dark light

MadRat

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 2,416 through 2,430 (of 4,651 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Rafale vs F-16b52+ and J-10 #2346101
    MadRat
    Participant

    Not really? Math suggests he was correct and your assessment was wrong. The only parity claim one could make was that at one time the sum for the gross weight of shoot downs was rather close between the two sides and even that comparison was short lived.

    in reply to: Predict the winners! #2346146
    MadRat
    Participant

    I missed the Indian contest, predicting Super Hornet would win. But when you think about it, the result may be a fluke of the current weak administration positioning itself to collapse it’s spending base more than a straight win. If the US hadn’t spent itself into a hole under the false pretense of world economic collapse then it would diplomatically been unlikely Super Hornet was removed from contention. I also feel the rumblings in the EU hampered the Eurofighter bid, whereas there was far less instability dealing with France. And because everything was dragged out by the F-35 distraction, a stronger diplomatic tone could have spoiled the Rafale bid. Luckily for France the overspending from 2008 by the US government weakened the current US bargaining position. Anyone that picked Rafale was solely right out of luck.

    Now if Brazil would make up their minds!

    in reply to: UK considers Rafale and F-18 as 'interim aircraft' #2354026
    MadRat
    Participant

    Hornets refurbished and leased are not implausible and they are the most fitting choice. The second most plausible is a Rafale M lease. You would take financial pressure off Frances MoD and have the most compatible aircraft. Super Hornet means a much bigger commitment. Rafale uses weapons that are less difficult to port over and vice versa.

    in reply to: UK considers Rafale and F-18 as 'interim aircraft' #2355868
    MadRat
    Participant

    The only real option is rebuilt Hornets from the boneyard. The USN already has a plan to dust many old airframes off. You can then use the mod for using ASRAAM and it’s cheaper than Super Hornet or Rafale. When they are done with them the USN can have them back. Simplest and cheapest solution.

    in reply to: T-50, M-346 and Yak-130 advance trainers future prospect? #2358987
    MadRat
    Participant

    You can conceivably fill the Kfir’s old niche with a fleshed out T-50. The M-346 really isn’t something you can really develop much beyond a trainer. Just a thought.

    in reply to: Here we go more cuts #2360671
    MadRat
    Participant

    The problem is its a slippery slope that has to get ‘better’ with each passing year or there is systemic failure. The economic woes of today is the realization that the road of progress is no longer open. If these ‘new ways’ of fixing old problems were investments they would consider them a form of ponzi scheme. The shrinking purchasing power of today is firmly entrenched in the decisions of yesterday. Add in the complexity of modern systems and the issues cascade.

    in reply to: Here we go more cuts #2360922
    MadRat
    Participant

    I would think Labour is the problem with the UK. It’s the US equivalent to progressives. Inch your way closer to communism with each passing year.

    in reply to: T-50, M-346 and Yak-130 advance trainers future prospect? #2361960
    MadRat
    Participant

    Everything in the cockit is COTS and the engine is used by M-346.

    in reply to: NORTH KOREA Airforce and Air defences #2362264
    MadRat
    Participant

    So the MiG-29 is their most advanced aircraft. What model? (Or has anyone taken time to analyze the variant yet?)

    in reply to: T-50, M-346 and Yak-130 advance trainers future prospect? #2362291
    MadRat
    Participant

    The twin tails on the Javelin lay in the airstream. The single tail has to be tall to hit that same airstream. The M-346 and Yak-130 could have opted for twin tails to not only be prettier, but to have some control surface redundancy.

    in reply to: T-50, M-346 and Yak-130 advance trainers future prospect? #2362494
    MadRat
    Participant

    M-346 is a graceful aircraft. Not sure that you don’t get more bang for the buck going for L-159. The IAI could probably buy the rights to build their own L-159’s at a competitive price.

    in reply to: Here we go more cuts #2362852
    MadRat
    Participant

    Aim for purely Pentagon staffing cut in half, that will cut down a significant amount of the budget.

    in reply to: Should modern combat jets go back to dedicated designs? #2363404
    MadRat
    Participant

    Russian Assault Helicopters in that era were used more like gyrocopters with running head starts for takeoff. The HIND was lighter loaded than the HIP and carried out more strafing roles. The HIP often carried rockets to clear out the area where they intended to land. Both types of helicopters were notoriously overloaded in the warzone and suffered from engine reliability. The engines would surge in and out of power under those conditions making flight somewhat like a series of bounds from one surge of power to the next. Most of the pretty filmography comes later in the war when the Afghanis are picking off helicopters in the lowlands much nearer their bases of operations. Those were perilous times for Russian ‘commandoes’.

    in reply to: T-50, M-346 and Yak-130 advance trainers future prospect? #2364329
    MadRat
    Participant

    The long tails on the Yak and M-346 bother me. I’m surprised with the way their back end lays out they didn’t opt for a more visually pleasant experience. Can anyone look at the now defunct Javelin project and say its unappealing to the eye?

    in reply to: Any further need for Mach 3? #2364545
    MadRat
    Participant

    High speed flight will never be obsolete no matter what people are saying here. There simply isn’t a SAM that will consistently take down high speed targets unless they are moving in a fairly straight line. That satellite shot was done by by moving the firing ship into an intercept location.

Viewing 15 posts - 2,416 through 2,430 (of 4,651 total)