Back on topic, Eurofighter news :diablo:
http://www.theregister.co.uk/2011/06/08/eurofighter_beaten_by_f16/page2.html
It’s a hoax, because it’s not in defencenet.gr. 😀 (if it was about Rafale or F35 now defencenet would have put it with colossal letters “F16 beat the pride of France” or “F35, a flying saucepan, now confirmed”!. Ahahaha.
Impossible as we all know as only the Rafale is a stealthy upper super plane with Spectra cloaking device (why does it need it anyway?).
:D:D You are mean! 😀
But if some day some linguist discovers a relation between clingonese and french, then you will have some apologizing to do and Dassault should upgrade her databank’s security. 😀
P.S.: No offense to the dear french members, i just couldn’t resist the “Spectra cloaking device”. 😀
Not true.
There are Christian Arab minorities in Egypt (several million – & a majority in some parts of the country), Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Jordan & among the Palestinians.
There are Druze (Arabs with an obscure religion) in Israel, Lebanon & Syria.
The government of Syria is dominated by Alawite (a sect which some class as Shia, some as a separate branch of Islam) Arabs.
Iraq & Bahrain have Shia Arab majorities, & there are Shia Arab minorities in Lebanon, Iran, Saudi Arabia, & other states.
This is not necessarily a complete list.
Correct, but none have enough influence to do something to influence an operation against Iran. Syria even if wanted (that doesn’t) has her own trouble. Bahrain will side with the rest of Emirates. In Egypt the Christians have no power whatsover, as a matter of fact about a month ago the higher religious authority of the Egyptian Copt Christians in Greece, was telling to the TV that the Christians in Egypt are afraid and that have been victims of progroms by muslims after the fall of Mubarak.
I’m sorry but I don’t see the logics. Sacrificing range to get one more air to air missile sounds silly in my opinion, and I don’t think no pilot in their right mind will look for a confrontation with enemy fighters if they have a strike mission to carry.
It would be much wiser to use the extra range to avoid the enemy fighters altogether, and either try to go undetected, or have a fighter sweep take care of the enemy fighters.
Seriously I really don’t understand your logics.
Nic
I agree more with your logic. You lose in flexibility. You have to go for either no fuel tanks or for 2 fuel tanks, that may be “overkill” and you lose 2 hardpoints for ammunition.
I thought it was clear that I was joking when I said Typhoon > Rafale
It’s weekend and it’s hot, i become “slower”. :p
He is obviously very skilled and self-confident, but one thing is to take a risk for himself and another is putting innocent bystanders into peril.
Anyway, this must be the lowest flying i have seen.
Well a Mirage 2000-9 managed to get a gunkill against a F22, which the Rafale didn’t. So Mirage 2000 > Rafale, so if the Typhoon = Mirage 2000, then Typhoon > Rafale.
Nic
The thing is, dogfight is very heavily influenced by individual pilot skill. We ‘ve had too cases of T-33 outmanouvering F16 (!), Mirage F1 gunkilling F16, but objectively, it was about a better pilot exploiting the weak spots of the opponent, not about having a better aircraft.
Ever heard about requirements? So if the Typhoon has crappy aerodynamics while being a souped up M2k, we must conclude that the Mirage had crappy aerodynamics as well and that it took Dassault some 3 decades from Mirage 3 to Rafale to get it finally right.:rolleyes::diablo:
Good point… And the Typhoon isn’t crappy in aerodynamics. The 1 of the 2 greek F16s pilots that dogfighted a Typhoon for the first time (I think it was in a german exercize), according to a defencenet’s article, said that the flight performance of the Typhoon reminded him when he was in A7s dogfighting F16s and that they had to use all their skill to counter it. And he must have seen Mirages in his service, so if anything, it must be a “very” souped up M2k. 😀 I simply think that Rafale and Typhoon can both kill each other and so this evolves in a neverending fight where both sides will make claims of superiority. Honestly, i think that up until Rafale gets more powerful engines, the Typhoon, if left to a free scenario, can have an advantage for the sole reason that it is optimized to fly high and fast and has no reason to go lower just to make Rafale happier. In lower altitudes the Rafale may be better today, but it’s probably also a question of pilot. This is why you get contradictory reports or exercize claims all the time.
