Trying once again to return to the core topic here:
The Eurofighter program is a “multinational machine”, what would be the worst outcome to the British (BAE Systems) percentage of the deal if the Saudis dropped off?
I understaood originally that the Saudi order would come out of the original RAF orders leaving the production totals unchanged is this still true?
Would the RAF be obliged to take all the originally ordered aircraft? If so, this would be a zero-sum situation no win/no loss for teh Eurofighter consortium but would keep the pre-existing financial burden on the UK government/RAF
Comments?
Hammer
P.S.: On a parallel reasoning line: Are the French actually fighting for the sheer survival of their fighter-building industry? If the Saudis are out of their future client list by buying EF2000 who’s left in the world to keep Dassault in this business? India?
According to Avia.ru newsletter Russia is about to sign a contract with Brazil for the delivery of various helicopters. Avia.ru said their sources was Janes, and that the contract is to be signed pretty soon. Total vallue of the deal was supposed to be 400 mln USD, and the types mentioned where Mil Mi-171, 26 and 35. Probably more info to come soon….
Tjhis news is apparenly hot! Mi-26s are for the Army, the rest are for the Air Force… it was all over the news today here in Brazil.
Regards,
Hammer
The Mexican Navy has no fighter force whatsoever, and they want to overcome this limitation. The fact that the Mexican AF may think that their F-5 is good enough is their own problem. ๐
Maybe the Navy dreams of operating Aircraft carriers in the future. Who knows, maybe a second hand Kuznetzov! ๐
The Navy is a good client of ex-soviet aviation Industry operatinhg a bunch of Mil brand helicopters and (ucranian) Antonov torboprop transports.
This is why Flankes make some sense
Regards
Hammer
Argentina and Brazil being the only candidates I can think of. The former is pretty possible, the latter should be going for Rafales one day, I think. As for any others, I don’t think so, even if nothing can be ruled out (Peru?).
Operationally-wise some 36 long-legged Flankers based out of the southernmost Argentinian air bases should take the sleep away from some of the people at the British MoD office in London… ๐
LOL!
Regards
Hammer
Is it possible that other countries could join the CVF Program? For example Spain plans on operating F-35B’s much like the RN and clearly would like a larger Carrier than its current “Principe de Asturias”! Further, France has been considering a second CVF-FR Carrier giving its Navy 3-Aircraft Carriers! (i.e. Charles de Gaulle & Two CVF’s) :rolleyes: Makes you wonder if we could see a Aircraft Carrier Arms Race in the future……………. ๐ฎ
FLY NAVY ๐
Brazil needs a new carrier, if only the government people were smart enough to have noticed it by now…
China and India need some CVs too! ๐
Regards,
Hammer
I was reading this thread and noticed that I had no idea if there was there ever was in the history of Aircraft Carriers any case of expansion through cutting and plugging? I know this is done regularly in the civilian side, but what about in the VC arena?
Regards
Hammer
The presence of the Super Tucanos in the Region apparently has been responsible for the upgrade from drugrunning light props to bizjets.
This is where the fast fighter jets come into the picture.
Regards,
Hammer
If someone would make a serious request, perhaps Dassault would consider re-opening the line. But nobody has done. That’s why it was shut. Indias idea of “immediate” seems to be “We’ll think about making a decision sometime this decade. Or maybe next”. 7 years ago, India wanted new M2K in service “as soon as possible” – & 6 1/2 years later, Dassault got tired of waiting for the evaluation process to start, & shut the line. It’s not being “too picky”, it’s not having a single customer who’s willing to negotiate in good faith!
Come on Swerve, you have to be kidding: “good faith”? ๐ A Government has its own pace and is driven back and forth by the political tides that change every quarter or so, any company that choses to sell to governments surely know how they work and knows also that it can’t really do anything about this…
The Indians main priority is to buy the “right aircraft” for their needs, notice tha “right” above does not necessarily mean the best, or cheaper, or best performing… it means just the “right” aircraft for the local political reality at the time of decision.
If they are lucky the airframe manufacturers will have a good option for the purchasing nation at the time the bid is opened. If not, too bad for the seller! If the French Government thought that maintaining the M2000 line open longer would be a good strategy for the country why didn’t they buy some 24 units themselves? This would allow the line to be left open longer…
Oh! Maybe it was Dassault that didn’t want the line open in order to be certain that the French Air Force (or their politicians!) would not be tempted to cancel part of the Rafale order for some new units of modernized M2000, right? ๐
I think you inavertently nailed the real problem in your text above, Dassault’s problem was not that India delayed its purchase, it’s that India was the ONLY client around (at least partialy) interested in new build M2000… ๐
Regards,
Hammer
Unless france is giving out Rafales for charity without any support and armament this budget will only fetch about 12 rafales. On the otherhand you could probably buy 18-20 sukhoi’s with everything.
