dark light

EdLaw

Forum Replies Created

Viewing 15 posts - 946 through 960 (of 1,259 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • in reply to: who will win the UAE trainer competition? #2591051
    EdLaw
    Participant

    I agree Petros, though the Hawk has only a basic air-to-ground capability (bombs and rockets mostly, though the Maverick has been mentioned a few times), whereas the T/A-50 is really a lightweight fighter, and can carry a full (APG-67) radar, and BVR missiles giving good air-to-air capability, and has a robust air-to-ground capability. The M346 looks promising, and the weapons options seem quite good, including light anti ship missiles, though fitting of a radar would be troublesome.

    in reply to: who will win the UAE trainer competition? #2591076
    EdLaw
    Participant

    On the other hand, the Korean T/A-50 would add a useful combat capability – further boosting the existing air power (which includes Mirage 2000s and F-16E/Fs). It all depends what you want – if you are looking for a jet trainer, then the Hawk could win, but if you are looking to add tactical roles, notably aggressor training, then the T/A-50 would probably win, and a mid point might be M346 (balance of agility and combat capability).

    in reply to: Why Poland and the Su-22? #2591560
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Well, unlike most of the other air forces, Poland has chosen to replace them, so they keep them on – they are apparently very good aircraft, and most were retired for financial reasons in other ex WarPac countries. Poland is looking like it will have a really good air force in the future, with advanced F-16s and eventually F-35s.

    in reply to: Uruguay to Buy Portuguese Frigates? #2051906
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Swerve: sorry, I was meaning the Baltic nations (Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania) who were suggested as possible customers for the used F-16s, but I was suggesting they go for the Gripens on offer (allegedly on offer) instead. Portugals F-16 have a good few years left in them, and any replacement would probably end up being F-35s or similar – Gripens are a little short ranged, though the -N model appears a good aircraft. I think the problem is that Portugal have relatively little air threat, so are looking to reduce the total number of fighters, so I doubt there would be any issues of a mixed fleet (I doubt there is enough funding around!).

    in reply to: India sends tender to MiG #2592148
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Infinite: I think you are probably thinking of the original Mig offer, which was the Mig-29M, which was pulled in favor of the Mig-35, which is just a renamed Mig-29OVT. Though they seem to change names every few years anyway…

    in reply to: Uruguay to Buy Portuguese Frigates? #2052017
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Ja:

    Uruguay (Commandant Riviere) class light ASW/patrol frigates
    Displacement: 2,250 tons full load
    Dimensions: 102.7 x 11.8 x 4.35 meters (337 x 39 x 14 feet)
    Propulsion: 4 diesels, 2 shafts, 16,000 shp, 26 knots
    Crew: 159
    Radar: DRBV 22A air search
    Sonar: SQS-17 hull, DUBA 3 attack
    Fire Control: DRBC 32C
    EW: ARBR 16 intercept
    Armament: 4 MM38 Exocet SSM, 2 100mm/55 DP, 2 40mm/70 AA, 1 305 mm
    ASW mortar, 2 triple 21.5 inch torpedo tubes
    Ex-French.

    Number Name Year Homeport Notes
    1 Uruguay 1963/90 Montevideo Ex-C.Bourdais
    2 General Artigas 1962/88 Montevideo Ex-V.Schoelcher
    3 Montevideo 1962/91 Montevideo Ex-A.Charner

    Source: http://www.hazegray.org/worldnav/ – (under Uruguay)

    I agree about the Pumas, though I suspect that for most eastern European countries, Bell 210s might make more sense (completely rebuilt and zero timed UH-1Hs).

    As for the F-16s, I think the suggestion was that they would a few of the soon to be retired Gripens from Sweden, possibly with a couple of Sk60s to help train some pilots. They would probably be a lot cheaper (and newer) than the F-16s – could be provided for free, and training in Sweden for a nominal fee (genuinely nominal, Sweden seems to actually like helping its Baltic neighbours). A possibility for the F-16s could be Thailand, who already use older F-16s, and a few more would probably be quite welcome.

    in reply to: F-35 namig (at last?) #2592547
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Lightning – the F-22 went by that name for a short while, so I would rule it out
    Spitfire – terrible name, it was a great plane, but naming JSF Spitfire is out in my books!
    Cyclone – I can just about see it, buy very unlikely
    Reaper – may as well cut to the chase and call it widowmaker!
    Black Mamba – not bad, I would just go with ‘Mamba’ though
    Piasa – huh?

    Well, Tempest makes sense, so would Mustang (P-51), Panther (F-9F), Cougar (F-11F) or Hellcat (F-6F) or even Corsair.

    in reply to: Uruguay to Buy Portuguese Frigates? #2052081
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Are you sure it is actually Romania that is interested, rather than IAR? They sometimes buy up Pumas to refurbish (they built some themselves under license as the IAR-330) and sell on – I remember reading that some middle eastern countries (cannot remember if it was UAE or Oman, I think it was one of them) were interested in procuring refurbished IAR-330s. They also did the refurb work on the RAFs ex South African Pumas, so I would not rule that out again (given that the Pumas are still giving valued service for the RAF).

    in reply to: Uruguay to Buy Portuguese Frigates? #2052108
    EdLaw
    Participant

    No, I think he means that Portugal are putting those up for sale, and Uruguay is buying just the frigates. The Allouettes would probably be sold publically, though they are quite old. Not sure who would buy the Pumas – the RAF might (they have bought up old Pumas before, to bolster the existing fleet).

    in reply to: Do JDAMS provide a new role for strategic bombers? #2593154
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Nice, and without the problems associated with swing-wings. I always liked the Victor more than the Vulcan – more payload, and generally proved itself more useful in my opinion.

    in reply to: PA-58 Verdun… #2052190
    EdLaw
    Participant

    There was a proposal to ‘Spey’ the Mirage III if memory serves, no pun intended, so a spey engined French fighter might not be out of the question. Any info on the Br.1120? Personally, I just wish they had managed to persuade the RAF to go for the Phantom (as a fighter) and the supersonic Buccaneer as the striker. It would have avoided some on the unpleasantness that developed between the RAF and RN (including a wonderful demonstration by the RAF, showing that land based TSR2s could strike anywhere a carrier could – only acheived by relocating Australia a few hundred miles!).

    This is a real world forum? Ahh, I missed that… :diablo:

    in reply to: Russian Space & Missile [ News/Discussion] #1813785
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Yeah, but it never hurts to have a little extra protection…

    in reply to: Russian Space & Missile [ News/Discussion] #1813813
    EdLaw
    Participant

    I think the idea with the Alaska positioning of ABM systems is more aimed at North Korea – they already have weapons with enough range to strike the western US. The US deployment of ABM systems is not aimed at Iran, but the Israeli involvement is because Israel needs to defend against Iran. A war between Russia and the US is not a scenario that can be dealt with by ABM systems, due to the sheer numbers involved, whereas the ability to intercept the odd missile thrown by North Korea is sensible.

    in reply to: Questions About the Hun #2593332
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Hmm, given the sizes of them, I would think the bombs on the outer pylons are 500lb Mk82, middle pylons have Mk84 2000lb bombs, and the inner wing pylons appear to be Mk83 1000lb bombs. Though I may be wrong!

    in reply to: Hypothetical #2593336
    EdLaw
    Participant

    Well, given that Evo Morales has decided that cocaine farming is a good thing, he would probably not have counter-narcotics as a high priority – he would probably want transports to help them!

Viewing 15 posts - 946 through 960 (of 1,259 total)