Up high the Typhoon can be beat be many aircraft and down low it can be beat by even more aircraft. It is probably the worst fighter currently in production. Waste of money.
I don’t think it’s a waste of money, but i think it requires a lot of money that few can afford… That and the fact that at the end, while started with more momentum for upgrades, it fell into the trap of “two cooks spoil the broth” (where the cooks here are actually more, the EADS members), while the Rafale, although without exports, follows a more reasonable upgrade path.
P.S.: I can’t stand the targeting pod in the center hardpoint of the Typhoon instead of a fuel tank. It shouts “I wasn’t thought to bomb, someone forced me to along the way”.
Smart air force would never reveal their best hand. The Indians easily beat the U.S. in COPE India 2004, but at the same time they reveal their clever tactics and combat radar emission characteristics. They realized they made a mistake in doing so, and in following exercises they set their Su radars/avionics to “Training Mode”, and use very basic tactics. It’s better to “lose” then reveal your military secrets.
Yes, believe me, we have things too that we don’t show because of the neighbour. If you notice, even our habitual trainning partner where large greek formations partecipate (and where you can apply more elaborated tactics), is french airforce, because it is the less likely to go tell the Turks.
1) In BVR a F4PI2020 is defenceless against Su-27. There isn’t much to hide for the Chinese there. They have to just call the shot. Besides, how many where the Sus sent to Turkey? Something like 4 doesn’t allow for “supertactics” anyway, so it’s not like the Chinese will reveal their “total air war” tactics to the Turks.
2) In WVR, pilots can’t hide their skill easily, because it’s second nature and pilot’s ego. And i doubt the chinese have some reason to hide what the Su-27 can do in dogfight, it’s not like USA doesn’t know about it and waits for the Turks to spy for them and tell them. Ok, let’s say they have a couple of “secret dogfight manouvers” that want to hide from the Turks, do they really need them to avoid a crushing defeat from F4s???
What one hides are jamming capability, large formation tactics and operational war tactics and plans that involve the entire airforce. When you send 4 aircrafts to an exercize it’s more about how quickly you can adopt and counter the enemy tactic in BVR and how good you are in dogfight once you go to WVR than to hide something “secret”. At least this is what i think.
Besides, if you are to send to a foreign country Su-27s (not the latest secret around) with orders to lose to F4Es in dogfight, what’s the point to send them in the first place??? Do what? See the turkish landscape and how the Turks paint their F4s? If the send planes abroads with the attitude “go to get beat by F4s”, what will be the attitude against F16s? “Go there and raise white flag?”
Thank you Alepou, my memory of the event was weak. So he was picked up first by the “Century” oil tanker, greek rescuers board the ship, he pulls the gun in order to avoid being rescued by the greek team.
It would be interesting to see if they can salvage the fighter..a Mirage is after all a costly asset..I remember seeing an Indian Navy Sea Harrier being salvaged in rather good condition from the sea since it had lost power while in the hover. But I don’t recall reading that it was ever put back into service.
Personally i am not very optimistic because of the costs. Greek politicians aren’t fond of the armed forces anyway, so for them, one aircraft more one less, doesn’t matter much. HAI has put back in service a HAF Mirage that “crash landed” on sea some years ago, but it was in shallow waters and in very good shape. Here it is in deeper water and was abbandoned at 2000ft, plus, they ‘ve put HAI on the list for sale. I doubt they will want to spend money on that aircraft… We ‘ll see…
So is that an attrition rate of 1.36 accidents per 10,000 hours of flying? That is interesting, because its higher than that of the Indian Air Force and on par with that of the PAF..see this link that mentions the attrition rates of these 2 air forces
I don’t know. It literally says “indicator of air accidents”. One thing i know for sure, is that the fact the accident rate has declined is something “natural”. From 1991 to this day, HAF got many more new aircrafts. In 1991, we had less and less modern aircrafts, with the results of putting much strain to them, in order to intercept turkish aircrafts. So it’s not like HAF suddenly magically reduced accidents for a mysterious reason. Simply, in the 90s we had limited number of interceptors, that had to go to intercept again and again as well as perform their “normal” trainning schedules,disturbing their own regular maintenance program, while now HAF has the luxury to keep some in readiness for interceptions, have others do their regular (not involving turkish) trainning program and others to pass through regular maintenance.
