dark light

Dave Homewood

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,131 through 2,145 (of 4,847 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: The most accurately portrayed Hollywood history films #1938135
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    PS Where in NZ do you live, have you always lived there and are you crying out for architects because the UK is beggining to get up my nose but due to political corectness can’t say why.

    I live in Cambridge, the exactcentre of the North Island, and currently a hugely desirable place for UK immigrants. We are a Pommie Enclave almost. Every one of them seems to have the same story – we came here because NZ is what the UK used to be like, and we’re sick of what it’s like now. Sadly I fear the influx of foreigners will soon make NZ like the UK now, and we’ll lose ‘our’ culture and heritage and lifestyle. It is already fast disappearing thanks to globalisation. But, in the meantime, architects rom the UK are probably very desirable here – there’s a massive housing boom to house all the foreigners coming here. Cambridge has jumped from a population of 10,000 people about five years ag to 15,000, and currently new subdivisions of over 1000 homes are underway. It really irks me. Everyone wants to come to Cambridge for it’s quaint old English charm with it’s village square and old oak trees, etc. But in doing so they’re turning us into a city like they wanted to get away from. Those of us who’ve lived here all our lives see the place rapidly evolving suddenly. Sad. But, at least it’s mostly Poms coming because they enjoy our beer culture.

    in reply to: General Discussion #363526
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Though a fantastic documentary, The Memphis Belle (1944) is not a strictly accurate account of one flight on one day as it portrays. It was filmed on many ocasions on several planes and half of it in the USA. It is a great representationin the end though, despite its faults.

    The problem with when they set out to make it entertaining yet based on fact, they often still put across the premise that it happened that way, so the gullible think it’s true.

    Take U-571, I watched and thought it was a fantastic piece of intelligent entertainment that drew on real stories for inspiration. I was quite shocked to later hear many people thought that it was a true story, and others thought it was Hollywood trying to say it was a true story. To me it was no more true than like a film based on an Alastair Maclean book or whatever. Others took it as fact that the US got the Enigma first. It’s in the perception. I still like the film.

    On the other hand when they take a true story, bend it all out of proportion and then continue to say its the true story (like Pearl Harbor, The Patriot, Windtalkers, etc) tht’s just wrong. You don’t see this happening much at all outside of Hollywood, which is why people around the world get up in arms because non-Americans perhaps trust the accuracy of of own historical films more and thus expect that we should be able to trust Hollywood’s, if you see what I mean.

    One of the greatest films made in my opinion, and though based on fact no-one can argue its accuracy as it’s not known, is JFK. I love that film. Great cast, great writing, great acting. That and Thirteen Days are he only Costner films I’ve seen that are worth watching.

    in reply to: The most accurately portrayed Hollywood history films #1938250
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Though a fantastic documentary, The Memphis Belle (1944) is not a strictly accurate account of one flight on one day as it portrays. It was filmed on many ocasions on several planes and half of it in the USA. It is a great representationin the end though, despite its faults.

    The problem with when they set out to make it entertaining yet based on fact, they often still put across the premise that it happened that way, so the gullible think it’s true.

    Take U-571, I watched and thought it was a fantastic piece of intelligent entertainment that drew on real stories for inspiration. I was quite shocked to later hear many people thought that it was a true story, and others thought it was Hollywood trying to say it was a true story. To me it was no more true than like a film based on an Alastair Maclean book or whatever. Others took it as fact that the US got the Enigma first. It’s in the perception. I still like the film.

    On the other hand when they take a true story, bend it all out of proportion and then continue to say its the true story (like Pearl Harbor, The Patriot, Windtalkers, etc) tht’s just wrong. You don’t see this happening much at all outside of Hollywood, which is why people around the world get up in arms because non-Americans perhaps trust the accuracy of of own historical films more and thus expect that we should be able to trust Hollywood’s, if you see what I mean.

    One of the greatest films made in my opinion, and though based on fact no-one can argue its accuracy as it’s not known, is JFK. I love that film. Great cast, great writing, great acting. That and Thirteen Days are he only Costner films I’ve seen that are worth watching.

    in reply to: More of James and Johns Excellent Adventure!!! #1375859
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    No, you’ve seen two Dragons – remember Stan Smith has one at Dairy Flat too. I know what you mean though.

    I had seen RIAMA in photos before but yours really shows it off in that sunlight. Do you know the significnce of the name? Sounds Maori.

    in reply to: General Discussion #363541
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Cheers Pete.

    It’s been years since I saw The Longest Day, but I recal reading it’s very well made with onlky a few characters and scenes that were made up. I agree about adding Patton and The Thin Red Line to the list. The latter is a brilliant film. Most people have trouble with it becuase there’s not all shooting fights etc like most US war films. I think it’s a masterpiece of examining the psychological effects of war.

    What about Catch 22? Wasn’t that based on a true story? I’ve not seen it in years and don’t rememebr the story too well.

    in reply to: The most accurately portrayed Hollywood history films #1938259
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Cheers Pete.

    It’s been years since I saw The Longest Day, but I recal reading it’s very well made with onlky a few characters and scenes that were made up. I agree about adding Patton and The Thin Red Line to the list. The latter is a brilliant film. Most people have trouble with it becuase there’s not all shooting fights etc like most US war films. I think it’s a masterpiece of examining the psychological effects of war.

