dark light

Pinko

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 331 through 345 (of 1,105 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2341907
    Pinko
    Participant

    On another note it does show how times are changing in the PRC. I would think a decade or two ago if you got that close to the airfield testing a secret new jet with a camera you would be shot no questions asked! Now you can walk up with your camera/camera phone sit in a hedge and take some pictures then go home to post them on the Chinese blogosphere!

    If that is the case, I would highly suggest you book the next flight and join the army of speculators mobilized there, the texiway run may still last for a while, and upload to this board LIVE via your Iphone. 😀

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2342548
    Pinko
    Participant

    Well, I have no idea, the latest news is it’s very close to the maiden flight :dev2:

    Final taxi way run seems finished…

    http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a184/Military_Pictures/J-20s.jpg?t=1293036958

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2342559
    Pinko
    Participant

    …I have seen all of the recent photos. J-11B projects are finally equipping with WS-10, but they still have a lot of problems. We have all been guilty of overly optimistic about the progress of Taihang over the years. Let’s wait and see that this is consistent first. Clearly, Shenyang Liming is entirely abysmal in its production and that situation is not improving anytime soon.

    I don’t doubt that they learnt a lot from studying AL-31F, but WS-10A is a different engine.

    Well, official China aviation news reported recently, SAC has handed over historically RECORD number of fighters to PLA.

    http://www.cannews.com.cn/zghkb/html/2010-12/18/content_11409.htm

    We know there are a large number of J11Bs manufactured in past 2years couldn’t be handed over because of the WS-10 issues. now, with the massive hand-over of J11Bs by SAC to both PLAAF & PLANAF in this year ( actually with the volume from past 2-3 years that makes the record number), it’s a clear sign the WS-10 powerplant issues have largely been solved. With approx 100 WS-10 engines in active service, the severity of problems collectively gathered from a pool of hundreds surely differs from problems coming from 1 or 2 lab made engine prototypes, the confidence level is different. To this scale and stage, I’d like to stress what I have said before, the WS-10 passed its most difficult stage, and on its way to final success, btw, another officail news has confirmed WS-10’s FADEC version has successfully flied on the flight testbed.

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2347389
    Pinko
    Participant

    a couple of things:
    1) I would not expect real photos of J-20 out there yet and any CG should be regarded as such and does not reflect the aircraft
    2) WS-15 is slated to be the engine for J-20, but when it will be ready is another story.
    3) WS-10A has shown the struggle that China is having with turbofan development and especially production. Always be conservative when talking about which engine will be ready and when.

    Ws-10 has passed its hardest time, and recent images confirmed that J-11B powered by Ws-10 has been in active service in PLAAF elite unites

    http://www.fyjs.cn/bbs/attachments/Mon_1011/27_130384_71cbe1f5d4663ae.jpg

    While new J-11 units like the twin seat J-11BS are all powered by WS-10

    http://i11.photobucket.com/albums/a184/Military_Pictures/J11BspoweredbyWS10.jpg?t=1292429602

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2349140
    Pinko
    Participant

    I’m not entirely sure the upmost right engine is the WS-15 core, it looks wrong. More like a small turbojet to my eyes.

    Well, that’s because the Chinese description line beside the engine says it is WuoShan-15 ( WS-15) under developing and intended to use in Chinese 4th G fighter ( 5th internationally)

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2349143
    Pinko
    Participant

    I think there was an aerodynamics issue with a canard delta with canted twin fins. I recall reading about that issue a while back. The CGs therefore look unrealistic to me. I’m still holding out for a more conventional design.

    Emm, one of early JSF candidates demoed there is no issue of canard with canted vertical fins as long as aerodynamic performance is concerned, below is not a cg, but a photo of real thing

    http://forum.keypublishing.co.uk/attachment.php?attachmentid=184463&d=1273246411

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2349920
    Pinko
    Participant

    What engine to power J-20, which touches some most vulnerable area of Chinese aviation industries. Officially, the WS-15 is still the final powerplant for upcoming Chinese 5th generation fighter jet, as illustrated by below chart. The image at upmost right is the core engine of WS-15.

    http://www.fyjs.cn/bbs/attachments/Mon_0912/27_2888_5415b55124abd46.jpg

    Since this chart has been existing for quite some time now, the prototype of Ws-15 should be ready by now, possible finished or undergoing high altitude tests to this point of time.

    WS-10 official max thrust is 122kn, on par with that of AL31F, even though the WS-10 reached > 130kn during endurance test, probably so that it can be conveniently exchanged with AL31F on J11s. be mindful, the Russians have stopped any AL31F for J11s, WS-10 is the only choice, and it’s mature now with massive production and consistent J11Bs/J11BSs being produced and inducted .

    Now there’s improved Ws-10G, with FADEC, 1st customer most likely to be PLANAF’s J15 for better TWR needed during aircraft carrier’s taking off. However, as J-15 itself is in prototype stage, unlikely, Ws-10G could be mature at present and being installed on J20 prototype.

    The j-20 main contractor, CAC has a close working relation with Russia’s Salyut, Salyut secured AL-31F contract from Saturn because of Chinese order ( CAC’s J10), and developed improved AL-31F-m1, m2 , m3 etc, solely for CAC initially, although later the Al31F-M1 became the standard powerplant of Su27SM. The AL31F-M1 reaches 13 ton max thust, slightly higher than wS-10 current allowed max thust . M2 reaches 14 tons, currently the best can be offered by Salyut to CAC, I suspect the Al-31F-M2 could have been installed in the J-20 prototype.

