark 4 trillion rubles ($125 billion) for arms procurements by 2011, including 1 trillion rubles ($31 billion) in 2009, the Russian prime minister said on Thursday.

    Vladimir Putin said the modernization of defense related enterprises would continue despite the global financial crisis.

    “The modernization of defense industry enterprises as well as the development of modern weapons should continue,” he said.

    He added that federal defense programs need to be reviewed and “streamlined,” in particular with regard to production volumes.

    Russian Finance Minister Alexei Kudrin said earlier on Thursday the state had earmarked $10 billion for ‘core enterprises’ and defense-related sectors of industry

    What does “streamlining production volumes” mean anyway?

    in reply to: A new RuAF news thread #2495615
    ink
    Participant

    MOSCOW, January 13 (RIA Novosti) – Russia has received export orders for the delivery of Ka-52 Hokum-B combat helicopters from three countries, the manufacturer said on Tuesday. (Ka-52 Alligator helicopter production launched – Image Galleries)

    The Ka-52 is a twin-seat derivative of the Ka-50 Hokum-A attack helicopter, and is designed primarily for reconnaissance and target designation purposes. It is similar to the U.S. AH-64 Apache attack helicopter.

    “We have received orders for these helicopters from three countries,” said Yury Denisenko, general director of the Progress aircraft manufacturing company.

    We are studying these orders and will provide the names of the countries that ordered the aircraft if the contracts are signed,” he added.

    Denisenko also said that the Russian Defense Ministry would remain the key customer for Ka-52 helicopters, although he refused to disclose the number of aircraft ordered by the military, citing confidentiality.

    The Russian government approved the production of Ka-52 attack helicopters at the Arsenyevsk plant in Russia’s Far East in December last year.

    According to Russia’s Air Force chief, Col. Gen. Alexander Zelin, deliveries of the first 12 Ka-52 Hokum-Bs to the Russian Air Force will start in 2009.

    Feel free to speculate about which countries are involved…

    in reply to: Croatian Air Force #2495636
    ink
    Participant

    Again, awesome pics! Thanks!

    in reply to: The PAK-DA Saga Episode I: The beginning. #2447876
    ink
    Participant

    What I would like to see is a moderately stealthy bomber built around two AL-31 size engines, with internal weapons bay, and delta wings. That’d be somethin’. Tu-160s – too expensive, too big, will lead to another economic collapse. Lets call it the PAK-DA MKII

    Hmm… Not sure you’re gonna get what you’re after.

    Personally, I expect to see something in the Tu-22M class. In other words, bigger and more powerful than the Su-34 but smaller and stealthier than a Tu-160. Also, moderately stealthy is not good enough frankly. I’ve explained why in the previous thread on this topic.

Viewing 15 posts - 346 through 360 (of 1,597 total)