    What about Catch 22? Wasn’t that based on a true story? I’ve not seen it in years and don’t rememebr the story too well.

    in reply to: General Discussion #363576
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    James, with all that sea in your blood I now see where your love of flying boats comes from.

    As far as contientious objectors go, I wouldn’t choose that route myself but I agree it is a tough choice for some. For other people there’s no question of objecting, they had to because of their religious beliefs. Here in NZ all those who objected were put into the Home Guard and EPS (like the ARP) by law, so they may have ended up at the front line anyway if we’d been invaded.

    Some very fine people were objectors. NZ’s wartime Prime Minister in WWII, Peter Fraser, and half his cabinet, had all been imprisoned in WWI for objecting! Now that’s a scary thought. Anoter prominent CO was Sir Edmund Hillary. After a bit of objecting he came to his senses and joined the RNZAF where he found life much better, and they taught him mountain climbing!

    in reply to: WHAT DID YOU DO IN THE WAR DADDY? #1938280
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    James, with all that sea in your blood I now see where your love of flying boats comes from.

    As far as contientious objectors go, I wouldn’t choose that route myself but I agree it is a tough choice for some. For other people there’s no question of objecting, they had to because of their religious beliefs. Here in NZ all those who objected were put into the Home Guard and EPS (like the ARP) by law, so they may have ended up at the front line anyway if we’d been invaded.

    Some very fine people were objectors. NZ’s wartime Prime Minister in WWII, Peter Fraser, and half his cabinet, had all been imprisoned in WWI for objecting! Now that’s a scary thought. Anoter prominent CO was Sir Edmund Hillary. After a bit of objecting he came to his senses and joined the RNZAF where he found life much better, and they taught him mountain climbing!

    in reply to: General Discussion #363594
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Errrrghhh!!

    Here was a chance to try to actually get some constructive debate going on good accurate historic films made in Hollywood, after all the years of pointing out the bad ones. I mean, maybe some films would have come up worth watching, we may have learned something.

    But no.

    in reply to: The most accurately portrayed Hollywood history films #1938283
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Errrrghhh!!

    Here was a chance to try to actually get some constructive debate going on good accurate historic films made in Hollywood, after all the years of pointing out the bad ones. I mean, maybe some films would have come up worth watching, we may have learned something.

    But no.

    in reply to: General Discussion #363603
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    I never had the pleasure to meet Mark Hanna properly, no more than a hello on the flightline when he was at Wigram with the Avenger, but I did see him display aircraft here in NZ on a number of occasions. He was a terrific pilot, like his father.

    It is interesting how well known both became even to the NZ public due to their trips out here for shows. A lot of people have heard of the Hannas because they often took the time to do interviews for local media, etc, and they always came across as good genuine chaps with a sense of humour and a love for their work. People you wanted to know or support.

    It was as big a shock here as in the UK no doubt when we learned of the tragedy. I won’t forget the TV news report. Mark, and his Dad, are the tyes of celebrities we can all genuinely admire, and perhaps aspire to be like in life, not like the so-called celebs of today.

    RIP Mark – you gave a lot of joy to the world

    in reply to: Sorely Missed #1938292
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    I never had the pleasure to meet Mark Hanna properly, no more than a hello on the flightline when he was at Wigram with the Avenger, but I did see him display aircraft here in NZ on a number of occasions. He was a terrific pilot, like his father.

    It is interesting how well known both became even to the NZ public due to their trips out here for shows. A lot of people have heard of the Hannas because they often took the time to do interviews for local media, etc, and they always came across as good genuine chaps with a sense of humour and a love for their work. People you wanted to know or support.

    It was as big a shock here as in the UK no doubt when we learned of the tragedy. I won’t forget the TV news report. Mark, and his Dad, are the tyes of celebrities we can all genuinely admire, and perhaps aspire to be like in life, not like the so-called celebs of today.

    RIP Mark – you gave a lot of joy to the world

    in reply to: General Discussion #363607
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Hmm, on Amazon’s list of the 25 best historical films it lists among them:
    Braveheart
    The Patriot
    Windtalkers
    and
    Monty Python and the Holy Grail :confused:

    http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/listmania/list-browse/-/1QAVHZJPF6TX4/103-6684526-9941461

    I think this list may not be strictly historically accurate 😀

    in reply to: The most accurately portrayed Hollywood history films #1938295
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Hmm, on Amazon’s list of the 25 best historical films it lists among them:
    Braveheart
    The Patriot
    Windtalkers
    and
    Monty Python and the Holy Grail :confused:

    http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/tg/listmania/list-browse/-/1QAVHZJPF6TX4/103-6684526-9941461

    I think this list may not be strictly historically accurate 😀

    in reply to: General Discussion #363618
    Dave Homewood
    Participant

    Another I hear was very accurate in its portrayl:
    Tucker: The Man and his Dream

    Also, a lot of well made biographical films about ‘pop culture’ stars like:
    And the Beat Goes On: The Sonny and Cher Story
    Daydream Believer – The Monkees Story
    The Karen Carpenter Story (creepily accurate!)
    The Tina Turner Story

Viewing 15 posts - 2,131 through 2,145 (of 4,847 total)