    But nevertheless, J-20 will be powered by Ws-15 turbofan, yes, I have to prioritize the official news, don’t we.;) For some more details on core engine of WS-15, we actually had some discussion 4 years ago:

    http://forum.keypublishing.co.uk/showthread.php?t=49067&highlight=pinko&page=8

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2350700
    Pinko
    Participant

    Be patient as usual, no pic doesn’t mean no flight. 😉

    http://oi53.tinypic.com/2q9yyxl.jpg

    J-10’s 1st flight in 1998, only 2001 we had its 1st image, even though still been called “PSed” this time round, I don’t think it will take that long, but will still be “lagging”.

    in reply to: China's upcoming 5th G fighter–J-20 prototype is ready #2350998
    Pinko
    Participant

    Sorry, but Jane’s “re”-reports only things which are said (or rumoured) since months in several Chinese forums, esp. Huitong posted this long ago.

    But anyway You are correct .. let tzhe speculation begin …. but I hope for something like that!

    Deino

    Do note Jane’s also quoted Russian source. There is still high chance that the prototype again may be powered by Russian engine, whcih makes russian source somehow reliable.

    As for your “rumours” commenet, hey, I got a track record of starting “rumours” in this board ;). as early as 2004/05, we were speculating WS-10A, J11B, WZ-10 etc. any of them is NOT a rumour then?! but today, no one will think it is again. because it’s reality. today, the chinese information channel is much open compared to 10 years again, the PLAAF depute chief has already confirmed IOC of J-20 by 2017, that’s NOT a rumour and what we can expect now really perfectly fits the timeframe of the roadmap

    in reply to: Hot Dog PLAAF; News and Photos volume 14 #2359795
    Pinko
    Participant

    J-10’s air show in Zhuhai by PLAAF August 1st. Aerobatic Team 

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FE1b48w6AYk

    12 mins long footage

    in reply to: Hot Dog PLAAF; News and Photos volume 14 #2392183
    Pinko
    Participant

    Don’t be surprised when you see C-130 owned by China:;)

    Letter from the President Regarding an Export Waiver for China
    TEXT OF A LETTER FROM THE PRESIDENT
    TO THE SPEAKER OF THE HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES
    AND THE PRESIDENT OF THE SENATE

    Dear Madam Speaker: (Dear Mr. President: )

    Pursuant to the authority vested in me by section 902(b)(2) of the Foreign Relations Authorization Act, Fiscal Years 1990 and 1991 (Public Law 101-246)(the “Act”), and as President of the United States, I hereby report to the Congress that it is in the national interest of the United States to terminate the suspensions under section 902(a)(3) of the Act with respect to the issuance of temporary munitions export licenses for exports to the People’s Republic of China insofar as such restrictions pertain to the C-130 cargo aircraft to be used in oil spill response operations at sea. License requirements remain in place for these exports and require review and approval on a case-by-case basis by the United States Government.

    Sincerely,
    BARACK OBAMA

    http://m.whitehouse.gov/the-press-office/2010/10/08/letter-president-regarding-export-waiver-china

    in reply to: Type 45 vs. DDG-1000 #2025858
    Pinko
    Participant

    Type 45 vs. DDG-1000

    EF-2000 Vs F-22 😉

    in reply to: PLAN Carrier Updates. #2028655
    Pinko
    Participant

    Rough translation: Steam Test, Keep away.

    Pinko
    Participant

    I wouldn’t totally rule out that the dense air defense actually attribute to the final losing of the D-21 UAV #527:

    The fourth and last operational flight attempt took place on March 20 using D-21 #527. This mission too would end in failure, when the drone was lost three-quarters of the way through the flight over a heavily defended area. This also turned out to be the last flight for the D-21 program. Out of the 21 D-21 missions flown, only four were modestly successful.

    http://goliath.ecnext.com/coms2/gi_0199-2707015/Tagboard-Senior-Bowl-The-D.html

    Now, The Chinese formally put the relic of the D-21 crashed in China on show in museum.

    http://res.news.ifeng.com/attachments/2010/08/09/63efe9668028cbbe26e4d89e9fa365db.jpg

    http://res.news.ifeng.com/attachments/2010/08/09/135a13341d919ebb52da71d423448462.jpg

    http://res.news.ifeng.com/attachments/2010/08/09/c5f0fb9020fedb021425d1863e836593.jpg

    http://res.news.ifeng.com/attachments/2010/08/09/47ed509cd245177b5ad6aad20399f950.jpg

    http://res.news.ifeng.com/attachments/2010/08/09/0858193d64edfad06396581bd8635770.jpg

    http://i37.tinypic.com/o0qfco.jpg

    in reply to: the MiG-15 and MiG-15UTI in China #2373336
    Pinko
    Participant

    No,man…we use 5,just because most of this aircrafts was started in our first 5 years plan…

    China’s 1st 5 year plan starts from 1953 and ends 1957, Q-5, the 1st attacker was designed and manufactured in 1960s, modeled after J-6, the same happens to 1st transport plane—Y-5 and 1st helicopter the Z-5. They all manufactured after 1st 5 year plan, yet still started with 5.

Viewing 15 posts - 331 through 345 (of 1,105 total)