On the contrary, you are really underestimating the RN’s amphibious capability. Remeber we retook the Falklands with far less capable ships. Also, I made no reference to either V-22s or LCACs, neither of which figure in the RN’s plans currently due to their cost. Without LCACs, the well deck can only be used whilst stationary, hence it is only a feature of second wave RN amphibs. First wave goes by air, Junglies currently (Sea King HC4/HAS6C).
The older US concept of the LHD is one even they are moving away from with the new America class. Yes using a CVF in the LPH role is less cost effective than a purpose built design, but it makes use of an asset that is then kept available for use in it’s primary role at short notice. A replacement for Ocean appears to be deferred at the moment (though the ship herself can be extended to cover the gap) so it makes sense to get more use out of the carriers, just as we do now with the CVSs. Carriers are not single role ships anyway, they are flexible air power projection platforms and always have been. I think it is possible that there may be a reciprocal arrangement in the middle of the next decade whereby France builds a couple of modified Mistrals (minus the well deck) for the RN, and in return we build PA2 (at least as far as the fitting out stage) for the MN. They have a ‘production line’ for Mistrals and we have a ‘production line’ for the CVFs (being set up as we speak). The current warship building plans for the RN aren’t based upon the maximum shipyard capacity, but the minimum sustainable capacity. Extra orders can be accomodated…
Obi Wan is right, if the Falklands hadn’t happened the UK would have virtually no amphibious assault capability now.
Instead the UK has an ability to conduct and support amphibious assaults second only to the USN now:
2 x Albion class
Hms Ocean
HMS Illustrious and HMS Ark Royal in secondary LPH role
4 x Bay Class (These are better and more numerous navies have globally let alone a reserve)
RFA Argus
RFA Diligence
Point class
Plus the Tankers and Fort class
The problem the RN has with the sea blind nature of recent governments is the cut down of the frigate and destroyer fleet tasked with protecting all this equipment plus the constant threat over the CVF program and the Harrier/F35 required to give air cover over any amphibious fleet.
Sign In