If france is not too picky they could reopen the Mirage 2k-5 lines and produce a limited quanitity. Brazil could easily afford 22-24 brand new mirages with that money and IAF wants 40 more for immediate use. 64 aircrafs can keep the M2k-5 line open for a couple of years.
Well unit costs are a big problem for the French and a big selling point for the Russians. But today support for the Russian planes is not just a budget issue it’s more and more related to the huge potential of Brazilian future exports to Russia as well as their interest in sharing advanced technology (mostly space operations and rocket launcher) with Brasil. The French don’t have as much to offer in such favourable conditions as the Russians.
The Venezuelan Flanker purchase may end up being the most effective strategy in order for Latin American governments to drop some long held prejudices against Russia and its aicraft industry.
Letยดs see how it develops. The Russians apparently were able to deliver yesterday two brand new Su-30s to Venezuela merely 6 months after signing the deal… not bad, not bad at all!
Regards,
Hammer
http://www.fav-club.com web magazine reports that the first two aircraft have been delivered today disassembled directly to Barcelona AFB in Venezuela on the belly of a An-124 transport. Cammo is 2-tone gray air superiority scheme with national flag and traditional “Combat triangle” on the tail . Quality pictures still not available to confirm this info.
Regards,
Hammer
High placed sources inside the Brazilian Air Force have indicated that the FX purchase this time around should be much less “public” than the first one was. Aparently there are only to paths ahead for the FX: a french one with Rafale (and another set of used M2000C as interim aircraft) and a Russian one with the Su-35 (no interim aircraft here). Apparently the Eurofighter is out on the grounds of costs and available delivery dates. The single engine types apparently have also been dropped, so the Gripen and the the Fighting Falcon are considered to be out of the race as well.
But this is the story at this point in time and everything can change radically in a minute…
Regards
Hammer
Brazil do not need highly sophisticate fighter aircraft,when the real threat was internal,not external.
I just read that average 20 people were killed in the slum of San paola,one out of 5 is unemployed,just last week,heavely armed gangs member attack police station resulting large casualties for both side.giving this problem,Brazil better concentrate there limited resources trying to fight this problem.
Well Challenge, if we go down the “need to have” line of reasoning, even the US, the largest military power ever in the world history, wouldn’t really NEED them since it’s only two next door neighbors can’t ever be seen as some kind of real military menace to the US…
Also since the fall of the USSR there is hardly any case for the purchase of modern fighters by the western european nations, but, for some reason, ๐ they keep on doing it…
Geopolitical reality changes quickly these days, today’s best buddy might turn out to be a future rival or outright enemy… Iran, Iraq, and Venezuela come to mind on this issue….
In our specific case, after a general region-wide fighter fleet upgrade with first generation supersonic models in the 70s South America is currently in the process of replacing tha now obsolete generation. Oh, yeah! Our neighbor in the north just bought some nice new and shiny Su-30s… Today Chavez is a friend of Brazil, but who know what may happen in the future? Should we just wait further and keep flying militarily useless airframes? I don’t think so.
You are right police & crime issues have nothing to do with the military forces thus they should be dealt with by the police forces, falling outside the main theme of this forum.
Regards
Hammer
Some food for thought…
The Portuguese government has expressed the desire to sell 20 of the currently held F-16s after MLU;
The MLU is to be performed by OGMA;
OGMA is nowadays essencialy owned by Embraer.You may see Vipers in the FAB future yet… we’ll see…
Hardly, Almansour, if the FAB had any wish for Vipers they would have bought the Dutch/Belgian aircraft offered dirt-cheap two years ago… The Venezuelan Viper embargo this year was percieved as a nasty precedent from Washington. There is absolutely no one cheering for the F-16 in the Air Force OR inside the government. Sorry.
Regards
Hammer
You’re right, Garry, it must have slipped my mind that Russia’s motives and actions are purely humanitarian. Misunderstood and misjudged, the gentle Bear.
Well I see the Russians less geopoliticaly-mided and more business oriented at this point in time. They now need to keep their defence industries alive and moving forward and they only got the export sale as a viable option for this. On the other hand if the US government could they would certainly immediately stop selling modern military equipement in the world market. Even to their staunchest allies… ๐ Today’s unconditional ally can quickly become tomorrow’s rival or enemy, think Iran, think Venezuela.. ๐
Regards, Hammer
As far as I know Latin America is pretty “western” so around here the russian sefense industry has been making some steady progress recently. Mi-8/17 and derivatives are operational in the militery forces of Cuba, Nicaragua, Mexico, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, Peru and according to some reports are soon to be used by Brasil and Argentina. Heavy Mi-6/26 are also beeig used as well as the light Il-103 in Peru. Fighterwise the 24-unit Su-30 sale to Venezuela is a major beachhead that might spur follow-up sales in Mexico, Brazil and in Argentina.
The US 30-YO fighter/BVR missile boycott to the continent has done wonders for the sale of Mirage fighters in the 70s and 80 and now is helping the russians. ๐
Regards
Hammer