dark light

comoford

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 94 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Sea operations off Libya… #2007492
    comoford
    Participant

    What is the the military or the political reason push to send the U.S. Navy aircraft carrier Enterprise to the Red Sea rather than its presence within the units of the Sixth Fleet in the Mediterranean.?!

    Lots of trouble stirring in Yemen.

    Plenty of US airfields and aircraft in Europe and the US also appears to want Europeans to have a bigger role.

    – Italian carrier Garibaldi is on Libyan ops.

    in reply to: Air Action Over Libya (Merged) #2367701
    comoford
    Participant

    Reasons for not deploying F-22s

    – threat not high enough
    – lack of data link
    – insufficient air-to-ground eg. only 2 x 1000lb JDAMs, SDBs not ready
    – unable to develop synthetic aperture radar maps

    http://www.airforcetimes.com/news/2011/03/defense-f22-raptor-absent-from-libya-ops-032211/


    Under the Air Force’s global strike task force doctrine, the Raptor would normally escort B-2 Spirit stealth bombers in “kicking down the door” of an enemy’s air defenses.

    in reply to: Air Action Over Libya (Merged) #2368020
    comoford
    Participant

    BBC showed pro gaddafi civilians camping on the grounds of the destroyed gaddafi compound.There were women with kids.I wonder if that was spontaneous or “influenced” by gaddafi’s security agencies.Hitting such could be diasastrous negative publicity for the coalition.

    That compound surely contains something vital , requiring human shield protection.

    He lives on a military base. Its a pretty big compound.

    in reply to: The Great ModMil Libya Thread (Merged) #2330528
    comoford
    Participant

    Can’t establish a NFZ without a prolonged engagement with ground targets. Most of the Iraqi SAM network was wiped out during the Gulf War. Libya has a similar population to Serbia but physically is many times larger (600nm end-to-end).

    “My military opinion is that it would be challenging,” General James Mattis, commander of U.S. Central Command, told a Senate hearing. “You would have to remove air defense capabilty in order to establish a no-fly zone, so no illusions here. It would be a military operations — it wouldn’t be just telling people not to fly airplanes.”

    How many aircraft do you suppose the RAF has to spare?

    in reply to: The Great ModMil Libya Thread (Merged) #2331619
    comoford
    Participant

    PLAAF has 4 IL-76 operating in & out Libya

    http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2011/03/02/PH2011030200930.jpg

    In this photo released by China’s Xinhua News Agency, Xinhua, a local worker walks by a taxiing China Air Force’s IL-76 transport aircraft arriving in Khartoum, Sudan, Tuesday, March 1, 2011. China’s Defense Ministry said Monday it had sent four military transport planes to bring home Chinese citizens trapped in strife-torn Libya. The website of the official newspaper People’s Daily said the mission marked the first time China’s air force has been mobilized to rescue citizens overseas. (AP Photo/Xinhua, Mohmmed Babiker) NO SALES (Mohmmed Babiker – AP)

    http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2011/03/02/AR2011030200928.html

    From the article:

    ….

    About 32,000 Chinese – most working on construction projects or providing oil field services – had been whisked out of Libya as of Wednesday, with another 3,000 waiting to be airlifted out of the desert in the country’s deep south, according to China’s Foreign Ministry.

    Thats some pretty good evacuating.

    in reply to: Chance for Typhoons first combat deployment? #2331625
    comoford
    Participant

    Just to give some idea of the distances involved (because I had to look them up too); distances to Tripoli from:

    Akrotiri – 1835km

    Gibraltar – 1738km (overflying Tunisian and Algerian airspace)

    Decimomannu – 817km

    I’ll let you guys do the conversion to nautical miles. 🙂

    Google Maps Distance Calculator: km, miles and nm
    http://www.daftlogic.com/projects-google-maps-distance-calculator.htm

    in reply to: Military Aviation News From Around The World – VII #2333213
    comoford
    Participant

    Australia; RAAF considering a 5th C-17 Globemaster

    RNZAF to get some air time. Aus-NZ cargo plane ~ amphib lift swap.
    http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/5th-c17-globemaster-being-considered-20110228-1bbn4.html

    New Zealand might get some use from this aircraft.