That’s why they say “lies, damn lies and statistics” and why i will wait and see the trend this year before i take the words of that paper like gold.
Tsk tsk, your a to devoted patriot Mr. Aspis. That sh*t was and is uneatable. You know it and I know it.
A juicy Sovlaki on the other hand -straight from the grill- flushed down with a coupple of ice cold bright Hellas lagers.. Now that something to be proud about! Yummy…
It’s delicious! Simply there are too many eggplants on the same dish for a scandinavian to bare! 😀 We are trainned since childhood to eat our eggplants.
Suvlaki is an expertese. You can try make it at home, but it won’t be as good as the greek one. After all, WE are a PIG. Ahahaha! Only if you are of Irish descent you have a chance of making good suvlaki i guess, but even then, you lack the suvlaki tradition. 😀
wait..so the Greeks picked him up first.. he pointed a gun at them.. so they put him back in the Ocean only to be picked up by Scandinavians? interesting.
More or less. Alepou may remember the details better. As far as i remember we didn’t “put him back in the sea”, because he refused to be touched by the greek crewman in the first place. He stayed in the water until the Scandinavians came.
He was probably feeling strong enough to wait…
why did he point the gun? did he want the Greeks to leave him back in the ocean?
He wanted to be saved by Turks. It’s a) better for the turkish SAR position, b) his career evolution would be over, once he ‘d become a “star of greek tv”, as greek journalists are fast and persistent like hyenas when they smell a story and in islands’ civillian hospitals there’s no way to avoid contact with them.
At the end he was picked up by a neutral ship (i think norvegian or some other scandinavian), so he was happy enough. Fortunately the Aegean isn’t “ocean”, but archipelago, so sooner or later many will come to the rescue… So he wanted to wait.
not at all.
so if the US or NATO/Europe attacked Iran
what Arab country would support them (i.e. Qatar, Bahrain, UAE, SA, etc).what does Iranians not being Arab have to do with it? Some Arab speaking countries are pro Iran, others are not.
All Arabs are sunni muslims. Iranians are shia muslims (like a fly in the milk). Iran has disputes with UAE about some tiny islands in the Persian Gulf, so one should not expect sympathy from there. Saudis also don’t like the Iranian will to be the controller in the straits. The only “glue” could be the presence of USA – the devil- that could unite the population in the streets, but i don’t think the arab goverments would do anything substantial to help Iran.
how are Greece relations with Libya? I know Libya and Bulgaria had some bad relations.. does this mean Greece is good with Qadaffi?
I don’t think we have a policy about Libya. Our goverment is shaking, our PM is sweating trying to fight against his own flesh (the unions, the interests that supported him, the mentality his party cultivated for 30 years), he is not likely to see the end of the year as PM, i am sure if you ask him “what’s your policy for Gadaffi” he will answer “I don’t know, there are others working on that, a guy called Nicolas i think”.
Greece used to have good relations in the 80s with Gadaffi (Papandreou Senior), some greek businessmen import (or used to import before the bombings) oil from Libya, but we had problems about the limits of continental shelf. So, yes, i ‘d say we don’t have a policy right now.
