dark light

Rii

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 1,516 through 1,530 (of 3,311 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: F-35 News, Multimedia & Discussion thread (2) #2263416
    Rii
    Participant

    JSR is right about opportunity cost tho. “Look at the benefits JSF brings to UK industry” ignores the benefits UK industry could’ve accrued by pursuing alternative paths foreclosed by JSF. To be fair the real epic blunders came before JSF — no Harrier successor, Typhoon unable to operate from aircraft carrier, etc.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread part 13 #2263452
    Rii
    Participant

    Is there any recent news on Russia’s MPA plans, i.e. A-40 or… ?

    Upgrades for Il-38s. Boring!

    in reply to: should Indonesia bail out on KFX? #2264500
    Rii
    Participant

    With respect to the Turks, I think the Korean project has a better prospect of coming to fruition in some form. If Turkey does go forward, alone, I expect the aircraft will be a Turkified Gripen E/F. Not that there’s anything wrong with that…

    in reply to: Egypt wants Russian! #2264553
    Rii
    Participant

    Not sure this is really deserving of its own thread until there are additional sources and/or details. At the current juncture I don’t see much potential for productive discussion here — just a political slanging match.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread part 13 #2264607
    Rii
    Participant

    Avicopter Slips AC332, Models New Larger AHL

    Good to see some news/details/confirmation on this at last. Thanks for the heads-up.

    China’s Avicopter suggests that the Advanced Heavy Lifter (AHL) may be eclipsed only by Russia’s giant Mil Mi-26.

    Are they including CH-53K in that? If so, that suggests this is basically a next-gen Mi-26. My guess is that they aren’t, and that it just means ‘larger than Chinook.’

    I’m a bit surprised that Russia/China isn’t going tri-engine for these giant helos like Merlin and CH-53E/K. Are modern turboshafts really that reliable with enough overdrive capacity for engine-out scenarios?

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 17 #2264781
    Rii
    Participant

    Who knows, maybe the truck is a fake too. And the people? Stuffed with straw!

    in reply to: Military Aviation News-2013 #2265407
    Rii
    Participant

    http://cdn-www.airliners.net/aviation-photos/middle/7/1/1/2342117.jpg

    Great shot! :applause:

    in reply to: Future Of Iranian Air Force #2265656
    Rii
    Participant

    Su-35 and J-10B would make for a good hi-lo mix, or perhaps a step lower in the form of MiG-35 and JF-17. A diversified mix is desirable to limit the impact of future supply disruptions — western sources are out of the question. Ok, maybe accept some hand-me-down F-16s like Iraq as part of some diplo deal for the cameras, but don’t spend too much on them, don’t rely on them for air intercept, and back them up with non-western aircraft too.

    in reply to: Chinese Air Power Thread 17 #2266518
    Rii
    Participant

    This may seem like an inane question, but why do manufacturers fly new aircraft unpainted or in primer? Presumably, the aircraft is going to get painted anyway. Is it a question of just wanting to see if the aircraft will fly first? I remember pics of F-22A’s being flown with natl. insignia and unit marks over primer.

    I suspect the difference is between a public rollout with press and a few amateurs snapping shots from over the fence.

    in reply to: should Indonesia bail out on KFX? #2266530
    Rii
    Participant

    Gripen E/F is closer to F-16 in the early-middle stages of its life, i.e. the aircraft that conquered the west.

    in reply to: should Indonesia bail out on KFX? #2266579
    Rii
    Participant

    I don’t think Sweden would be interested in an aircraft configured as above — it wouldn’t seem to offer any advantage over Gripen E/F besides size, which is likely a disadvantage from the Swedish perspective, i.e. more expensive to acquire/operate.

    in reply to: should Indonesia bail out on KFX? #2266873
    Rii
    Participant

    If they could sort out the workshare issues a joint Korean-Turkish program with SAAB assistance still makes excellent sense. With both nations being confronted recently with cost issues, perhaps a compromise is still possible…

    in reply to: should Indonesia bail out on KFX? #2266902
    Rii
    Participant

    No. Regardless of configuration KF-X will accrue valuable industrial benefits to Indonesia, and the aircraft will offer a modern, affordable complement to future high-end platforms such as T-50 — certainly far moreso than the likely alternative of more, increasingly rickety F-16s.

    Indeed, Indonesia would probably prefer a config like that depicted above (F100/110 propulsion one assumes) to a heavier platform in the class of F-35.

    in reply to: Brazil closer to Boeing on jets deal after Biden visit #2266994
    Rii
    Participant

    Rafale’s superiority in A2A far exceeds any edge Super Hornet has in A2G.

    I doubt Rafale is any cheaper to run than Super Hornet. The real question is, given comparable costs, why would you buy the inferior platform?

    From Brazil’s perspective, where they’re not living under the looming shadow of a heavy adversary, cost is going to be the main parameter. And this is where I’d imagine an (always cheap) American munitions complement would swing it for the SH vis a vis Rafale.

    Pity Gripen NG is in the mix as well to murder both.

    But I don’t think cost is the single overriding factor, industry considerations will be key also, and this is where Gripen falters. The Americans could offer a competitive package, if the White House is behind it to clear away all the procedural roadblocks, but then there are strategic questions for Brazil to consider also — questions that’ve only been reinforced by the recent NSA revelations.

    in reply to: RuAF News and Development Thread part 13 #2267624
    Rii
    Participant

    http://img542.imageshack.us/img542/8513/7135.jpg

    Is there any recent news on Russia’s MPA plans, i.e. A-40 or… ?

    I see from Beriev website that contract for 4 x Be-200 was signed with MoD earlier this year, with more expected to follow. Don’t think these have any MPA role tho…

Viewing 15 posts - 1,516 through 1,530 (of 3,311 total)