dark light

stuart gowans

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 151 through 165 (of 1,986 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #782366
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    YUP you got my number just a couch potato; However the basic assumption is that it has been saved, well how much has been saved? I doubt very much that the Egyptians will show you all the bits they skipped in the process of salvation; when you have worked on a single piece of airframe for several months in order to conserve it, then you might understand.
    With regards to whether the spitfire was complete of otherwise it was more complete than anything returned to the air in a long time.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #782381
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    It’s easy now to say that the plan had two stages (especially as heads have rolled and some house cleaning done) but there could only have been one stage in reality, it would either be recovered to the care of the RAFM, or it wouldn’t.

    To claim partial success (a bridge too far springs to mind) is more typical of these modern times, much like the cr@p they teach the kids at school “there are no losers, you are all winners”

    moving the p40 from one place in a volatile environment to another was not a success, (as said previously) any deal struck should have been for it to be delivered to the UK, the other aspect to the arrangement is the payment, the loudest voices in favour of the “deal” are personal friends, of the recipient of the spitfire, I have heard a value as little as £100k attached to the spitfire; when was the last time a complete airframe came up for sale at anywhere near that price? payment should have been made in cash.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #784570
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Even in this country finding an RAF A/C on your land doesn’t convey right of ownership, SOC or not, so why would that be any different for another country?

    Personally I would have thought that pre hostilities (of a more recent time) the RAFM would have made arrangement with the Egyptian government before sanctioning a recovery, had they not as you suggest, then clearly more heads needed to roll, but we will probably never know.

    I don’t believe that the primary reason for the “restoration” of ww2 artifacts (or indeed those from any other era) should be the encouragement of tourism, and clearly they have no interest in the history of this particular A/C, other wise they might have placed a notice board nearby themselves; did they ask for help in the restoration process, again we will probably never know, personally I doubt it.

    Is it displayed in the correct place, well that is subjective, like many I believe it should have been conserved, and displayed as found, not just as a memorial to Sgt Copping, but to a wider conflict ; it must have taken courage to fight in such an inhospitable environment.

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #784994
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    I wouldn’t hold your breath, over reacquiring this airframe, hypothetically what you suggest is possible, however when you want someone to do a shoddy job and just paint over the original, inevitably they strip every last bit, and with regards to metal work, it was very badly damaged, (even though it appeared to be quite good) one can only imagine what was removed and lost to get to this “finished state”

    in reply to: Flt Sgt Copping's P-40 From The Egyptian Desert #785225
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    The only reason it survived for so long, is that Egypt is third world, ultimately it has become a victim of that environment,(as it would have, had it been left in the desert) and who knows another uprising may be just around the corner, giving the opportunity for someone to destroy it completely.

    The blame falls entirely at the feet of the RAFM, who should have been smart enough to state “freight on board” in the contract; as said above there was no guarantee that the Egyptians would ever let it leave the country even before the “Arab spring”.

    The director has long since resigned, and his replacement has successfully dismantled at least part of the museum that would have been it’s home; (but it’s early days, she may yet be able to ruin Hendon completely) fair to say that the RAFM haven’t learned any lessons.

    in reply to: Another dumb winter project! #788841
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Found the drg (amazingly) the distance from tip to tip is 18.26″; as said previously mine was 3/4″ under, even the spherical gunsight mount was well undersize!

    in reply to: Another dumb winter project! #789101
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Robert, the coaming isn’t as difficult as it seems; BUT be warned, if the gun sight bar is a reproduction, it will almost certainly be too small (point to point) mine was 3/4″ out and had to make the coaming pieces so they flared out at the end to accept the gun site casting.

    There is a drg for this measurement, which I do have, but unsure where at the mo.

    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Are those 50% original parts by weight, volume, or fantasy? I’m sure Graham, would never have made such a claim, so journalistic creativity then……

    in reply to: Battle of Britain film…it's a crazy world #822955
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Is this entire thread written in code?

    in reply to: Glen Miller Wasn't Killed By RAF Lancasters? #829248
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Even in this modern age light A/C are more than capable of getting themselves into trouble, without any help from a passer by.

    in reply to: Hurricane R4085 relics Billericay crash #829256
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    I don’t believe they are still active; something in the back of my mind says Ramsden, the Cater museum in the high street (if it’s still going) had photos, of the crash site I believe

    in reply to: Hurricane R4085 relics Billericay crash #829325
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Where did this one come down? we used to have a field in Ramsden (generally considered to be Billericay except if you come from Billericay that is) and they excavated (two different groups) a 110 the latter group removing an engine back to Tilbury fort; South East Aviation something or other, it may have been them.

    in reply to: Another Amelia Theory of Disappearance #829331
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    I must admit when I squint I can kind of see Taurus, or orion, or even an escort or fiesta…….

    in reply to: Flying K5054 Replica #831595
    stuart gowans
    Participant

    Indeed a lovely aeroplane, hope you enjoy flying it.

    stuart gowans
    Participant

    I like to think in those days we applied racism in a more even handed manner, they were all “bl00dy foreigners” unless born in England, and that included the jocks the taffs and the paddys; it will probably be an ATA pilot, with previously unknown lesbian tendencies, and an African parentage recently discovered through my ancestory . bolok …….

Viewing 15 posts - 151 through 165 (of 1,986 total)