OK, we have the F16s B30 that HAF has decided that won’t be upgraded and if we search all hangars we may come up with some Mirage F1s. Also in HAF’s museum there are a couple of F104s. Oh and the RF4Es that are supposed to be retired this year, but we could arrange for a “hot transfer” to Libya… We need the money, we can beat any other offer. 😀
According to this article:
http://www.defence-point.gr/news/?p=12362
The “mobile team for maintenance of underwater and sea structures” which belongs to the 206th Wing of Airforce Infrastructure, has located the crashed Mirage2000, at 1,5 nm SW of Samos, at depth of 50m. First indications show that the aircraft is in relatively good conditions (it didn’t fall apart on impact). There will be evaluation about whether it’s worth the effort to bring it on surface and attempt to bring it back to flying conditions like the other Mirage.
————————————————————–
HAF’s Air Command also gave a “non paper” about the accidents and the accusations from websites:
“The accident rate of HAF in the past decade is steadily declining and the average of the last 3 years (1.36) is the best of the period 1991-2011. The accident rate is one of the lowest amongst the most advanced airforces of the world. Specifically, amongst 14 airforces, HAF, while having high density of activities, is at 8th place with index 2.9, with the first ranking airforce having 1.0 and the last 5.8.
Comparing to 2010, in the totality of air accidents of all kinds, this years presents accident reduction by 30%. There is full coverage from spare parts and maintenance”.
http://www.defence-point.gr/news/?p=12419
Yes, well, let us hope so, because if they continue like in this month, their statistics will soon take a very bad turn…
———————————————————
Contrary to previous statement (typical of the greek gov), HAI was put on the list of state enterprises for privatization. Dennis Plessas (LM), come and get it…
Samos… Its been a long time since I heard that name. It was my first “out of Scandinavia” vaccation as a little kid. And the last summer we spent together before our parents divorced. Gosh, time flies… I still remember playing on the rather stony/gravel-ish beach and eating that horrible Moussaka. And watching the old men playing Backgamon under the olive trees and drinking Ouzo in the evnings.. Beautiful sunsets. Beautiful island. Not totally destroyed by tourism back then (mid 80:s). Only local kids to play with. I also remember my ethusiasm and euforia of all the army vehicles you could see here and there in the countryside. The proximity to Turkey I guess…
Good to hear the Mirage guys made it out ok.
Ahaha! I like Mussaka, but not the creamy top of it (i remove it). But it depends on the restaurant. You can find some awful food specially in touristic locations. The problem with the islands is that… they want to be destroyed by tourism… Traditional jobs like fisherman, shepard, agriculture, aren’t as profitable as they used to be, because a) population decreased locally, with the younger going to mainland for studying-working and b) the “globalization” made their products become less attractive. Now we import lemons from Argentina, potatoes from Egypt, fish from Turkey, etc. There are still though some islands not so crowded by tourists or at least by teenagers, but they are the smaller ones and with less comforts.
The army vehicles are still there alright. The bigger eastern islands (Samos, Kos, Limnos, Chios, Rhodes, Lesbos) are the ones that are more seriously defended. The lesser ones have a more or less small garisson/detachment that rotates from the bigger islands. Limnos has the added bonus of having a military airfield too with F16s stationed.
Yes, the proximity with Turkey and according to Defencenet, the Mirage2000 was trainning in virtual shots with Exocet against some turkish surface vessels. 😀
Four Things:
1. Thank goodness the pilots are alive!
In deed.
2. Thank goodness there were no one else around when it crashed
Yes, fortunately it was over sea and i think i read they were at low level at the time.
3. Thank goodness the pilots were picked up by fishermen, not Turkish navy
Actually turns out that they were picked up by a speed boat of an Army Lt. Colonel that was trainning his SF team nearby. Defencenet in its rush to beat the others in details about the news, “invented” the fishermen (they probably learnt about a boat and logically thought “fishermen”). :rolleyes:
But it’s ok, in the past a dead pilot was found by a turkish ship, nothing bad happened. It’s not that they would put them in jail. The issue is more political in that Turkey wants the SAR area up to the center of the Aegean. So if you actually perform SAR up to the middle of the Aegean, de facto you enforce your position.
4. Thank goodness it was an older Mirage, not the upgraded one
Yes, considering how much the French charge to upgrade another 2000 to -5 again… 😀