dark light

pjhydro

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 751 through 765 (of 845 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: Tornado F3's What to do with them? #2442804
    pjhydro
    Participant

    The British had no problem to fetch the real price for all services and some profit.
    Basic operation cost of the F3 did double that of the F-104S from the start, when the later F-16 was similar to the F-104S.

    I don’t want to point out some obvious points (but I will)…

    F3 is a two engined, two man airframe so thats twice the engine and crew equipment costs right off the bat. I would have thought that would have been obvious?

    For the same number of aircraft you have double the crew and double the engines so of course increased ground personnel to deal with that. The italians operate Tornado IDS, how could this have shocked them?

    It also has twice as many missile rails as an F104, is swing wing, carries more fuel, has a more complex avionics suite… This all costs, how can the Italians possibly have been suprised by higher costs of F3 over F104? :confused:

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031416
    pjhydro
    Participant

    I’d look forward to it, I could join the Navy without having to go more than 20 miles from home to do it.

    And that really is the west country way!

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031480
    pjhydro
    Participant

    Oi! Enough of the Westcountry bashing.

    eyes married to a wet c’untry gurl so eyes can’t.

    I think Bristol would be perfect, it was after all the home of the original School of Navigation.

    Move Dartmouth to Weston-Super-mud, that would be a real test of character.

    in reply to: Tornado F3's What to do with them? #2443035
    pjhydro
    Participant

    It’s a shame Japan doesn’t make an offer for them. They could retire the F-4 and be ahead overall until F-35 reaches production.

    These Tornadoes are nice planes. Its ridiculous that they are being scrapped let alone replaced so early in their lifespans. Its no wonder you people in the UK are so much in the hole when it comes to defense spending.

    Its really not that good an aeroplane, honestly its only really become useful in recent years but most people will be glad to be shot of it as our primary fighter.

    We’re in a hole because we got dragged into some pointless conflict in the middle east…yeah i know, our own silly fault.

    in reply to: Tornado F3's What to do with them? #2443179
    pjhydro
    Participant

    What’s this?

    F3?
    F3a?
    F4a?
    F5?

    Read my post above the picture. It was an F3 modified in house by 11 Sqn, called unofficially the EF3. Proved to be a great platform in the few exercises it was used in before being scrapped. Was ear marked for GW2 but rumour has it the GR community got tetsy at the F3 community turning up with a more useful platform.

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031556
    pjhydro
    Participant

    The Defence Procurement agency is in Bristol. Take from that what you like.

    Thought it was in Bath?

    in reply to: Tornado F3's What to do with them? #2443246
    pjhydro
    Participant

    http://www.xisquadron.co.uk/Heritage/Images/Tornado.gif

    here you go.

    in reply to: Tornado F3's What to do with them? #2443247
    pjhydro
    Participant

    Its very simple to fit pylons and 11 sqn did it in house and created the EF3 to carry Alarm, before they were disbanded to become a Typhoon outfit. I would argue that the best use of F3 airframes would be to use them as SEAD and Recce platforms within the GR force, so extending the life of the Tornado force overall.

    Very little modification would be needed as the F3s own RWR/Def system worked very well with Alarm and that mod was done inhouse by 11sqn engineers, while RAPTOR and JRP are pretty well self contained pods and would just need a bit of wiring and some cockpit switches.

    The GR force would gain its own escort force by default, An EF3 with ASRAAM, AMRAAM and ALARM would be a formidable opponent down in the weeds escorting the TONKA4s and with its better medium alt engines would be great carrying recce pods.

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031583
    pjhydro
    Participant

    That’s why the army is mostly based around Aldershot. If all that was wanted was cheap land for large-scale training (the official reason for setting up the camp in the 1850s), there were many better places, but they were all too far from London for ossifers to commute, or visit their clubs in the evenings. 🙁

    And it’s not so different today….Perhaps if we moved the MOD, or at least the ‘admiralty’ to lets say Bristol, we would get a different and (by inference)better class of officer to run the Navy?

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031648
    pjhydro
    Participant

    I’m sure Portsmouth will be able to fit all the ships. Wouldn’t want the MoD to make a giant **** up like having all the ships sent there only to find there aren’t enough parking spaces.

    Oh wait, I do wish that would happen so that they don’t do it. Stupid idea. I’ve never understood why they are moving everything out of the larger port (Devonport).

    Portsmouth is so much closer to Wimbledon, Ascot, Harrods, Fortum and Mason, Twickenham, West End…. You have senior officers wives to think about, and ministers don’t want to trapse all the way to Plymouth on visits, they have justify that second home in Kensington somehow….

    in reply to: Royal Navy C3 #2031664
    pjhydro
    Participant

    You might just get away with the VT 100M ship concept, but at 3,000 tons your not going to get numbers.

    in reply to: Royal Navy C3 #2031665
    pjhydro
    Participant

    C3 is unlikely to be anything as complex or big as LCS or Sigma. When it comes to the crunch decisions the treasury will look at the types of ship it is replacing such as a 484 ton Sandown and if you turn up with a picture of USS Freedom and say “I want that one” I know what the answer will be.

    If you want high teen numbers C3 needs to be simple and pretty small. Bigger than the current MCM classes granted; much more likely to be an adaptation of the River class.

    in reply to: HMS Invincible #2031825
    pjhydro
    Participant

    I am confused why the invicible class would have taken such a battering in 1982, seeing as she was operating pretty close to where she was designed to be, was it something to do with not being fully fitted outwhen sailing?

    The seas of the N Atlantic are bad at times, but the South atlantic is far worse, stonger currents, bigger waves and weather with far more attitude. Through Deck Cruisers were designed to do Halifax and back, not chug all the way down south and stay at sea for best part of a year.

    in reply to: RN FSC – C1/C2 hull & armament proposals #2031827
    pjhydro
    Participant

    Letchworth – sum contribution to the world – the roundabout, and a load of snobbism about their neighbours.

    Phil (ex-Stevenage with inferiority complex:o)

    🙂

    Only bettered by snobbery from Hitchin…

    Paul (ex-stevenage and not going back complex 😮 )

    pjhydro
    Participant

    And in the alternate universe where the Republicans win the last election and the EU decides for the good of the world its time for a regime change…..

    So UK puts three Invincibles to sea, along with Argus and Ocean- That would be a minimum of 100 A/c berths . Spain joins with Principd’A, Italy joins with GariB and rushes Cavour into service, that would add another 50-60 A/c, then France throws in the jewel of the EU strike fleet, CDG with its 40 A/c complement, decides to attach the Mistral and Tonnnnnnnerrrrre to the Dutch and German fleets as ASW carriers and offers Jean D’Arc to Scandanavians.

    So that would be something like 100 strike/fighter, 100 odd ASW Helos and 20 odd AEW a/c…. then throw in escorts, Auxilaries with their organic air…

    Subs -6SSN from FN, lets say 8SSN from UK backed up by 4 German U212a and the plethora of costal subs acting as back stops….

    I think that might see the USN in difficulties in the North Atlantic….especailly if we do a deal with China to get all feisty in the Pacific.

    Of course the heat might be getting to me…. :p

Viewing 15 posts - 751 through 765 (of 845 total)