dark light

Creaking Door

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 10,516 through 10,530 (of 12,419 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225368
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Yes, of course it would be regrettable to loose the only Comet 2/C2, and currently the only Comet in RAF Transport Command colours, but the only really appropriate place to display it, Cosford, already has a Comet.

    And Comet 1XB XM823 has a history that fits well into the Cosford collection; it was a trials aircraft, carried a military serial, was painted in Transport Command colours (nearly) and could be painted so again.

    It is also very important in its own right as the last complete Comet 1.

    Who knows, with the current trend for painting aircraft in authentic colours (RAFM Tempest, IWM Mosquito) isn’t it possible that one of the other genuine RAF Comet C4 aircraft may wear Transport Command colours again?

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225448
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Came across this interesting thread when googling for appropriate colour schemes for Comet 1XB XM823 at Cosford:

    http://forum.keypublishing.co.uk/showthread.php?t=71057

    Now where would I find some real anoraky information about XM823? Yes, of course…..here! :rolleyes:

    Couldn’t RAF Transport Command honour be satisfied if the Lyneham Comet was lost?

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225467
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    No, no, no…..Tu-144…..ugly sister…..with a moustache…

    moustache…..get it? 😀

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225486
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Sorry guys, maybe I should have said ‘race of masterminds’ or ‘master-race’…

    …it’s obviously a bit early for jokes! 😀

    Yes, obviously a bit early for jokes! :rolleyes:

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225518
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Sorry guys, maybe I should have said ‘race of masterminds’ or ‘master-race’…

    …it’s obviously a bit early for jokes! 😀

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225605
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    …I would love to have seen a TU-144 flown over to the UK and preserved next to a Concorde.

    There is no way you’re going to see a Tu-144 alongside a Concorde, you’re dreaming…

    …why it would take unimaginable audacity and imagination…..and could only be accomplished by a race of supermen! :rolleyes:

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1225926
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    Unfortunately we lost our only airliner standard 707, in a wicked cull…

    Wasn’t the 707 scrapped at Cosford the last surviving Rolls-Royce Conway engined version?

    I’m not much of an airliner fan myself but the accidents that overtake them are well documented and usually contain a lot of engineering so spark my interest. The only other thing that I know about the Conway engined version of the 707 is that a BOAC one was lost over Japan when it broke-up in severe turbulence. No prizes for guessing why that has been on my mind recently.

    Same goes for my Comet knowledge; I’m pretty sure the RAF C2/C4 fleet had a good safety record…..because I know little about them.

    A question for those who are primarily interested in airliners…..why are there so few in museums?

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1226154
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    This is Cosford’s BOAC coloured comet 1…..I thought she would have square windows.

    Apparently she is a Comet 1XB…

    …something I’ve learnt recently. 🙂 Thanks for the up-to-date photos…..she looks in good condition.

    in reply to: General Motors bankruptcy #1909718
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    The deal has effectively been done with Magna International/Russian banks, and this has been approved by the German government (who are providing a significant portion of the funds, in return for a promise that no German factories will be closed).

    So, no protectionism there then! :rolleyes:

    Goodbye Ellesmere Port. 😡

    in reply to: General Discussion #335188
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    The deal has effectively been done with Magna International/Russian banks, and this has been approved by the German government (who are providing a significant portion of the funds, in return for a promise that no German factories will be closed).

    So, no protectionism there then! :rolleyes:

    Goodbye Ellesmere Port. 😡

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1226688
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    A bit more oblique thinking.

    While there are five other complete preserved Comets in the UK only two of them are under cover at Duxford and Wroughton (I’m guessing)…..or maybe it is the Comet 1 at Cosford that is under cover?

    Comet 1 – XM823, F-BGNY – RAF Museum Cosford – Under cover?

    Comet 4 – G-APDB – DAS Collection, IWM Duxford – Under cover
    Comet 4B – G-APYD – Science Museum collection, Wroughton – Under cover
    Comet 4C – G-BDIX – Museum of Flight, East Fortune.
    Comet 4 – XS235 – Cold war jets collection, Bruntingthorpe

    (Hopefully Bruce won’t mind me appropriating part of his list.)

    So if the budget for even moving the Lyneham C2 to storage somewhere is of the order of £100,000 wouldn’t that money be better spent in ensuring the long-term survival of the remaining Comets? How much is a hangar?

    How long have the other Comets been outside?

    How long will they last if they remain outside given the fragile nature of some of the exotic early alloys they were built with?

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1226923
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    There are no C.2s anywhere else, Bruces list is complete. However G-BDIW in Germany is an ex RAF C.4, East Fortunes Comet 4 may be ex C.4 aswel. Other than this C.2, no Comets are preserved in RAF service colours

    Thanks, didn’t know that the RAF operated a Comet C4 as well…..is a Comet C2 effectively the same as a Comet 2 and a C4 effectively a Comet 4?

    Cold comfort if this is the last remaining Comet 2 but at least there is the possibility of the Duxford Comet 4 masquerading as an RAF C4 or even the more appropriate re-painting of either the East Fortune or the German Comet in RAF C4 livery.

    What plans are there for the Cosford Comet and what paint does it currently wear?

    in reply to: Comet at Lyneham no longer doomed….! #1226936
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    …this is still the only RAF example in the UK…

    …she is more important in the military jet transport context than in the wider Comet one in general.

    Am I missing something; is there an RAF Comet C2 preserved abroad?

    While I agree that this Comet is better representative of the RAF service of the Comet the obvious places to preserve it, Cosford, Hendon or Duxford either already have one (but not a C2 obviously) or don’t want this one…..the RAF Museum having already washed its hands of this particular airframe.

    Don’t get me wrong I’d truly love to see it saved but it is going to be an uphill struggle if the best options are non-starters.

    in reply to: General Discussion #335319
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    …if we lose Vauxhall in the UK to be replaced by the far more stylish Opel brand I can’t say I’ll be sorry.

    I wouldn’t take that attitude very close to Ellesmere Port if I were you! :diablo:

    The Vauxhall and Opel brands are identical surely; literally, only the badge is different.

    in reply to: General Motors bankruptcy #1909751
    Creaking Door
    Participant

    …if we lose Vauxhall in the UK to be replaced by the far more stylish Opel brand I can’t say I’ll be sorry.

    I wouldn’t take that attitude very close to Ellesmere Port if I were you! :diablo:

    The Vauxhall and Opel brands are identical surely; literally, only the badge is different.

Viewing 15 posts - 10,516 through 10,530 (of 12,419 total)