    Mr Smith said he and New Zealand defence Minister Wayne Mapp agreed last month on enhanced cooperation, coordination and sharing in airlift.

    “An acquisition of an additional C-17 would almost certainly obviate any need for the acquisition of two additional C-130 aircraft, currently planned for after 2013-14.”

    in reply to: Options for MPA #2011847
    comoford
    Participant

    8-12 / RAAF – they might buy the P-8 but they might be interested in the A319 – they bought airbus refuelers, so lets see.

    The RAAF already operates 737s for VIP transport and AEW. They also want interoperability with the USN in the Pacific. P-8 (+UAVs) is more likely.

    My pick for UK MPA – the MQ-9 ‘Mariner’. Maritime patrol version of the Reaper (already in UK service),. Operate it with C-130s, it’d be perfect as an interim measure. It’ll get things done till a P-8 FMS buy becomes possible.

    49 hour endrance
    http://media.defenseindustrydaily.com/images/AIR_UAV_Mariner_Over_Water_lg.jpg

    in reply to: What Aircraft Does Canada Really Want? #2358802
    comoford
    Participant

    So it seems that if the Liberal Leader had his way, he’d scrap the F-35 and open up the process to multiple bidders.

    By “multiple bidders”, he means Super Hornet.

    Perceived to be a simpler purchase (ask the RAAF) and combat proven.

    in reply to: Ark Royal for Sale??? #2018099
    comoford
    Participant

    Training for crews for the Canberra class can be done better on someone elses ships. What about putting a detachment aboard Juan Carlos 1? They can learn about the machinery & dock while they’re at it. Or aboard a US LHD.

    The ADF trains with USN LHDs quite regularly.

    in reply to: MRA4 dying a slow death? #2385538
    comoford
    Participant

    IMHO. Its not a flawed aircraft. Its a bespoke aircraft. Only 9 aircraft planned and it is a new build aircraft resulting in high operating costs and a low number of aircraft for the R&D spent.

    Very little opportunity for export. Burden on the UK when it comes to integration and upgrades. Too many unknowns. Cardinal rule in business; never chase sunk costs.

    in reply to: A-10C to the USMC #2389390
    comoford
    Participant

    The USMC are introducing gunship kits for their KC-130s.

    http://forum.keypublishing.com/showthread.php?t=89633

    in reply to: "Blair force one" ?? #2410716
    comoford
    Participant

    This is what Gordon Brown once used on a trip to DC in 2008.

    http://i127.photobucket.com/albums/p138/doutorfred/Titan%20Airways%2016nov06/800GZAPX01.jpg

    in reply to: F-35 news thread II #2419199
    comoford
    Participant

    Some pricing from down under. FMS purchase: $60m fly away, $140m with accessories. Cheaper than recent Super Hornets.

    http://www.heraldsun.com.au/news/national/stealth-fighters-cheap-at-140m/story-e6frf7l6-1225909569574

    AUSTRALIA will pay a “fly away” price of less than $60 million each for up to 100 of the world’s most advanced stealth fighter jets.

    But the total will be more than double that for a package that includes weapons, sensors, training and lifetime support for the F35 Joint Strike Fighter.

    At $140 million, the single-seat jets will be cheaper than the 24 two-seat Super Hornets bought by the Howard government for $6.6 billion or more than $220 million each.

    ….

    Australia is buying up to 100 jets from the US Air Force under a so-called foreign military sales deal.

    For the first time the aircraft maker, Lockheed Martin, has provided a “firm” price to Australian taxpayers in 2010 dollars.

    ….

    “Your average cost of buying your fleet of aeroplanes will be at that number ($60m) or maybe slightly below it,” Mr Burbage said.

    ….

    Mr Burbage also revealed that the hourly flying cost of the JSF would be about 20 per cent below the RAAF’s fleet of F/A-18 Hornet fighters.

    in reply to: LGB vs Aircraft Carrier #2028792
    comoford
    Participant

    Cargo ship vs. 2 x 2000lb: LGB http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AQeWD6hm6Ak

    Compared the usual anti-ship missiles, a 2000lb Paveway has higher kinetic energy and a bigger bang.

Viewing 15 posts - 61 through 75 (of 94 total)